The Problem With Lecturing: A Rhetorical Analysis

1395 words - 6 pages

When I first read the title of the article “The Problem with Lecturing” I was immediately drawn to the subject at hand. Being a student who has struggled in the past with the teaching method of lecture classes, I was curious as of what aspect Emily Hanford was going to write about. I was curious to see what appeal she would use to make her point. Would she use ethos, logos, pathos or a combination of all three? And at what point would her kairos moments appear. To my delight, Emily touched base on may different aspect of the problem with lecturing including, but not limited to, testing understanding once lectured (ethos), professors taking the matter to heart of its lack of effectiveness (pathos) , and the importance of professors changing the way they teach/lecture in a classroom setting(logos). Hanford also remarked that Professors have long been aware of the problem with lecturing student, but most are not sure of how to make the needed change. While others feel there is no need make changes to what is, as they believe is “working well”. This last statement however was not clear as what she was trying to convey in her article, which may leave the readers confused of what her actual point is. For example is she looking for a change or is she just expressing an issue that exists.
In the following paragraph, we will investigate Emily Hanford background and how it can be used as ethos toward her article. Hanford is an Education Correspondent who writes for American Radio Works (ARW). She has been writing for ARW since January 2008, specifically covering education. Hanford Has worked for several well known public radio programs such as North Carolina Public. She has received many awards for cover complex issues, such as, the 2005 series Understanding Poverty, which received a duPont-Columbia Award. Hanford now works from her home in Takoma Park, MD, just outside of Washington, DC. She has a degree in English and American Studies from Amherst College ("American Radioworks"). As it is noted her background and work history gives Hanford credibility as a writer and solid evidence as of why one may trust her concern and observation on the subject of education. As well as being an honored journalist.
Next, as an appeal to logic Hanford begins by sharing about two professors in the late 1970 from two different well know college who were perplex that semester after semester there students were not receiving rating above the 40 percent mark on their exams because of the lecturing method that were being used. To further convince the reader about her concern about the problem with lecturing she continues to share about Hestenes and Hallouns testing methods, which were created specifically to probe student understand of physics. This test was known as Force Concept Inventory (FCI), which was used to track the conceptual understanding of physics. She states that Hastenes and Hallouns gave the test to 1000 students who attended two different schools and...

Find Another Essay On The Problem with Lecturing: A Rhetorical Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis of The Talking Heads’ “Once in a Lifetime”

1896 words - 8 pages Rhetorical Analysis of The Talking Heads’ “Once in a Lifetime” Kenneth Burke’s Five Master Terms exist to bring to light the motivation behind, theoretically, any bit of text to which we care to apply them. The beauty of this Pentad is its fundamentality in regards to the motivations humans have in creating words and meaning using the tools of language available. This doesn’t just apply to long-winded theses regarding the

A Rhetorical Analysis of “The Death of Honesty”

1078 words - 4 pages honesty, he ends his appeal by stating “As the Founders…warned, the failure to cultivate virtue in citizens can be a lethal threat to any democracy” (par. 20). Damon ends on this warning note after leading his audience through his line of rhetorical arguments. William Damon uses the classical rhetorical devices of logos, pathos and ethos to convince his audience of the urgency to address the decline of honesty. He provides a balanced assessment

‘We Shall Fight on the Beaches’- A Rhetorical Analysis

1913 words - 8 pages ‘We Shall Fight on the Beaches’- A Rhetorical Analysis I have, myself, full confidence that if all do their duty, if nothing is neglected, and if the best arrangements are made, as they are being made, we shall prove ourselves once again able to defend our Island home, to ride out the storm of war, and to outlive the menace of tyranny, if necessary for years, if necessary alone. –Sir Winston Churchill, ‘ We Shall Fight on the Beaches

A Modest Proposal Rhetorical Analysis

1011 words - 5 pages table for them and their family. Imagine for a moment having something for nine months, seeing it grow, feeling it move and when you can finally hold it in your arms it’s gone just as fast. These are the things that Jonathan Swift should have considered when he originally wrote this proposal. All in all, Swift crafted a pretty good proposal whit an outrageous idea. He used rhetorical appeals to connect with his audience on a personal level. He

A Rhetorical Analysis of Superman

929 words - 4 pages . in Burgchardt 608) Superman is clearly an example of a rhetorical object. As a rhetorical object Superman shares the values and ideologies of the American culture. The character’s strength, humility, and tolerance when acting as both Clark Kent and Superman show his integrity. Although Superman has god like powers he only uses them for the greater good. Superman is a warrior with immense powers like that of Hercules, but unlike the

