The Straight State: Sexuality And Citizenship In Twentieth Century America

1495 words - 6 pages

In the United States of America, three campaigns for civil rights dominated the twentieth century. Firstly, women fought for the right to vote during the suffrage years, claiming victory with the ratification of the nineteenth amendment to the Constitution in 1920. Secondly, Native Americans – or “Indians” to some – finally attained citizenship rights in 1924, when President Coolidge signed the Indian Citizenship Act. Thirdly, African Americans fought against segregation and miscegenation, winning both of those battles in landmark Supreme Court cases. However, these victories were not the be-all-end-all; each of the aforementioned groups continues to battle for equality and social ...view middle of the document...

She believes that these three areas set the stage for the homosexual garnering the label of “anti-citizen,” and argues that this continues to be the case, well into the twenty-first century.
Canaday divides the book into two parts. She calls the first “Nascent Policing,” and the second “Explicit Regulation.” Each part implicitly links to the other, as Canaday makes use of this two-part structure to show the interconnectedness of the bureaucratic elements she wishes to expose. She specifically argues that the development of the modern state ran parallel to the regulation of sexuality. She argues, “Homosexuality went from a total nonentity to a commonly understood category in the same years that the Federal government went from a fledgling to a full-service bureaucracy” (p. 258). During this time, the state had consistently attempted to control and punish homosexuals. She believes that by doing so, the state constructed an inherently homophobic society.
At its core, Canaday’s study aims to bring together the social, cultural, political, and legal aspects of American life in order to change the way people think about the past issues of the homosexual population. In her book, she claims her research will do just that. She believes that the fears brought about by McCarthyism skewed the way Americans viewed the issue, and that the emphasis on the “nuclear family” led to the continued demonization of the homosexual as an affront to the American dream.
According to Canaday, the United States fashioned a social tie between citizenship and homosexuality, which is evident through its policy history. These policies “established individuals who exhibited gender inversion or engaged in homoerotic behavior as either outside of or degraded within citizenship” (p. 13). Although there was surely homophobia in the years prior to World War 1, Canaday uses this time as a focal point for when systematic oppression of homosexuals began. The military was the first branch of Canaday’s “bureaucracy” that systematically began oppressing and weeding out homosexuals. Psychiatric examinations of potential soldiers during the war looked for “abnormalities,” which Canaday claims was a euphemism for homosexuality (p. 14). The most overt and intriguing policies occurred during World War 2, when the state denied soldiers suspected of homosexuality the advantages promised to them by the G.I. bill. So engrained were these policies into the daily operations of the military that during the early fifties, military policing of homosexuality began to heavily influence outside federal policies (like immigration).
Canaday is an obvious feminist, as her politics are clear from the very introduction to the book. Because of this, she focuses much on the systematic distinctions made between male homosexuals and female homosexuals. With regard to the military, she notes the different policies and emphasis placed on lesbians, arguing that these distinctions were sexist...

Find Another Essay On The Straight State: Sexuality and Citizenship in Twentieth Century America

Women in the Twentieth Century Essay

931 words - 4 pages After the success of antislavery movement in the early nineteenth century, activist women in the United States took another step toward claiming themselves a voice in politics. They were known as the suffragists. It took those women a lot of efforts and some decades to seek for the ratification of the Nineteenth Amendment. In her essay “The Next Generation of Suffragists: Harriot Stanton Blatch and Grassroots Politics,” Ellen Carol Dubois notes

Citizens as Consumers: Modernism and Convenience in the Twentieth Century

1835 words - 8 pages Convenience and efficiency became the raison d’être of the twentieth century. As the burgeoning markets of industrialism led to the shopping markets of consumerism, Washington, D.C. and Paris, France were competing to be the newest and the most efficient. As the cities became more efficient, they also became more automated: both in their infrastructure and in their denizens. It’s the nature of a city to be a hive for large numbers of people

Advances in Cloning in the Twentieth Century

1179 words - 5 pages loning may sound like science fiction, but it is very real. There were many advances in cloning in the twentieth century. The climax was when scientists successfully cloned a sheep in 1996.(11) Advances stopped when scientists asked themselves whether or not it is ethical to attempt to clone a human. The same question is asked 
of lawmakers today. The debate is a very complicated and is one that could change the course of our society. The United

