What Is A Monster? Essay

1045 words - 4 pages

Peter Brooks' essay "What Is a Monster" tackles many complex ideas within Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, and the main concept that is the title of the essay itself. What is the definition of a monster, or to be monstrous? Is a monster the classic representation we know, green skin, neck bolts, grunting and groaning? A cartoon wishing to deliver sugary cereal? or someone we dislike so greatly their qualities invade our language and affect our interpretation of their image and physical being? Brooks' essay approaches this question by using Shelley's narrative structure to examine how language, not nature, is mainly accountable for creating the idea of the monstrous body.
Brooks begins his argument by analyzing the relationships of the novel and how they build tension between the characters. He speaks to how the narrative frame itself positions the reader to "supplement" the story of the "speaker", which in the case of Frankenstein is both the text itself and the individual narration of the characters. Most importantly, he sets up how Frankenstein's narrative frame, essentially a series of conversations relating one characters unresolved issues to another, begins creating the concept of the monster. Creation of the monstrous, in the idea of Brooks happens solely through language, a medium deemed corrupt and insufficient. This is the source of the monstrous, as Brooks reveals that through the Monster's exposure to the world, he no longer takes part in the imaginary order as he finds that he cannot be accepted on appearance alone, and instead uses language as a tool to express his desires.
However, this proves to be insufficient, as once the monster uses the symbolic power of language, an expression of the conscious, he no longer can quantify what his desire actually is. By using language to express his desires, and knowing that he is using language as the ends to a mean, he is creating an excess of meaning that has no direct tie to a signified any longer - there is too much signification and no signifier. Actual unconscious desire that the Monster seeks is not apparent to him, and that lack of meaning tied to one's desire is passed on through his plea to his creator, Victor Frankenstein. Subsequently this "lack" of meaning touches Victor's tale to Walton, and finally the reader as a surrogate receiving Walton's letters to his absent sister. The Monster becomes a symbol (and signifier) of the detachment from unconscious desire (the signified) created by language and relationships, a "monster" in the truest sense of the form, signifying deficiency and the unnatural, an object beyond comprehension and meaning itself. By extending beyond meaning, the Monster no longer is part of an interlocutionary relationship, but a symbol to be discussed, viewed, and compared.
Brooks' argument takes a firm look at the text and how it uses language to position the internal mechanics of desire. Since what we desire is no longer part of our vocabulary in language, we...

Find Another Essay On What Is A Monster?

What Is A Hero? Essay

2418 words - 10 pages The Value of Heroic Nature: Ancient versus ModernWhat is heroism? Is it being able to slaughter an entire army singlehandedly? Is it being a good father to your children? Or is it being able to do what is right, even if the choice is hard to make? The Oxford English Dictionary defines being heroic as "Of or pertaining to a hero or heroes; characteristic of, or suitable to the character of a hero; of a bravery, virtue, or nobleness of character

What Is A Counsellor? Essay

944 words - 4 pages What is a Counsellor? Introduction After reading, viewing, thinking and talking over this question, I came up with the following two informal attempts at defining what a counsellor is.1. A counsellor is someone who (by agreement) helps another in the process of sorting out a problem. To put it another way, counselling is an interaction between two people where a person who is trying to sort something out, uses the help of another.2. A counsellor

What is a Portrait

913 words - 4 pages What is a portrait? Portraits are one of most common forms of photography. However, “what is a portrait?” is such a vague question because a portrait could be defined as many things. An official dictionary definition of the word describes a portrait as “a painting, drawing, photograph, or engraving of a person, especially one depicting only the face or head and shoulders (Merriam Webster).” The photographer’s aim is to give prominence to the

What Is A Hero?

667 words - 3 pages What is a Hero? In today's world the news media throw the word around like it is an everyday word. So what exactly is a hero? Who or can be classified as a heroic? The correct definition of a hero is: One invested with heroic qualities in the opinion of others. That definition is for books and intellectual minds, but to an average person like me a hero is much more than just that. First, to understand what a hero is, we must find

What is a Phobia?

1011 words - 5 pages There are many, many different phobias in the world. Some ranging from claustrophobia, the fear of enclosed spaces, to agoraphobia, the fear of open spaces, however these little “fears” control these people’s lives. What we look at as just a normal day, they wake up worrying about ways to cope with this obsession. What causes phobias? What is a phobia? And how do we cure them? What is a phobia? A phobia is classified as a

What Is A Man?

