Why The Confederacy Lost The War

1028 words - 4 pages

Why the Confederacy Lost the War
Many historians have tried to offer their ideology on the outcome of the Civil War. McPherson in his “American Victory, American Defeat” writes about what other historians have decreed their answers to why the Confederacy lost. He tells us the reasons that could not be the explanation for the loss, and explains the internal reasons but leaves the true cause of the loss untold. Freehling explains the defeat by discussing what could have been and then gives reasons to negate some of the cases that he states for the outcome of the Confederacy. Both McPherson and Freehling both agreed that there were other factors besides battles that needed to be looked at.
Each author agreed that the battles were not the only reason for the fall and death of the Confederacy. While battles were being fought on the battlefields, the home fronts were had their own battles to fight. McPherson discusses what he calls as the “internal conflict” thesis, which blames the uneasiness among the southerners. The government was being blamed. Southerners were opposing conscription, taxes, and habeus corpus. McPherson points out that these could not have been reasons for the loss. The same thing was happening in the North. Therefore this internal conflict with the home front government does not have a plausible role in why the South lost the war. If the North was fighting the same type of opposition at home, then shouldn’t the war have ended in a stalemate? Also, the non-slaveholding whites and the slaves were feeling alienated. Rich slaveholders who wanted to keep slave labor alive were fighting the war. The two alienated groups were fighting a war on the wrong side. The non-slaveholders opposed secession. The United States could protect them from the rich plantation owners, the taxes, and the inflation due to a new nation that was not able to survive when it had nothing to start with. Again, though, McPherson says that this could not be the reason either because the same was true during the Revolution, but the fight for independence in the 18th Century was a successful fight. So why couldn’t this fight be one?
Freehling looks at the economical factors of the Confederacy during the war to explain that the home front was not able to withstand the hard times so therefore it flowed into the cause on the battlefield. With many of the plantation owners gone, the wives were left to control the plantation and the slaves. These slaves ran away leaving the fields unworked and soldiers and families hungry. Also the railroads were being destroyed in the west and by Sherman’s March to Sea. Already plagued with low sources of food, the ability to move food to troops was virtually impossible. Freehling believes that military outcomes formed social outcomes (Freehling, 221). I...

Find Another Essay On Why the Confederacy Lost the War

Collapse of the Confederacy from 1864-65

1255 words - 5 pages HIST 4055 (Final Essay/Question 2) 25 June 2010 Collapse of the Confederacy from 1864-65 The collapse of the Confederacy in 1865 was due to a variety of reasons. These issues by and large involved the military along with a dire political and economic situation. The transfer of General Ulysses S. Grant, from the West, with his “aggressive” new war strategy, in addition to, Union General William T. Sherman’s "March to the Sea," and eventual

Why the US lost in Vietnam

1497 words - 6 pages to prevent the South Vietnam government from collapsing, however, the United States ultimately failed to achieve its goal. The North Vietnamese successfully reunited the North and South in 1975. In 1976, they became the Socialist Republic of Vietnam. The United States not only underestimated the enemy, they took the wrong measures to try and accomplish their goals. The state of affairs in Vietnam was a civil war and may have ended in a different way without American intervention.1) "Why We Lost South Vietnam"2006/02/012) "Why US Lost in Vietnam"2006/02/013)"Why US Lost in Vietnam"2006/02/014) "Why US Lost in Vietnam"2006/02/015)"Why US Lost in Vietnam"2006/02/01

How america lost the war in vi

603 words - 2 pages The Vietnam War was the most controversial war in American history. Costing more than 47,000 U.S. lives and $140,000,000, the war had momentous impact on the country, politically, economically, and socially. More significantly, the United States failed to achieve its stated war aims, for the first time in history. The goal was to preserve an independent, noncommunist government in South Vietnam, but by the war's end in 1975, all of Vietnam was

The Vietnam War: How America Lost the War Against Communism

1081 words - 4 pages The Vietnam War was a conflict, which the United States involved itself in unnecessarily and ultimately lost. The basis of the conflict was simple enough: Communism vs. Capitalism, yet the conduct of the Vietnam War was complex and strategic, and brought repercussions which had never been seen before. The struggle between North and South had an almost inevitable outcome, yet the Americans entered the War optimistic that they could aid the