The architectural movement in the twentieth century

1086 words - 4 pages future. (Woods, 2007)2.0 The architectural movement in the twentieth centuryIn the twentieth century, the transition of the architectural styles from one another reflects the art, cultures, technology and the people. Fragments & frictions of the transition in the architectural movement from Art Nouveau to Post-Modernism show the beautiful world of architecture in this time period.2.1 Art Nouveau & Art DecoArt Nouveau was the first stage

Women’s Groups In The Twentieth-Century

1482 words - 6 pages women when he appointed Madeline Albright to Secretary of State. Life for women in America keeps getting better. Life for women in 2013 is much different than it was for her counterpart in the 1900s, a life that was made possible by the contribution of numerous women’s groups. Women activists didn’t only focus on women’s causes; they were also participants in child labor laws and the Civil Rights movement. The 21st century has brought the

Dance In The Early Twentieth Century

1928 words - 8 pages The history of Jazz music is one that is tied to enslavement, and prejudices, and it is impossible to separate the development of Jazz music from the racial oppression that occurred in the United States as they are inextricably connected. Slavery was a part of our country’s development that is shameful and yet, lead to some of the greatest musical advances of the twentieth century. Slavery in the United States first began in 1619 when Dutch

Portrayal of Women in the Twentieth Century

1050 words - 4 pages The role of females during much of the Twentieth Century is domestic. Two well-known authors during this time period have conflicting views of how women fulfill these roles. In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby and John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath, the women portray two very different perspectives on the roles of women within families and the values they instill within their families. The value the women share about money is one of

Propaganda in the Early Twentieth Century

951 words - 4 pages the recipient and provoke an almost primal thought process, leaving normal reasoning behind. It is the goal of the propagandists to put those viewing it under an almost mental spell or even in a brain washed state. This quote from Bertrand Russell exemplifies this notion, “You must not kill your neighbor, whom perhaps you genuinely hate, but by a little propaganda this hate can be transferred to some foreign nation, against whom all your murderous

JRR Tolkien and the Twentieth Century

2285 words - 9 pages The early twentieth century saw an upheaval of normal life in Europe because of the Great War and the changing political and social systems. In the midst of this time, JRR Tolkien found himself transformed from a young student at Oxford to a soldier in the British army as war broke out across the continent. This war affected his life deeply, whether indirectly while he was at Oxford or through his time in the trenches in direct combat. As a

Economic Expansion in the Late Nineteenth Century and Early Twentieth Century

890 words - 4 pages Economic expansion in the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century was driven by economic expansion and sole beliefs. In the past the United States was an agricultural nation and based there economy on farming. Since the United States based there economy on farming they need to expand was necessary for the country to grow. However as time went on the slow transition between farming to big business changed the motives for America’s

HIST415 Vietnam and the Twentieth Century

693 words - 3 pages It is both necessary and helpful to study the context of prior history because it reveals who we are in relation to other people, cultures, and countries. Exploring the history of different peoples and cultures experiences provides a clearer picture of their views, beliefs, feelings, and opinions. History is a story told from a political and educational style. Learning how the past shaped a country and the leaders that had a part in it helps us

Similar Essays

The Pre Twentieth Century Gorkha State Essay

1104 words - 4 pages The pre-twentieth century Gorkha state can be thought of us segmentary in Aidan Southall’s sense as opposed to a unitary state, which is more common in modern twenty first century western states, as vectors of power and identity, as expressed through political sovereignty and ritual suzerainty, don’t overlap. A core component of segmentary state is the incorporation Karl Marx’s proposed Asiatic mode of production, in which the king maintains a

Steamer Trunks And Social Class In Late Nineteenth Century And Early Twentieth Century America

690 words - 3 pages Dating back to the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, steamships were ideal for travel. Steamships were wildly popular during this time because they were an advanced transportation that was more efficient than a railroad because it traveled across sea. The steamboat helped advance trade along the Mississippi and brought new towns, new industry, and new jobs. During this time, America was divided into social classes based on social

Italy In The Twentieth Century Essay

764 words - 3 pages Italy in the Twentieth Century Only thirty years after the Piedmontese army marched into Rome to unite Italy under one government, the country suddenly found itself on the brink of the twentieth century and a rapidly changing world. The twentieth century would mark the beginning of great changes throughout Europe, and Italy would not be left untouched. What set the stage for these changes, though, were the years just prior to, and

Canada In The Twentieth Century Essay

606 words - 2 pages the electricity use in poorer countries around the globe.In conclusion, I belief that I have clearly stated my position on the Canadian foreign policy. Canada's foreign policy should be based to the significant extent on global concerns. Canada in the twentieth century will have a unique identity all over the globe.