The Ethical Structure Behind Human Experimentation

3353 words - 13 pages

The Ethical Structure Behind Human Experimentation

The history of medical research in the twentieth century provides abundant evidence which shows how easy it is to exploit individuals, especially the sick, the weak, and the vulnerable, when the only moral guide for science is a naive utilitarian dedication to the greatest good for the greatest number. Locally administered internal review boards were thought to be a solution to the need for ethical safeguards to protect the human guinea pig. However, with problems surrounding informed consent, the differentiation between experimentation and treatment, and the new advances within medicine, internal review boards were found to be inadequate for the job. This led to the establishment of the National Bioethics Advisory Commission by President Bill Clinton in the hopes of setting clear ethical standards for human research.

History
Examples of unethical human research cases

The dark history of human experimentation began with the clarification between experimentation and treatment. The larger public began to notice experimenters ethical neglect for their subjects in the early 1960s. Those charged with administering research funding took note of the public furor generated by the exposure of gross abuses in medical research. These included uncontrolled promotional distribution of thalidomide throughout the United States, labeled as an experimental drug; the administration of cancer cells to senile and debilitated patients at the Brooklyn Jewish Chronic Disease Hospital; and the uncontrolled distribution of LSD to children at Harvard Medical Center through Professors Alpert and Leary. Most important was Henry Beechers 1966 article in the New England Journal of Medicine, detailing 22 protocols of dubious ethicality and declaring that the roster had been winnowed down from a longer list culled more or less from periodicals crossing his desk (Edgar, 495).

Publics fears concerning these cases

The public was very sensitive to these experiments since the US government had imprinted the crimes committed by the Nazi doctors throughout the war into their minds. When the public became aware that their own government was capable of the same devious unethical experimentation, two fears arose. The first was the frightening power of some political ideologies to demand that no private interest impede the accomplishment of the public good, and the second was the acute fear that people must adapt to whatever science produces, and that science is ultimately beyond social control (Edgar 496). Therefore, the U.S. government changed their slogans to focus on how the Nuremburg trials taught us that there must be limits to government power.

If Nuremberg was one critical underpinning for public attitudes toward human experimentation, the second was the social awareness that new medical breakthroughs affected not simply the individual patient, but also human life more generally. Given the dimensions of the...

Find Another Essay On The Ethical Structure Behind Human Experimentation

Lord of the flies: exam notes relating to the theme of human nature (includes quotes from novel and pg numbers)and a possible essay structure

2259 words - 9 pages HUMAN NATURE"the theme (of the book) is an attempt to trace back the defects of society to the defects of human nature...The moral is that the shape of society must depend on the ethical nature of the individual and not on any political system." (Golding)"Evil in Manq Golding believes that man is naturally predisposed to do evil."What I mean is . . . Maybe it's only us . . ." (page 97)q Simon speaks these words in Chapter 5

The Science behind Human Space Travel over Time

1059 words - 5 pages With our never ending discovery of the universe, and the galaxies and planets within it, humans have had the urge to explore other worlds. The purpose of this exploration is to find planets similar to Earth, answering the question: Are we alone in the universe? In this essay, I will be comparing the space travel of today to space travel of the future and the science behind how these forms of travel work and how one form is more effective than

In what ways are ethical decisions in regard to the value of human life disregarded in times of War? What are the ramifications of this? Using the example of 'The Holocaust',

2997 words - 12 pages War and its savagery promote a primitive and callous disregard for human life. Nations at war tend to devise what is ethically right or wrong to promote their own cause. The Holocaust is the most prevalent example of this. Throughout this essay, I will demonstrate the ways in which ethical decisions in regard to human life are disregarded during times of war, in particular during the 'Holocaust' will be discussed. The essay will be commenced by

Humans Conducting Experiments on Other Humans

1898 words - 8 pages also given society a foundation on defining and understanding human rights. Ethical standards have been developed to help differentiate from acceptable and unacceptable experimentation of people. There are two classes of ethical standards: categorical imperative and utility (Withgott and Laposata, 2012). Categorical imperative simply advises humans to treat other humans as they would prefer to be treated themselves. This is known as one of the

The Necessity of Animal Testing

1299 words - 5 pages create vaccines, records and treatments have evolved tremendously. Supporters of anti-animal experimentation also argue that because of these advancements, the need for animal testing is completely unnecessary. The structure, anatomy and psychology of animals differ from humans, making them inadequate models for human related research. “It has been suggested that several alternative technologies, including computer modeling, micro-dosing, and