Polyphagia: A Rhetorical Analysis of the Film “Hungry for Change”

1509 words - 7 pages to no contradiction in opinion, oftentimes continuing on the talking point to a fault. This is suggestive of a single-sided static argument with little dynamic development across opinions. While this is not a problem in itself, it may have been a conscious choice due to the argument presented not being strong enough to hold up to scrutiny. The arguments made often rely on the trussing that these ‘experts’ provide through their ethos. Statements

The Old vs. New: A Rhetorical Analysis of Persepolis

996 words - 4 pages In the book Persepolis, a non-fiction piece about the author Marjane Satrapi’s life in a changing Iran, Satrapi explores the idea of tensions between old and new by referencing conversations with her grandma, talking about parties, the transition of the veil into society, talking about her school, noting the demonstrations that took place in the streets, and discussing the cultural revolution that occurred. Satrapi purposefully communicates this

A Modest Proposal: Rhetorical Analysis

904 words - 4 pages A Modest Proposal, by Jonathan Swift, is a satirical pamphlet that was published to the public in 1729. Its purpose was to shock the citizens of Ireland with an appalling solution to their economic troubles at the time. Swift’s purpose for A Modest Proposal was to present a horrific solution for an ever growing problem in Ireland. He adopts an aloof but eerily serious tone to grab the attention of the lower and middle class. The issue in

The Great Gatsby Rhetorical Analysis

947 words - 4 pages the visions specifically through the development of the main character, Jay Gatsby. Gatsby is introduced in a way that leaves the reader with questions. One of the important components of Gatsby is his background and how his life started. Throughout the book, from many characters, there’s speculation of how Gatsby acquired his wealth. There is simple dialogue-a rhetorical strategy-between characters to display Fitzgerald’s’ purpose. At many of his

The Argument Culture: Rhetorical Analysis

1591 words - 6 pages acknowledging there are times to fight, Tannen keeps from alienating those who would bring up civil rights and basic humanities issues, encouraging one to put those issues aside. The problem with this concept is that we always see our issues as being valid and worthy to fight for. After all, if we didn’t, we wouldn’t be fighting for them to begin with. This is a kind of deflective tactic. If you aren’t thinking about it closely, you don’t even

Rhetorical Analysis: The Argument Culture

1659 words - 7 pages something, they rationally make a judgment and there always has to be reason. Therefore, explaining with some examples or quoting an expert opinion would be very successful idea in those reasons. So now we can see that Deborah Tannen, the author of ‘The Argument Culture’, shows us the way of using Aristotle’s three skills: interesting to readers by using her career indirectly, compelling readers to follow her writing structure so that making the reader’s

Similar Essays

The Audacity Of Hope: A Rhetorical Analysis

2079 words - 8 pages Hope, by definition means to look forward to something with reasonable desire and confidence. Hope also means a person or thing in which expectations are centered. When discussing the word hope, one must consider the core values by which the word works around. You could hope for financial success, world peace, or simply hope for some good out of your day. In 2006, Barack Obama wrote the political biography The Audacity of Hope to outline his

Outfoxed: A Rhetorical Analysis

1565 words - 6 pages This was an assignment where I was supposed to do a rhetorical analysis over the documentary Outfoxed: Rupert Murdoch's War on Journalism. We were supposed to discuss the message of the essay and talk about how to improve it.**************************************************Journalism, by definition of the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, is defined as "the collection and editing of news for presentation through the media." In the movie "Outfoxed

A Rhetorical Analysis

817 words - 4 pages evident, his target audience is the people in Ireland of 1729. the main point or thesis are that in order to solve this problem the people should just eat babies. Some of the argument being presented are that babies are useless, that a one year old baby in good health would taste delicious and all these plans of how the system would work. the purpose of these arguments is to get people to see that it's a good idea and that it will work and

A Rhetorical Analysis

723 words - 3 pages . The assumption is that he wants to sell babies and for his solution to help his country to be more outrageous and not having children and families with worries about money. I would describe the writer’s character by genuine and sincere about his work. His persona is to be able to have the ability to satisfy his readers for the solution. He had the credibility of a writer and a graduate from Harvard University. Swift shows goodwill with the fact