The Australian Constitution Essay

1234 words - 5 pages

The Australian Constitution

Will Australia become a republic in the next twenty years? This is a difficult question to speculate on. The main area of law governing this issue is section 128 of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900 (U.K). Other issues in this debate are regarding appointment, termination and the powers to be awarded to the proposed Head of State, and the impact the change will have on the States. Examining the history of Australian Legislative powers, and reasons why Australians would want to change, is also useful when speculating on this issue.

The Colonial Laws Validity Act 1865 emphasized self-government in the colonies, although denying them the power to amend or repeal British law. (Enright 1995, p.14) It wasn’t until Australia became a Federation with the enactment of the Australian Constitution Act 1901(U.K.) on 1 January 1901, that Australia had their own law making powers. However, these powers were still limited by the Constitution. (Waller 2000, p.71) When the Statute of Winchester 1931 invalidated the Colonial Laws Validity Act 1865 the Commonwealth gained the power to pass their own Acts, irrespective of whether they were consistent with British Law. However, this power did not extend to the States. Remaining restrictions were removed with the enactment of the Australia Acts 1986. Australian Parliaments and Courts now had full control of Australian Laws. (Enright 1995, p.p. 16-17 and Carvan 1999, p.p. 25-26)

Although the Monarch ceased to be active in government, the Queen still remains as the Constitutional Head of State, with Monarchial power being exercised through the Governor-General. With the exception of ‘reserve powers’ the Governor-General acts on the advice of the government. (Enright 1995, p.19 and Brown 1995,p.16)

Opinion polls show that the majority of Australians would prefer a Republic system of government. (Chisholm 1997,p.68) There is a feeling that for Australia to be truly independent, the ties with England would need to be severed. (Mack, K., in Corkery 1998, p.34) One view would be to simply abolish the Monarchy. (Winterton, G., in Stephenson 1994, p.17) However, others might say that our current system is already mostly Republican with the only Monarchial elements remaining being the concentration of Royal powers in the Ministry. (

In any event, ‘severing the Royal ties’ is not that easy, as amendments to the Australian Constitution Acts 1900(U.K) can only be passed in Parliament in accordance with section 128. (Chisholm 1997, p.61)

Section 128 prescribes that changes can only be implemented by referendum. To hold a referendum a Bill needs to be passed through the Commonwealth Parliament to authorize it. Once authorized, a majority of votes, as well as a majority of States is required. This dual criterion has proven difficult to achieve, with...

Find Another Essay On The Australian Constitution

The Anacronistic Constitution Essay

2677 words - 11 pages INTRODUCTION In recent years, the Australian Constitution has come under increasing scrutiny. Pro republicans have argued that the Constitution is anachronistic and that it should be replaced by a better system; one that is more complimentary of today's lifestyle and does not include an hereditary monarch as the nation's Head-of-State. Monarchists believe that while the Constitution may need amending in some areas, the Queen as the Head

Religion in Australian Politics Essay

2479 words - 10 pages statistics on religion is Australian society are just as difficult to interpret as the constitution. In the 2011 census, 22% of Australians reported having no religion (ABS 2013). Whilst the number of people reporting no religion is not a majority, it is a significant portion of the population. In fact only Catholics make up a larger portion of Australian society with 25% of people identifying as Catholic in the 2011 census (ABS 2013). Not only is ‘no

Outline the major developments in the move towards an Australian republic in the twentieth century

751 words - 3 pages surrendering of Australia's defence and foreign policy to Australia, helped to further Australian independence from Britain. The High Court could now make the final decision in interpreting the Australian Constitution, rather than having the chance of being overruled by Britain.Republicanism took its next step in the form of the 1999 referendum. The issue had now come to a head; the Australian public was to decide whether Australia was to become a


2560 words - 10 pages parliaments, the development of the voting systems within Australia, the role and development of the Australian constitution and the effectiveness of liberal democracy in modern day Australia.The Basis Of Law In Australia The foundation of Australian law derives from English law. Australian law was originally formed upon the idea that no person or group was in possession of any part of what we now call Australia. After Captain James Cook claimed