The Lost

1621 words - 7 pages Rarely is there a book such as Dan Brown’s The Lost Symbol, where you will find just the sheer number of conflicts within one piece literary work. These are not just simple problems either but multiple, complex things that involve multiple people and do not get solved in just a page or two. These conflicts are quite possibly the most intriguing and the most difficult kind to get through; these are conflicts of the mind. These are not your

Population, Industry, and Generals – How the Confederacy Survived to 1865

2560 words - 10 pages if it is industrial. War crates jobs in manufacturing and in the military, but takes jobs away from agriculture due to the drafting of soldiers. The Union’s immigrant population solved this problem, however, “Emigration from Europe is already pouring into New York at the rate of 1,000 a day, which will fill the gap made by the war in our labor population” (Catton 414). The Confederacy was not so fortunate, they had trouble replacing lost

Reasons On Why Napoleon Had Lost The Campaign Of 1812

1138 words - 5 pages army with more care and forbearance." pg 255, The Campaign of 1812 in Russia If Napoleon only had at least 300,000 men, he could have waited for supplies with the comfort of knowing that he was safe. Instead, Napoleon retreated and allowed his army to slowly wither under the attack of the Russian guerrillas.Therefore I have shown some reasons why Napoleon had lost the Campaign of 1812 to Russia. However, Napoleon did not lose the war out of

Why the Spanish Armada Invaded Britain and Lost

1166 words - 5 pages Spanish Armada Essay In this essay I am going to look at why the Spanish armada wanted to invade Britain and why they failed to do so, was it down to luck or were the British too smart for the Spanish. And was it all England's glory? The Spanish wanted to invade England was mainly to turn England back into a catholic country, and to get Queen Elizabeth of the throne and to get a queen who was for the catholic monarch on the throne. However

Population, Industry, and Generals: How the Confederacy Survived to 1865

1266 words - 5 pages . The war was pre-ordained from the beginning, as the Union had most of the country’s infrastructure, was much wealthier, had more metal deposits, and was larger. The Confederacy had more military colleges and a brilliant military commander. This was enough to win the early battles, but fell apart once the Confederacy suffered economic collapse, was cut in twain, and was put under a blockade. This blockade that ended hope of a Confederate

Why The Civil War Started?

723 words - 3 pages For a long time, historians have been unable to come to an agreement to why the Civil War started and whether or not it was repressible or irrepressible. Northern and Southern writers had different opinions as to why the war occurred. To most Northern writers, the war occurred because of the unlawful plan of slave owners who were committed to a not liable institution. The North defended the Constitution and was against the immoral aggression of

Answers the question "Why War?"

622 words - 2 pages their other older brother goes just to watch after them. Two different reasons to fight, two different reasons to die. Now perhaps the younger brothers were power hungry, and wanted to kill to feel supreme? On the other hand, maybe it was the convincing of the government to make it seem so appealing to go off and fight on their battlefields.Now I feel all of this is justified in Freud's "Why War", "The individual in any given nation has in this

Similar Essays

Why Germany Lost The First World War

698 words - 3 pages The First World War was one of the most horrifying the world has ever seen. Lasting between 1914 and 1918 the impact is such that many of the repercussions can still be seen as late on as today. The allied nations defeated Germany after 4 years of war and thousands of deaths, this essay will help to explain some of the reasons why this was the case.There were numerous reasons behind why Germany eventually lost the war. Probably the most

The Defeat Of The Confederacy Essay

2037 words - 8 pages resources and the fact that foreign recognition was denied the Confederacy. Why did the South lose? When the question is asked that way, it presupposes that the South lost the war all by itself and that it really never could have won it. The South lost because the North outmanned and outclassed it at almost every point, even militarily (Donald, 1996, pp. 99-100). The North was able to bring its industry and its manpower to bear in such a way

How The Usa Lost The Vietnam War

2793 words - 11 pages Robert S. McNamara, appointed by John F. Kennedy to the position of U.S. Secretary of Defense in 1961, said about the Vietnam War, “It is important to recognize it’s a South Vietnamese war. It will be won or lost depending upon what they do. We can advise and help, but they are responsible for the final results, and it remains to be seen how they will continue to conduct that war,'; (McNamara 72). Despite these guidelines

How The Usa Lost The Vietnam War

1053 words - 4 pages Since the civil war in the United States there have been many events that could be described as having the biggest impact on our national identity. There are countless ways that the American people have evolved since then. To me, there is no stronger test of a country’s unity and ability to succeed under pressure than war. The United States has weathered many wars and has gone back to help save the countries they defeated. World War 1