The Internet And User Content Essay

1131 words - 5 pages

In the January 18th, 2012 New York Times article “The False Ideals of the Web”, Jaron Lanier attempts to take a very difficult issue – one that many view in terms of black or white – and find some middle ground. Unfortunately, what he ends up doing in the article is create an either/or situation, rather than find any middle ground. In the end we are left in the same situation that we started with.

In the first paragraph, Jaron appeals to the pathos of the reader; he assumes that the reader is of the generation that has grown up in the digital age, thus they would agree that the most important aspect of the internet is the people who contribute to it. However, there is no reason to ever assume that. Some people may actually believe that user contribution detracts from what makes the internet a viable source of information. For example, if the internet were controlled by academia, it would most likely be a peer reviewed source of information. However, as it is, anyone can contribute information to the internet, which makes the internet not a reliable source for knowledge. We can see this in academia, which typically does not support the use of Wikipedia as an academic source, and Wikipedia is an encyclopedia that relies entirely on user contribution.

In the third paragraph the author says, “The proposed Stop Online Piracy Act, or SOPA, which is being considered in the House while the Senate looks at a similar bill, is deemed the worst thing ever. “ However, at no point does the author state who considers this bill “the worst thing ever.” There are many people who supported this bill, and I would assume in supporting this bill that they did not think it was the worst bill ever.

The author then goes on to say, “The legislation has indeed included draconian remedies in various drafts, so I join my colleagues in criticizing the bills.” The author never goes on to state what these draconian methods are. He assumes that the reader will accept his word that the legislation deals with this issue using the mentioned method. In a way, this can be considered a bandwagon fallacy, in that we're supposed to accept that because he and his colleagues think the bill uses draconion methods, it does in fact use them. Without support for this statement, there is no reason to ever believe what the author has said. In addition, the author appeals to the readers' ethos, as well as an appeal to authority, in that we're expected to accept the opinions of these people, simply because the author says we should.

The author then goes on to state, “Those rare tech companies that have come out in support of SOPA are not merely criticized but barred from industry events and subject to boycotts. We, the keepers of the flame of free speech, are banishing people for their speech. The result is a chilling atmosphere, with people afraid to speak their minds.” It's hard to see, but this is definitely a fallacy of equivocation. The author is comparing the corporations who...

Find Another Essay On The Internet and User Content

Contraceptives and the Teenage User Essay

719 words - 3 pages Contraceptives and the Teenage User For years now a debate has been ongoing concerning teenagers and contraceptives. Some argue that giving contraceptives or even allowing teenagers to purchase them only encourages premarital sex. This attitude, however, denies the simple fact that premarital sex in adolescents has been common throughout the ages. It occurred before effective contraceptives were available, it occurs now despite the well

Design and User Experience : The Private Hospital

507 words - 2 pages Design and User Experience : The Private Hospital (calls Clinic in Chile) website in general are very well structured with easy access to all the services that these institution provides. The neonatology and pediatrics sections usually lacks of images and multimedia sections, the one reason of that can be that the information is oriented toward adults visitors or potentials parent patients. Additionally in general these WebPages provides

The Increase in Piracy as a Result of Internet User Apathy

1083 words - 5 pages The evolution of the Internet into a mainstream resource has provided its users with access to whatever their hearts desire, often at no cost. Such free access has instilled in the minds of users that they are entitled to possess all that they may obtain, without regard to those from whom they are taking. Causing the damages to our economy and society on a global scale, and challenges to the current state of copyright law, resulting from the

The Content and Presentation of Teenage Magazines

2507 words - 10 pages The Content and Presentation of Teenage Magazines Analyse and comment on the content and presentation, and the advertising of the Summer 2004 issue of Elle Girl magazine. Examine the relationship between features and the advertising in the magazine and consider in particular how this magazine tries to persuade young women to buy fashion and beauty products. Elle Girl is a magazine aimed at young teenage girls. It

