The Role Of History And Memory In The Fiftieth Gate, Schindler's List, And The Send Off

1114 words - 4 pages

The strong relationship created between history and memory is one of a vexing nature due to deliberate selection and emphasis. It does however result in a confluence of different representations, that is, personal stories (memory) and public stories (history). Mark Baker’s biography and autobiography ‘The Fiftieth Gate: A Journey Through Memory’, explores his parents’ memories which are both verified and contradicted by Baker’s historical findings, as each asserts their claim through these different theories of representation drawing on such established criteria as evidence, accuracy, authenticity, authority and detail. Steven Spielberg’s horror-psychological thriller film, ‘Schindler’s List’ shows how amongst the abhorrence of the Holocaust, one man can make a difference for the better and leave a legacy of his generosity but it is also a question of what else he did that wasn’t emphasised due to the context of the film. Lastly, the poem ‘The Send-Off’ by Wilfred Owen expresses Owen’s personal feelings towards war which is enunciated through his strong emotive language.

Mark Baker’s ‘The Fiftieth Gate’ creates a struggle between memory and history as each represents the Holocaust but through different means of representation. The language of memory is partial, subjective, and emotional and experiences confusion and doubts. Baker provides the historical facts of the Aktions and slave-labour camps in historian terms, that of numbers of deaths, survivors and prisoners, and is criticised by his parents. “Fecks, fecks” Joe says dismissively and Genia describes his work as “shopping lists”. This demonstrates how Baker believed his parents’ pasts were represented through history, and Joe and Genia felt their experiences were represented through memory. It is the contrast between the cold facts of history and the intimate details of survival that gives ‘The Fiftieth Gate’ its meaning. Baker uses the technique of polyphony, having originally been inspired by the form of the Jewish Talmud, to allow the story to be told from each person’s perspective and personal experiences. At times the voices compete against each other, which is shown through Mark Baker’s many voices, and include his voice as a historian, son, storyteller and Jewish intellectual. As a historian he seeks the ‘truth’ which can be no absolute version, for example he instantaneously believes Elzbieta’s version of his mother’s hiding over his own mother’s story, and also aims for objectivity, accuracy and validity while always trying to find proof. Baker’s voice as a historian can be challenged by his voice as a son. This voice involves his personal interpretations and has emotional attachment as he wishes to record his parents’ stories for the future and understand their past while also protecting them. This protection affects the context as it results in deliberate selection and emphasis, with the emphasis been on their sufferings and particular discoveries been left out which includes...

Find Another Essay On The Role of History and Memory in The Fiftieth Gate, Schindler's List, and The Send Off

A description of the movie "Schindler's List" as well as character analysis and theme of the movie

1436 words - 6 pages shovel snow and the Nazi soldier's pick the one armed man out of the line. They also think he is useless and he tries to explain that he is one of Schindler's workers, and that he is very useful. The soldier's laugh at him and shoot him in the back of the head. Schindler wants some compensation for the lost worker but is asked how useful the man was since he only had one arm. Schindler explained that he was a skilled metal worker and that he

The Relationship of Photographs, History, and Memory

5350 words - 21 pages -collections of the past. This essay is about photography, memory, and history and addresses the relationship between photographic images and the need to remember; it is based on the notion that seeing is a prelude to historical knowledge and that understanding the past relies on the ability to imagine. At the same time, the role of thought and imagination in the production of society--as reflected in the earlier work of Louis Althusser (1970), Maurice

Compare and Contrast the Way in Which Poets Present Ideas About Soldiers Leaving for War in Joining the Colours and The Send Off

1053 words - 4 pages rhyme scheme is also very simple and consistent, following an ABAB scheme. The constant rhythm and regularity of the verses gives the effect of soldiers marching. This is ironic, as although the scene is a jolly one, the rhythm contrasts with the poets feelings of sadness and despair. The rhyme scheme in 'The Send Off' is also very regular, although the lines vary in length and the verses are split into two and three lines. Owen also uses enjambment

The History of the Golden Gate Bridge

1461 words - 6 pages Stretching across the San Francisco Bay stands the world famous Golden Gate Bridge. The bridge is located in one of nature’s most beautiful settings, spanning the mile-wide bay from Fort Point in San Francisco to the Marin County Shore. Joseph Strauss, specializing in bridge building, was the leader of the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge. The start of construction began on January 5, 1993 and, after four years, was completed on April 27

Oskar Schindler and Schindler's List

1637 words - 7 pages Holocaust. An interview with Sir Ben Kingsley gives an in-depth look at how he felt portraying Itzak Stern in Schindler's List. In the interview he talks about how nervous he was to accept the role of Itzak Stern and how he wasn't sure what the “narrative function” of the character would be. When he met with Steven Spielberg and asked him Spielberg replies “well he's the witness to the story”. So they made the decision the Sir Kingsley would

