Targeted Killings In The Fight Against Terrorism

1485 words - 6 pages

Introduction
Just ten years ago the United States publically condemned Israel’s use of targeted killings against Palestinian terrorists. Martin S. Indyk, the former American ambassador to Israel, said in a statement on 5 July 2001, ''‘The United States government is very clearly on the record as against targeted assassinations…they are extrajudicial killings, and we do not support that.’'' However, after September 11th, the US makes frequent use of the controversial tactic in the global war on terrorism. In addition to the numerous moral and legal ambiguities, there are significant doubts that targeted killings are effective in deterring and defeating terrorism. In Israel, targeted killings have often resulted in increased animosity, surges in violence, and provided a recruiting tool for terrorist organizations. Unfortunately, these effects are consequences of overusing the tactic. The United States must learn from Israel’s mistakes and use targeted killings as a last resort, after every opportunity to capture a terrorist leader is exhausted.
The United States policy of targeted killings drew significant public scrutiny after American born cleric Anwar Al-Aulaqi was killed by a drone strike in late 2011. During several months of debate, many scholars, lawyers and journalists accused the U.S. of executing one of their own citizens without the benefit of due process afforded by the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution. Finally, last week on 5 March 2012, Attorney General Eric Holder publicized the Obama Administration’s position in a speech at the Northwestern University School of Law. Holder stated, “The Constitution guarantees due process, not judicial process,” inferring that due process occurs during the Executive Branch’s deliberations on whether or not to conduct the targeted killing. Georgetown University’s Jonathan Turley criticized this interpretation of the constitution “’as the very definition of authoritarian power’” At the very least, this liberal definition of “due process” is a compromise of democratic principles for ensuring security. However, both American and Israeli citizens have made it clear they are willing to make concessions on democratic principles for a perceived sense of safety. Unfortunately targeted killings, whether targeting U.S. citizens or foreign nationals, are only a short term victory and may actually hurt a country’s anti-terror campaign in the long run.
Problems with Targeted Killings
Israel’s targeted killings of Palestinian terrorist leaders often result in increased animosity from sympathetic Palestinian citizens. Commonly used methods of targeted killing involve dropping bombs from fighter aircraft, setting explosives, and shooting Hellfire missiles. Although these methods are effective and reduce the potential for friendly casualties, they are also very indiscriminate and often result in innocent civilian casualties. When Israel targeted Hamas leader Salah Shahada in 2002 with a 2,200 lb...

Find Another Essay On Targeted Killings in the Fight Against Terrorism

The Fight Against Pollution in China

728 words - 3 pages Polluting companies around China might be forgiven for feeling under pressure: they have good reason to be after China announced the latest measures to fight environmental damage. On February 11, news came out that in 2013 China's environmental watchdog blocked 32 projects – the combined value of which amounted to 118.4 billion yuan ($19.5 billion) - on the ground that they had broken rules protecting the environment. Zhai Qing, the vice

the fight against hate Essay

1722 words - 7 pages duty to punish conduct that we find reprehensible, conduct that we believe is wrong. And who of you will stand and tell me that conduct based on hatred and bias and prejudice is anything but wrong” (The Hate Debate). Making laws against hate crimes is the first step in a fight against hatred. If these laws are continued and even pushed further, each state will see a positive effect over time. Works Cited "The many kinds of hate crime

The Fight Against Homelessness

1024 words - 5 pages you are disrupting the peace on the streets. Who to turn to when everybody has given up on you is going to be a hard decision. We, the more fortunate, need to come together to fight against homelessness. Imagine being in their shoes, scared, lost, cold, and hungry. In this paper, I will talk about the facts and statistics of the homeless, organizations providing and protecting them, the causes that put them where they are and different shelters

The War Against Terrorism

1041 words - 4 pages the United States, and supported by the United Nations, a new war on terrorism has begun. Overwhelming support worldwide has surfaced as President Bush has vowed to punish those who decide to commit terrorist acts, as well as those who harbor or condone these activities. So far Bush has followed through on his promise with the war in Afghanistan against the Taliban regime. Others are also displaying their understanding of the situation and are