User Interface and its Importance for the Customer

1266 words - 6 pages When dealing with technology, User Interface Design is often not considered the main part of the technology. One might assume that UI is not an important part of the device and can be thrown in at last minute but in reality UI is the most vital part of the any system. When a user looks at the device, the UI is the most essential part because it is how people interact with the computer. If a user is confused or doesn’t understand the UI, that

This essay is about the controversy over the internet, either being user friendly, or invading privacy of the users

552 words - 2 pages The growing popularity of the Internet is highly due to being user friendly and a source of endless access to information. Even though there are many positive aspects of using the Internet, there are also important negative aspects that need to be considered. People who use the Internet are more likely to experience depression and loneliness. The Internet can also be used to obtain intimate personal information about people.A study of social and

Privacy and the Internet

3948 words - 16 pages addresses some of the ways unauthorized personal information has been and is being collected and steps that can be taken to prevent or avoid this collection. To make an online purchase, an Internet user must provide a certain amount of personal information to the vendor. This information usually includes the user's name, address, telephone number, e-mail address, and credit card data. There have been many reported cases of security failures

Children and the Internet

2597 words - 10 pages the Internet by children (Adapted from Livingstone and Haddon 2009, 8) Content: child as recipient Contact: child as participant Conduct: child as actor Education, learning and literacy Educational resources Contact with others who share one’s interests Self-initiated or collaborative learning Creativity Diversity of resources Being invited/inspired to create or participate User generated content creation Identity and social connection Advise

Network and the Internet

795 words - 4 pages days both in houses and commercially” (Riaz). In this quote author saying that network is available in different types and confirming that network system is been use by home users to big companies. The reason computer user are using network system is to share document, software but also help transmit internet signal through their network making internet accessibility in the area they preferred. There many network but the most common use are WAN

Pornography and the Internet

2869 words - 11 pages is downloaded with images and scenes of the most gratuitous nature. Despite having some of the most extreme anti-porn laws in Europe, Britain is the second highest consumer of porn, and there is little in the way of control concerning the restriction of access, availability or content on the Internet. The effect of this 'sea of porn' is far reaching. Internet porn has many victims including animals, women and children. So far it has washed across

Routers and the Internet

922 words - 4 pages to reach an individual who could be potentially interested in purchasing the advertised items. The internet is a very diverse tool that can be used to any user’s needs and has made people’s lives considerably easier due to its easy access and its capabilities. At times the internet can also be harmful as well because of its content and the ability to communicate with people in other countries. Terrorist have also taken advantage of the easy

Similar Essays

Web 2.0 And User Generated Content: The Effect Of User Generated Content On The Quality Of Published Content Is A Hotly Discussed Subject

1351 words - 5 pages elements of the internet and the core principles of the technology are still the same, the difference is how the data is managed, distributed and supplied.Pre Web 2.0, now referred to as Web 1.0, sites where static information was presented for consumption. Publishers supplied information and users consumed it. Web 2.0 creates an interactive web experience for the user who is also the supplier of content. The web is currently about services rather

The Relationship Between Advertising And Content Provision On The Internet

4468 words - 18 pages Advertising and content on the Internet 677 The relationship between advertising and content provision on the Internet Yuehong Yuan, Jonathan P. Caulkins and Stephen Roehrig H.J. Heinz III School of Public Policy and Management, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA Introduction The distinction between advertising and content may sometimes seem to be blurred on the Net. Consider, for example, the majority of company Web

The Internet: A Network Of Controversies Exploring The Problems And Solutions Of Offensive Content On The Internet

1820 words - 7 pages website such as popular children's toys to attract visitors. These business practices are unacceptable, and would never be allowed in the "real world."There is also the much talked about issue of child pornography. Child pornography is a very real problem and generates approximately 3 billion dollars annually (Pornography Statistics). The average Internet user would not consider child pornography a huge problem, however there are numerous sites that

Anabolic Steroids And The User Essay

1184 words - 5 pages children idolize these athletes wanting to be just like them. This causes an increase in steroid use in high school students and in some cases middle school students. Steroids have both positive but more so negative effect on the body. Both need to be acknowledged by the user in order to prevent injury or possibly death. If athletes did not commonly use steroids it is quite possible that we would see a decrease in use amongst children and teens.The