Two Women Confined Essay

679 words - 3 pages

Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants,” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” are about two women who find themselves confined in different ways in their lives. One feels a strong sense of commitment to a man who appears to have her best interest at heart and the other feels bonded within a loveless marriage.

The Short Story “Hills Like White Elephants”, possibly set in the 1960’s, depicts a couple, waiting for a train, while traveling through Spain, having a discussion about, what the American describes as ‘an awfully simple operation’ for the girl who he refers to as Jig. Although it is never confirmed, the ‘awfully simple operation’ best describes an abortion. It appears as though the American feels that their carefree way of life will be greatly impeded with the addition of a baby. Yet, more than once, he makes the statement that he ‘doesn’t want her to do anything she doesn’t want to do.” However, he also says that he doesn’t want anybody but her. He doesn’t want anyone else. His contradictions causes Jig to remain unsure of her decision. She continues to glance at the scenery surrounding the train station as she contemplates her decision. There’s a certain amount of freedom that comes with having an abortion. There’s the freedom from being entirely responsible for another life and the ability to continue the nomad lifestyle with her lover and traveling companion. If she chooses to keep the baby she may jeopardize losing her lover and her life will be drastically altered forever. Neither choice will give her total freedom. If she chooses to have the operation she will continue to be influenced by the man in future decisions. If she chooses to keep the baby she will lose the man and be sole caretaker of a baby.

Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” is set in the 1800’s. The main character, Louise Mallard, is ‘afflicted with a heart...

Find Another Essay On Two Women Confined

The Domesticity Of Giraffes By Judith Beveridge

684 words - 3 pages society. The poet illustrates the giraffe as constantly confined in captivity; this is similar to that of housewives’ confinement to their homes. As they do not have any freedom nor any independence, both the housewives and the giraffe are seen as powerless. As a result, readers gain a broader perspective into the social powerlessness of women as drawn through the giraffe.The ideas of power and powerlessness are accentuated through the use of

Evolution of Women’s Roles From the 1500’s to Today

1038 words - 5 pages considered subordinate to men” (Women Today 01) and did not have the same rights. Men were in charge of doing laborious jobs and bringing in money for their families, while women had two basic roles: taking care of the home and the kids. Of course, taking care of the home was an enormous responsibility when paired with raising numerous kids - Men often thought that the women had it easy compared to them. At that point in time, female children

The Evolution of the Image of Women in Sports

1077 words - 4 pages the images of women in sports have changed drastically throughout the twentieth century. The women in Bend it Like Beckham had to deal with cultural stereotypes against women in sport. Jess' mother had strictly confined ideas of how a woman should look. She did not approve of Jess playing soccer, but if she did it was important for her to keep her legs covered. The issue that comes up repeatedly in this movie is the popular notion that women

Analyse the effect of women of Australia during the 20th century

597 words - 2 pages During the 1900's, women had a vigorous thought to break through their confined lives at home. Since then the lives of woman has had a dramatic change. From the 1950's to 1990's I will describe how a simple housewife evolves through decades to become a woman at the workforce. They have been through a lot in the society to have gained such recognition and status.Throughout the 1950's, Australia declared a principle that 'woman's place is in the

Religion as a Method of Improvement for Gender Equality

1950 words - 8 pages no real rights. Although Greek drama portrayed many strong, remarkable women, like Antigone, what women in Greece actually experienced was much different. The role of free women in Athens, and many other places in Greece, was confined to the private sphere of the household. Women were restricted to childbearing and supervising the work done in the household; a woman’s value was based on her ability to produce legitimate heirs and to be a

The Need to Eliminate the Abusive Treatment of Muslim Women

824 words - 3 pages The Need to Eliminate the Abusive Treatment of Muslim Women Thirty thousand men and boys poured into the dilapidated Olympic sports stadium in Kabul, capital of Afghanistan. Street hawkers peddle nuts, biscuits and tea to the waiting crowd. The scheduled entertainment? They were there to see a young woman, Sohaila, receive 100 lashes, and to watch two thieves have their hands chopped off. Sohaila had been arrested while walking with a man

