The Controversy Of The Manipulation Of Advertising

1411 words - 6 pages

The Controversy of the Manipulation of Advertising

Is advertising manipulative; can it be controlling, or is it fueling the demand of the American economy? The exhaustive battle of what advertising is and what it’s not is never-ending and both ends of the spectrum can only battle with statistics, words, and opinions on the fact of the matter. Many arguments have arisen since the establishment of the advertising industry and everyone sheds their own light on the subject. In “Beauty and the Beast of Advertising,” Jean Kilbourne argues that the advertising industry portrayal of women is narrow-minded and produces emotional and psychological problems within women in regards with their roles in society, their physical appearance, and sexual attitudes. She also emphasizes how the world of advertising creates artificiality among women. On another note, the author of “What Advertisement Isn’t,” John O’Toole, takes a look at how the government has too much control of and poorly regulates advertising, how it is not deceptive on a subconscious level, and how advertising is a sales tool and should not be evaluated by journalistic or any other standards. These two arguments talk about issues in advertising that interconnect on broader levels but essentially are speaking of two different levels of advertisements.
Kilbourne looks at advertising as a guideline that women of today abide by. She argues that women in advertisements are portrayed as a sex object or a housewife. She goes on to say how the advertising housewife is “obsessed with cleanliness and lemon fresh scents”(238). She also states that the sex object “is a mannequin, a shell”(238). Her physical appearance is the only beauty about her. This “conventional beauty” is what all advertisement women are conformed to. Women of today are constantly bombarded with this ideal and feel they have to live up to the norm, and if they don’t then they are undesirable then feel guilty about it.
According to Kilbourne advertising creates artificiality in the sense that “beauty comes from without”(238). She supports her argument by stating, “more than one million dollars is spent every hour on cosmetics”(238). She said woman are conditioned to fit this false ideal and are going as far as altering body parts to reach the unreachable norm. She further supports her argument by stating more facts, stats, and surveys. Kilbourne complains that women are “dismembered in commercials, separated into body parts in need of change or improvement”(239). She reiterates that it is to reach this level of beauty and is not viable to maintain.
Kilbourne’s last point is that advertising influences sexual attitudes. She points out that “advertising’s approach to sex is pornographic: it reduces people to objects and de-emphasizes human contact and individuality”(239). She argues that the commercial women today are portrayed as independent hardworking women that can do it all. On the contrary she...

Find Another Essay On The Controversy of the Manipulation of Advertising

The Manipulation of the Media Essay

1329 words - 5 pages Watching the average American is a lot like watching Homer Simpson. There is an episode of the television show the Simpsons where someone, probably Bart places a Twinkie in the backyard. The Twinkie is rigged to electrocute anyone who touches it. Homer loves Twinkies and he just can’t resist them. So for the next several hours we hear a shocking noise followed by Homer’s trademark D'oh. Poor Homer is just not smart enough to keep from getting

The Development of Gene Manipulation Essay

1679 words - 7 pages discoveries. An efficient mechanism promising vast improvements to healthcare is the development of gene manipulation. Genetic engineering, also called genetic modification, is the direct manipulation of an organism's genome by using biotechnologies. The process begins with the molecular cloning of genetic materials or by synthesizing the DNA. The finished product is a new DNA sequence that then can be inserted into a host organism. Complete manipulation

The Manipulation of Natural Resources

1097 words - 4 pages people (Food and Agriculture). Nigeria, home to oil and natural gas, attracts many First World oil companies. These companies hire guerrillas to steal oil from Nigeria’s reservoir. Ethnic minorities claim that foreign companies keep most of the wealth from oil exports, while Nigerians suffer from underpaid labor (Africa: Resources). Core country manipulation of natural resources is unfair and is a cause of extreme poverty in Third World countries

The Medias Manipulation of Friendships

849 words - 4 pages emulate these constructed stereotypes. The Power Wheel campaign highlights the underlying construction of the binary oppositions of gender in advertising that is instilled upon children. The Barbie Jammin Jeep advertisement encapsulates the stereotypical attributes of girls to emphasise the socially defined limits of femineity. The advertisement’s safe animated setting with exclusively female characters visually projects a façade of females being

the manipulation of a story

1040 words - 5 pages The Minority Report and the action film Minority Report both come face the challenge of their police’s office chief commissioner John Anderton were both setup an force to either be falsely arrested for a murder of killing a man that Anderton didn’t even know is the biggest similarity the novel and film have in common. But there are a differences between the two; from the setting, characters and their description, plot, theme, and conclusion