Smoke in the Eye - The Fight Against Big Tobacco

965 words - 4 pages could prove that B&W did in fact know about the potential health hazards of cigarette smoking, yet continued to deny them for over thirty years. Professor Glantz released the documents into the UCSF library archives for all to see and study, and B&W launched several suits against Glantz and the university in a desperate attempt to retrieve the stolen documents, however they were unsuccessful in each and every case.Upon the release of the

Security versus Liberty In the US fight against terror

982 words - 4 pages from 1995 with numbers from today. In 1995, 57% of the people asked were willing to give up some liberties in the fight against terrorism, but in 2013 only 40% said that they were willing to give up some liberties. One would think that when terrorism has hit the society and the treat for new terrorist actions are high, they would fight terrorism with all means. But the result shows us that they are less willing to give up liberty now than

Problems and Solutions in the Fight Against Urban Poverty

4430 words - 18 pages Problems and solutions in the fight against urban poverty Introduction – the advent of capitalism and the resultant economic inequality There can be no talk of modern poverty without talking first of capitalism, and as such, the capitalist model of production and the exploitation of labor is where I will begin my paper. Capitalism evolved from the feudal system, which was incorporated into western European societies hundreds of years ago

The World's Fight Against Microbes

2036 words - 8 pages remain potentially lethal. By 1982 fewer than 10 percent of all clinical staph cases could be cured with penicillin, which is a dramatic shift from the almost 100 percent penicillin susceptibility of Staphylococcus in 1952. Most strains of staph became resistant to penicillin’s by changing their DNA structure (Garrett 411).      The fight against staph switched from using the mostly ineffective penicillin to using methicillin in the late

The Fight Against School Violence

2404 words - 10 pages to fight in school. Parents might fear that their teens may become more aggressive or even more prone to fight. In reality, not all self defense tactics are fighting with fists, in many situations it is better to give the attacker what the want to try and defuse the situation rather than aggravating them further. Students will learn many techniques to try and prevent a situation before it becomes violent (Gavin). However, If the situation is

The Fight Against Child Pornography

2341 words - 9 pages against complete censorship. What seems more feasible is a sort of multi-layered approach to regulate illegal and harmful content on the Net. This would make it possible to form some sort of insulation for children while keeping in place the adults rights to view this material. It would also leave the ability to fight offenders of illegal content such as child pornography. Pornography on the Internet can be found in a wide array of forms. There

The Fight Against Gun Control

1685 words - 7 pages the right to bear arms. Guns have been in America for a very long time, and some people would like them gone because they think firearms are not needed anymore. While other people believe that guns may be needed for many reasons. There are arguments for and against gun control laws. Self defense and protection, but also people think that we need gun control laws to prevent violence and shootings. Self defense is a key argument point for those who

Similar Essays

The Global Fight Against Terrorism Essay

1377 words - 6 pages Despite spending billions of dollars to fight endless wars, global terrorism rose 43% in 2013. As a result, terrorism has been brought to the fore of not only the American mentality, but the international mentality as well. Consequently, we must do a few things in order to maintain our sanity, dignity, power, and security. We must retaliate forcefully and successfully. We must garner support for our cause and give

Canada's Fight Against Terrorism Essay

1131 words - 5 pages The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines terrorism as “the use of violent acts to frighten the people in an area as a way of trying to achieve a political goal” (“Terrorism”). Terrorism is a problem that all countries should be concerned with. Canada has been one of the countries that are concerned with the safety of people against terrorist attacks. Canada is very concerned with the issue of terrorism, it has a very specific position of counter

America's Futile Fight Against Terrorism And Isis

1103 words - 4 pages wage a guerrilla war against coalition forces and their domestic allies. A U.S. counterterrorism campaign, combined with Sunni efforts to maintain local security, known as the Tribal Awakening, led to AQI violence diminishing for a few years. Unfortunately, since U.S. withdrawal in 2011, the group has increased assaults on mostly Shiite populations. These targeted orchestrations are seen as an attempt to birth violence from the tension between

To Fight Or Not To Fight ( Terrorism In The Usa )

779 words - 3 pages speak in their language, namely terror. We should take extreme steps against these people.The other expressed concern is getting the right people. Although we are ninety nine percent sure we know who did this, by foreign intelligence, our own investigation and captured Muslimism people here, still we wait. The solution seems simple. Take the word of our allies. If you are a hold out because that's not enough, then back track the activities of