Social Confinement in Austen’s Sense and Sensibility

1291 words - 6 pages position of women in most of her novels, her early work Sense and Sensibility, is perhaps the most interesting to take into consideration when reviewing the issue of confinement. In it Austen juxtaposes the freedom of the countryside exteriors with the confinement of the city’s interiors. These settings serve as a backdrop for the exploration of two female characters whose social status has been set back as a result of the primogeniture of the time

Women in "The Merchant of Venice"

701 words - 3 pages her time and Portia and Jessica's characters wouldn't be appreciated as powerful ones if we couldn't compare them with an ordinary woman like Nerissa. Nerissa is not as initiative as the other two women of the play in deviating from conventions, yet she proves that every woman can just follow their examples and succeed. Shakespear presents women as powerful and smart as men and even bettering "The Merchant of Venice" and gives each female character a role to complement those of the other two. Portia, Jessica,and Nerissa, together, introduce a new definition of women's real identity to the male dominated society of the Elizabethan time.

The Power Struggles in Jury of Her Peers and Mama Come Home

1184 words - 5 pages begin with, “A Jury of her Peers” is about the way women in 1917 were treated by men. The main women characters are Minnie Wright, Mrs. Peters, and Mrs. Hale. The women in the story are confined to their homes; rarely getting to go to town or visit with their friends. The women did not have many things with color and beauty. The men looked down on the women as inferior. The women in the story are the subordinates and the men are the dominants

Rape As Fierce

1247 words - 5 pages , feminist are trying hard to ensure women right. Many laws has been passed to stop oppression. Sometimes, lack of security cause the to confined into household, but it cannot diminish violence against women. Rape in happening because of low social values towards women, man’s dominant mentality and lower social protest against rapist because of “blaming the victim” mentality. Firstly, women are considered inferior and are not treated with enough

The Oppressed Female in Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre

978 words - 4 pages . Through the depictions of the incarcerated female, Brontë speaks on the ills of an unjust society. Brontë's representation of Bertha as a wild, chained, and trapped animal and the symbolic use of fire reflect the difficulties women had in expressing their sexuality in an era in which men dominated and in which women played the role of the obedient, confined, and inferior being.   Works Cited and Consulted: Brontë, Charlotte.  Jane

Similar Essays

Mental And Physical Confinement Of Women

879 words - 4 pages In the “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Gilman and “The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin, the female characters are confined mentally and physically. In the 1890’s, when these stories were written, women did not have a role in society. A woman’s role in the house involved cleaning and keeping up the house, taking care of the children, and making a meal three times a day. The man’s role was to go out and work to make money for his family. He

The Ideal Victorian Woman: "Jane Eyre" By Charlotte Bronte

979 words - 4 pages -room (5)." Jane is figuratively confined from being an independent person by Mrs. Reed because it was "unacceptable" behavior.After Jane leaves Gateshead she attends a strict boarding school, Lowood (34). Lowood is a school for orphan girls and is operated by rigid Mr. Brocklehurst. Mr. Brocklehurst keeps all the girls in the school very contained and gives them virtually no rights and sets standards that allow for no individuality. The school

Women Of World War 2 Essay

1280 words - 6 pages Women Of World War 2 When speaking of women's roles, the initial thought is the things done at home, their unpaid domestic labour. But women actually played a vital part in their country's success in world war two. The war started a new era for women's opportunities to contribute to the country. By 1945, over 2.2 million women were working in war industries, constructing ships, weaponry, and aircrafts, women also worked in factories, farms

Analysis Of The Yellow Wallpaper By Charlotte Gilman

1019 words - 4 pages strong imagery throughout "The Yellow Wallpaper" to set the scene for the story and foreshadow the certain madness that is to come of the narrator. As the story progresses, so does the woman's declining mental status. An example of how imagery is used to display the inferiority of women is the fact that the woman in the story is confined to the old nursery room for most of her time. Gilman describes the room as "It was nursery first and then