1126 words - 5 pages value of his life, and how much he affects the people around him. In his diary, he writes: “good by mr wigin tell them im strong tell them im a man” (Gaines 234). With the help of Grant, Jefferson grows to understand that he is not an animal, but a man. He realizes that if he stood up for what he believed in, then no one can tell him he cannot do something; and the only person who can bring him down is himself. A man never blames someone else for

what is a hero?

471 words - 2 pages Random House 255 West 45th Street New York, NY 10022 To Random House Editorial Review Board: What is a hero? Everyone's vision is somewhat different. To me, a hero is someone whom I can look up to as a role model for something he or she has accomplished. These might include tasks that were performed with bravery and unselfishness. This is why I propose to you to enter into Tom Brokaw's new book titled, The Millenium Generation, a person who had

What is a Friend?

615 words - 2 pages What is a friend? A friend is someone who supports you, sympathizes with you, or patronizes a group. An easily definition of that would be a person you know, like and trust. In these tough times we count on friend to help us get through. I like to think of friendship as everlasting, but is friendship truly forever? Can miles drive you away from friends you made after graduating from places like high school or college? Just imagine walking

What is a Miracle?

1001 words - 4 pages (a) What is meant by the term miracle? (4 marks) A miracle can be defined as, `a transgression of a law of nature by a particular violation of a deity," Hume. It describes supernatural events, which defy the universal laws of nature. This could be a man rising from the ground against the law of gravity. J.L. Mackie has a similar point of view and suggests that miracles occur when the world is interfered with, by something that is not of

What is a Mother?

1224 words - 5 pages The definition of the word “mother” according to the dictionary is “a female parent,” (“Mother,” 2011) but the way society views a mother is more. A mother isn’t simply a woman who gave birth to a child, but a woman who can raise, comfort, and care for their child. A mother’s job changes depending on what social standing they are in and what time they live in. Because of the different social classes and time periods Daisy and Ma live in

What is a Community?

1329 words - 5 pages , and thus no two communities are the same; even a given community is not the same over time (Cnaan & Milofsky, p. 1) Based on this definition it is interesting to note that the Old Order Amish Mennoite community satisfies the requirements of place, interests and communion. Aside from being a perfect example of a community the Amish people exemplify what it means to be a part of a community that it is their source of identity, strength, and

Similar Essays

What Makes A Monster Nature Vs Nurture In Mary Shelleys Frankenstein

840 words - 4 pages For nearly 2 centuries Mary Shelleys Frankenstein has been considered by many to be the ultimate human vs monster conflict. However what makes someone a “monster”? Appearance? Character traits? Since the creature was born as an outsider humans neglected him and he becomes malicious. In the beginning an overly ambitious victor creates an imperfect creature. Since he is neglected by his creator as he is born an outsider he faces societies shunning

According To Mary Shelley Who Is More Of A 'monster', Frankenstein Or His Creation?

3688 words - 15 pages 'Frankenstein's' writing its meaning was quite different. In earlier usage a monster is 'someone or something to be shown' Shelley uses both definitions in order to blur the fine line between what is considered to be monstrous and what is considered humane. Shelley also uses multiple narrators to further this effect.Mary Shelley creates many differences between Victor Frankenstein and his creation, but simultaneously creates parallels between the

Who Is More To Blame For What Happens In The Novel: Frankenstein Or The Monster? (Frankenstein By Mary Shelley)

1323 words - 5 pages Who is more to Blame for what Happens in the Novel: Frankenstein or the Monster?In Mary Shelley's novel Frankenstein, the main character Victor Frankenstein, becomes obsessed with the notion of bringing a human being to life. The result is the creation of a monster only known to us as 'the monster'. The monster is hideous, and is therefore rejected by Victor and by society to fend for himself. He soon commits many murders, as a result of his

"Monster: An Autobiography Of An La Gang Member" Included Is Works Cited This Paper Was Only Written For A 200 Level English Class Analyze The Representation Of Violence In One Scene In "Monster"

929 words - 4 pages graphic word choices Kody Scott is able to paint a very graphic picture throughout his book, but especially throughout the gang initiation scene. He is able to describe what is taking place by using different types of imagery, similes, metaphors, and onomatopoeias. This proved to be very effective because it allowed the reader get a clear picture of what gang life will be like for Scott. Scott's imagery also is helpful in putting the audience into the atmosphere and into his shoes to feel his pain.WORKS CITEDScott, Kody. Monster: The Autobiography of an L.A. Gang Member. Penguin Books: New York, NY. 1994.