The Holocaust: As depicted through the movie Schindler's List. How Schindler risked his own life, how was a hero, and how he protected the lives of the innocent

1043 words - 4 pages possibly been out for personal wealth because he became poor in the process of saving lives and he could not be an exploiter of slave workers because he made little money off of his factory. In addition, Oscar was aware of and did not acquiesce with the Nazi's plans and even fled the country when his crimes of aiding the proletariats were made known. Thus, he could not be seen as a bad antagonist, only as the one who liberated the Jews from their

Conpare/contract paper about the role of religion in The Jilting of Granny Weatherall and The Man to Send Rain Clouds

841 words - 3 pages Joe Van LanenMay 6, 2004EN 135J.K. RayThe Jilting of Granny Weatherall and The Man to SendRain Clouds both deal with people's attitudes towardsreligion and the role of in people's lives. Write a paperdiscussing the role of religion in these two stories.ReligionIn both stories The Man to Send Rain Clouds and TheJiltingof Granny Weatherall religion plays a large part inthe lives of the characters, but in death it takes an evenmore central role.In

Forgiveness and Forgetting in Schindler's List and Elie Wiesel's Night

1079 words - 4 pages camps. Schindler's List, another story in the form of a movie produced by Steven Spielberg, illustrates the transformation of a German profiteer into a passionate man. The three main characters in Night and Schindler's List represent the unwilling forgiver as Elie Wiesel, the forgiven as Oskar Schindler and the barbaric murderer as Amon Goeth.Night begins with Elie Wiesel expressing interest and intense faith in the Jewish religion and their God

“Heritage, Memory and Reconciliation: Central Concepts and Methods in the Study and Dissemination of Church History“

623 words - 3 pages “Heritage, Memory and Reconciliation: Central Concepts and Methods in the Study and Dissemination of Church History“ The paper’s point of departure is the separation between the Church of Sweden and the Swedish state. Nordback will discuss church history’s role within the Swedish higher education system. She will explain how and why the discipline’s conditions are changing and give some examples of theoretical and methodological trends that can

Freud and Nietzsche - An Account For The Role Of Memory In Our Lives

1208 words - 5 pages One of the main concerns of contemporary philosophy has been the role of the memory in the life of the individual and the group, or more precisely - the lack and excess of memory. Memory is something very unreliable, because it causes the same kind of decay that invades our physical bodies, undermining the identity of every individual and every society. Even though human identity is based on historical memory, neither individuals, nor societies

Masterpiece or moral authority; analysing the critical receptions of Spielberg's Schindler's List (1993)

2026 words - 8 pages historical voyeurism. The critical reception of Schindler's List is a intellectual discussion on the moral nature of a film through the ability to dramatize what was deemed impossible; critically selectively received with a social conscious, and a division on Spielberg's stylistic representation of the subject matter. The scholarship on Schindler's List only reaches one shared thesis that of its transitional nature in his cinematic career into a more

Similar Essays

Representations Of History And Memory In Mark Baker's 'the Fiftieth Gate' And David Olere's Painting 'the Massacre Of The Innocents'

1364 words - 6 pages History and memory are depicted through human attitudes and behaviours. The way that History is shaped and represented impacts on our response to events of the past and memory is vital to this equation in order to fully understand history and appreciate the past. The representation of History and memory in Mark Baker's 'The Fiftieth Gate' (TFG) justifys Yossl, Genia and Baker's attitudes and behaviours. We are made aware of this through

Focussing On The Fiftieth Gate, A Novel By Mark Baker, Explain The Difference Between History And Memory, And Explain Whether One Is More Valid Than The Other. Other Support Material Included

1403 words - 6 pages History can be viewed as a sequential series of indisputable events, whereas memory is of such events that are highly subjective, and affect the way in which they are perceived. The link between history and memory, and the way the human experiences it, is a component of past and present. We are shown this throughout the prescribed text "The Fiftieth Gate", where, through Baker's quest, we see the past continually impacting on the present, as the

History And Memory: "The Fifieth Gate" By Mark Baker

1405 words - 6 pages Mark Baker, in 'The Fiftieth Gate' exposes the true values of both history and memory in determining truth and meaning. Baker, in 'The Fiftieth Gate', disputes the classical view that history is of more importance than memory, instead he argues that history and memory are of equal importance. Baker explores the traditional views of history and memory that are: History is the branch of knowledge that records and researches past events, while

The Message Of Courage In Schindler's List By Thomas Keneally

1349 words - 5 pages The Message of Courage in Schindler's List by Thomas Keneally Throughout the novel of Schindler’s List, by Thomas Keneally, the message of courage is portrayed greatly. Keneally was a gentile man who wrote about how bad the Holocaust was, even-though he was not Jewish. He tells a story of how one man successfully saved thousands of Jews by letting them work for him. Keneally wrote about how helping someone pays off and by letting someone