The Federation Illusion

1988 words - 8 pages also, Australia still comes under the "rule" of "the King or Queen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain. The Australian Commonwealth Constitution created the High Court of Australia. However, the Constitution made the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in England the highest court of appeal for Australia. With the arrival of Federation, the Australian States and newly appointed Federal Government, Smith (1999) says "Australia was little

Parlaimentary Powers

1416 words - 6 pages colonies wanted to create a central authority to legislate for the national issues. Each colony also wanted to retain the power to govern in its own territory. A federal system of government had to be designed which would balance these interests. This is why the Australian Constitution, Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900 (UK), was passed by the British Parliament and came into force in Australia on 1 January 1901. This document sets

The gradual transfer of legislative power from the imperial government to the colonies, States and the Commonwealth

2510 words - 10 pages limited legislative power. They had several meetings; to discuss possible legislation with the best intentions for the various colonies and the long term goal of an Australian Constitution.In 1891, National Australasian Federation Convention, Sydney, attended by all colonies plus New Zealand. This drafted a constitution, but it was not later proceeded with by the colonial parliaments. It was, however, the basis of future discussion of Federation.In

Was autocracy in the middle ages better or worse than the democracy we live in today?

573 words - 2 pages public with information, explaining the government in terms that the public can relate to.Because of the Australian democratic system women are treated equally.As a result of the Australian democratic system, women have the right to vote in an election. Unlike medieval autocracy, living under our constitution, it is illegal to discriminate against women and we now recognise the value of women as a role of a mother and equal pay for equal work.Unlike

General Overview of the Republic Debate

1051 words - 4 pages would veto our application. Also, our constitution is the heart of our Australian identity and the Governor General who is above party politics and has in effect become Australia's head of state. Destroying these is like taking away a part of our culture.The bipartisan model put forward is not even supported by all republicans. Firstly, it doesn't allow for a President to be elected by the people and therefore is undemocratic. Instead, he/she will

Australian History

1159 words - 5 pages largest export and jobs in mining make up over 2 percent of the total labor force. Mining was also responsible for bringing in a large portion of Australia’s population with the initial discovery of gold in 1851bringing in immigrants from all over the world. Government The commonwealth of Australia was formed when six British colonies agreed to join and become a new nation. This nations rules were preserved in the Australian constitution

Essay about the importance of the independence of the judiciary in Australia

1830 words - 7 pages Court shall consist of a chief justice and so many other justices, not less than two, as the Parliament describes.Using this definition contained in the Australian Constitution, the expression 'the independence of the judiciary' to my understanding refers only to independence in making decisions in court cases. It means that in making such decisions a judge must be individually independent and free from pressures which could influence a judge in

Similar Essays

The Australian Constitution Essay

2054 words - 8 pages The Australian Constitution The founding fathers of Australia could never have predicted the society that was to come. However, the constitution- the most important document of the land- stands today with only 8 changes to the words after over 100 years of use. The constitution is not without flaws; the rights outlined in the document are far from clear, which hampers the knowledge of the public about their rights

The High Court Of Australia Essay

1779 words - 7 pages 1)What is the role of the High Court in Australia?The High Court of Australia is the nations most fundamental legal tribunal. The Australian High Court was formed by the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act of 1900. Under the original jurisdiction, the exclusive role of the Australian High Court is to interpret the constitution through making decisional outcomes upon existing disputes on constitutional matters.Under the High Court of

The Australian Government Essay

1432 words - 6 pages news television show and it was quite humorous. I am going to give a quick history lesson on Australia then go into how the government formed and came to be. Then I will talk about the Australian constitution, the Australian arms of government, their federal system, political parties and Australia’s current Prime Minister. The government of Australia is Constitutional Monarchy and a Federal Parliamentary. According to the Australian Government

Australia: A Brief History And Analysis

1419 words - 6 pages Australia, formally known as the Commonwealth of Australia, was formed in 1901. This was the result of six independent British colonies that came together to form a new nation. The foundation for this federation, as they refer to themselves by, is known as the Australian Constitution. This written document acts as the basis for which how the government can operate and what it can do. Under the Constitution, the Australian Government is a federal