Animal Abuse in the name of Science

1018 words - 4 pages November 1, 1986, stated “Animal experiments confuse the issues and their results will never have scientific precision. There is absolutely no connection between vivisection and human health. The general belief in the value of animal experimentation is the result of brainwashing that the public has been submitted to for a long time. Behind it are the pharmaceutical industries, which spend fortunes on publicity and finance the research institutes

Investigating Ethical Issues from a Philosophical and Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation:

826 words - 4 pages Investigating Ethical Issues from a Philosophical and Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation: “Ask the experimenters why they experiment on animals, and the answer is, “Because the animals are like us." Ask the experimenters why it is morally okay to experiment on animals, and the answer is, "Because the animals are not like us. Animal experimentation rests on a logical contradiction.” (Charles R. Magel) For abounding years the

Should Animal Testing be Banned?

987 words - 4 pages both human skin cells grown in test tubes that are layered to mimic the structure of human skin.” (Bardon,1) Skin samples of any kind would be of use and important. Granted, some would say that there are many different kinds of human tissue. However, places like the National Disease Research Interchange in Philadelphia supply more than 100 different types of human tissue. ( Bardon,2) There are hospitals and labs around the country that could

Testing Limits: Preventing Past Mistakes from Becoming the Future

1116 words - 5 pages American Tradition Institute v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, but due to gaps in the law regarding ethical human experimentation, the Nuremsburg Code, the suit against the EPA was overturned. (Milloy) Examination of the American Tradition Institute v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency case makes it clear that the Nuremsburg Code is not enough to protect citizens from immoral human experimentation. (Milloy) Actions are being taken, however

The Ethics and Limitations of Animal Research

1871 words - 7 pages experimentations put the subject in both mental and physical stress. These cases can range from dissections to in-vivo experimentation. Much of the controversy on animal research is coming from experimentation with alive animals, which is in-vitro. Claims follow that using an animal for experimentation is the same as using a human being for the same purpose; therefore it is unethical (Rowan, 1997). Animal research encompasses a wide range of methods

Pros of Animal Experimentation

1242 words - 5 pages , and the use of animals is highly ethical considering what could be the alternative, although there is progress being made to change these measures. This is how animal experimentation is of use to society for humans and animals. Animal testing has gone back as far as three hundred B.C.E with the Greek physician and philosopher, Aristotle (*). Then there was Galen, a Greek physician, who studied animals in Rome and learned more about medicine

Similar Essays

The Psychology Behind Human Selfishness Essay

2403 words - 10 pages While numerous people claim to be men of selfless character, the human race has never been alluded to for its outstanding and gallant nobleness. Truth be told, when an individual finds him or herself in a precarious situation, selfish thoughts instinctively kick in as part of automated survival predispositions—which the human race has been equipped with since prehistoric periods—and the only prevailing priority is the wellbeing of that

The Human Response To Physical Structure

1549 words - 6 pages The Human Response to Physical Structure Most of the world's inhabitants view space and structure through visual elements such as bricks, rock, vegetation and foliage, hallways, doors, windows, trims, and flooring. These elements combine to allow each individual's experience of a space. The German word gestalt means form or shape. Gestalt psychology attempts to investigate the human mind and how it conceives of or recognizes patterns

The Ethical Implications Of The Human Genome Project And Its Parallel Efforts

3349 words - 13 pages The human genome consists of all the genes that make up the master blue print for building a human being. There are about one hundred thousand genes concealed inside of the nucleus of each cell. The genes are tangled inside of an elongated genetic structure that is called the chromosome. Mapping and eventually decoding the human genome will enable us to provide strategies to diagnose and possibly prevent different genetic diseases, and

Human Cloning Examines The Issue Human Cloning. Debates The Pros And Cons And The Ethical Issues Surrounding The Procedure. Describes Political Efforts To Outlaw The Process

1198 words - 5 pages to life" groups feel that it is wrong to end one life to save another. According to the Family Research Council, a group opposed to all forms of cloning, human reproductive cloning has too many social and ethical concerns, such as how the new clones would perceive themselves in society and in the family. I believe that human cloning will continue to be a hotly debated issue as long as both sides remain adamant about cloning benefits and