Analysis of the Intellectual Manipulation of Ads

1115 words - 4 pages improving body image, none of which involve demonizing any form of media (Levine and Smolak). Advertising possesses the elements of artwork and its developing mediums should be expected of the art-form. As “all the definitions [of art] offered over the centuries include some notion of human agency, whether through manual skills … intellectual manipulation … or public or personal expression,” and the three majors categories of art are "form

Manipulation Of The Truth By The Powerful

1038 words - 5 pages : Unidentified false reports presented as fact to make exciting news stories; Disputed events presented as fact for propaganda purposes; Military disinformation. This shows that the manipulation scopes from sensationalism to the more worrying military disinformation. The phrase "A young woman in the bank said to me yesterday: "I've stopped listening to any of the war news. It's all just propaganda."" shows that even 'common' people can see that the media and government are controlling the truth.The public's opinion may be that "It's on TV so it must be true", but for the misrepresentation and distortion of the truth to stop, the public must become aware of what goes on.

The Manipulation of the Farming Industry

919 words - 4 pages Over the past couple of years multi-billion dollar companies have been putting small farms out of business. Farming has been a way of life since the beginning of time, and not much has changed until recently. GMOs or genetically modified organisms are the cause of this change. Monsanto is the main contributor of GMOs to farms around the United States. John Francisco Queeny founded Monsanto in 1997 in Creve Coeur, Missouri. Monsanto was one of

The Controversy of Animal Testing

1302 words - 5 pages normally would to the drugs and chemicals. Animals are also not identical to humans, so no one is sure whether the effects will be the same on humans (http://www.aboutanimaltesting.co.uk /controversy-of-animal- testing.html). After many animal tests, the animals are euthanized. Again, they are not able to give consent for this as would be required of a human. Other animals have to endure the rest of their life in captivity or

The Controversy of Huckleberry Finn

1912 words - 8 pages   Over the 129 years for which the book has been in print, Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn has been regarded with much controversy, for many different reasons. As it has progressed, the subject of this controversy has been almost constantly changing. This essay will explore some of the claims and explanations of the controversy, as well as a discussion on whether the book is even that controversial. While everyone is entitled to

The Controversy of Media Imperialism

1336 words - 5 pages The Controversy of Media Imperialism The controversy of media imperialism questions us as to whether a certain medium (in this case, the newspaper – tabloid, broadsheet, hybrid) is controlled by the publication owner or the managers/editors-in-chief/journalists. They both deliver news and make it possible to be accessed by the reading-public. Proprietors own publication companies and administer the content of the media

Similar Essays

The Influence Of Manipulation Essay

1713 words - 7 pages transferred to other parts of the brain to process and analyze, and is finally builds a perception. In modern society, a form of manipulation called subliminal messaging is used especially by advertising companies to influence the subconscious. In film, Christopher Nolan’s movie “Inception”, the process of planting ideas in the subconscious is displayed through the characters inserting themselves in the person’s innermost thoughts. Do not let

The Manipulation Of Prospero Essay

651 words - 3 pages The Manipulation of Prospero "Manipulation" means "to influence or manage shrewdly or deviously; to tamper with or falsify for personal gain." In William Shakespeare’s play, The Tempest, we meet an interesting, mysterious Prospero, a magician and the true Duke of Milan now living on a deserted island with his daughter Miranda. Prospero has the power to manipulate his own daughter and does this because he wants to protect her from danger

The Power Of Manipulation Essay

1085 words - 4 pages It was July 1519. The stage was set in Leipzig, and thousands of Europeans flocked to Pleissenburg Castle, where the Protestant Martin Luther and Scholastic Johann Eck had gathered to debate one of the most seminal theological issues of the era. The seeds of the Protestant Reformation had been planted, but the turmoil had barely begun. At a superficial level, it was difficult for many contemporary followers to comprehend where Luther and Eck

The Power Of Manipulation Essay

813 words - 3 pages Macbeth’s weakness of mind and character allowed the witches to manipulate him psychologically, rather than acting as a supernatural force. The Weird Sisters were pivotal in Macbeth’s eventual breakdown. They choose their target very wisely, and since Macbeth is, to them, merely a worthless pawn, the loss of his sanity was not even considered a small price to pay, but a pleasurable consequence. Until Macbeth’s encounter with the witches, he was