School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice Essay

3089 words - 12 pages

School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice

Since entering office in January, President George W. Bush has given education reform high priority on his agenda. One element of his four-point initiative involves the implementation of school vouchers. A voucher, as defined in The American Heritage Dictionary, is a "certificate representing a credit against future expenditures." (The American Heritage) By diverting tax dollars from public schools to private institutions through the use of vouchers, America's public education system will become less effective, students from low income families will be set further behind, and the First Amendment will be directly violated.

The conservative economist Milton Friedman first suggested the concept of school vouchers in 1955. He laid out a plan, "to return tax monies to parents of school-aged children for tuition use in a variety of authorized public and private educational settings." (Noll 193) Now, President Bush embraces Friedman's philosophy with his four-point education initiative. In his plan, Bush advocates (1) annual testing in reading and math in every primary grade; (2) empowering schools and school districts to implement reforms; and (3) federal government assistance in transition to higher standards. Most significantly, Bush says in his final point, (4) "If any school consistently fails to meet minimal standards for three consecutive years, vouchers will be offered so that children can go to the school of their selection, rather than the choice of the government." (Thomas 1) For the most part, liberal Democrats, such as Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, agree with the first three elements of Bush's proposal; but party lines are drawn over vouchers (Thomas 1). Under Bush's proposal, students attending public schools that fail to meet minimal standards for three consecutive years will be granted a $1,500 per year voucher to assist low-income families in covering the expense of after-school tutoring or private school tuition (Brownstein 2).

Over the past ten years, a few voucher programs have been put into effect in some states. In 1990, the first American voucher program was developed in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The program, after many court challenges, is still operating today with an expanded number of children who qualify to participate (Knowles 1). Six years later, Cleveland, Ohio, adopted a similar voucher plan, which was found to be unconstitutional by a U.S. district court judge in December 1999. That same year, Florida passed a law allowing students, regardless of income, to receive up to $4,000 toward private school tuition if the public schools they currently attend get F's from the State Education Panel in two of four successive years (Knowles 1). However, the program continues to operate pending further judicial review (Knowles 2). In Congress, voucher programs have met a considerably higher degree of opposition. An appropriations bill that called for an experimental plan for tax support of...

Find Another Essay On School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice

Vouchers and School Choice - First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System

1936 words - 8 pages School Vouchers:  The First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System On November 9, 1998, Jennifer Marshall, Education Policy Analyst for the Family Research Council, declared in a press statement: "Parental choice in education just got a green light from the Supreme Court." Her statement came as a response to the decision made the same day by the Supreme Court to deny a petition for a writ of certiorari in Jackson v. Benton, a

Vouchers and School Choice More Effective than Affirmative Action

797 words - 3 pages based on equality of opportunity. The best way to accomplish this is to implement a nationwide program of school choice.   A school choice program at the elementary and secondary level would produce revolutionary results. The underclass (all races) would gain the opportunity to develop the skills necessary to enter the middle class. A school choice-based educational system would help break the cycle of poverty and give parents the

School Vouchers - A Great Relief!

875 words - 4 pages can be saved. This funding can also help them in putting their children in the school of their choice. It has also been put forward by a lot of African Americans that getting these school vouchers is a part of their civil right. According to Mr.Wasow, 29 years of age and the executive director of, the main goal is to provide the equivalent quality of education to the African Americans as their white Americans classmates get

The Admissions Committee would like to learn why you are a good fit for your undergraduate school choice (College of Arts and Sciences, School of

635 words - 3 pages While in high school I watched a Biomedical lecture of Yale University and recalled the professor saying that most people of today benefited from living longer when compared people alive in the early 1800s or prior to that time. He mentioned that due to the lack of technology and hence scarcity of research and knowledge people died of many illnesses which would have been curable in today’s society. This was the first time I have heard this

Vouchers Are Not the Solution for Improving Public Schools

1762 words - 7 pages directly aid religion because the vouchers are given to the parents, whose choice it is to enroll their children in a religious school or a nonsecular school. That can not cover the fact that public money ends up in the hands of religious schools. Opponents of vouchers argue that vouchers degrade public education in a number of ways. Most voucher supporters hold the incorrect opinion that the public school system is failing. Supporters use this

School Vouchers

1461 words - 6 pages School Vouchers      School vouchers can be described as financial funding given to students who elect not to attend public schools. Therefore the government would not be spending money educating that student in a public school. A school voucher is the allotment of money that the government would have used for that student to attend public school. This money is then given to the family of the student to help fund the education of that

Should Tuition Vouchers Be Available?

522 words - 2 pages feel better about schools is if they have the choice to choose what school their child would attend. The parents then get the say and it puts the choice back to child-centered funding. This would then be a happy medium, and we would not abandon the public schools.The view of whether school voucher can help or harm children will always be around. I am a public school teacher, and believe that the money taken away from public school would effect


1627 words - 7 pages Century. 23 Sept 1998: 857."Public Education: A Monopoly No Longer." US News and World Report. 25 June 1998: 25.Rouse, Cecilia. "Private School Vouchers and Student Achievement." Quarterly Journal of Economics. v113 (1998) 553-603.Noll, James Wm. Taking Sides, Dushkin Mcgraw Hill, 1999 Shapiro, Walter. "Pick a School, Any School." Time. 3 Sept 1990: 70-71.Skillen, James W., The School-Choice Controversy. Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1993.

School Vouchers

720 words - 3 pages teachers as well. Vouchers do not guarantee that a child will attend his or her choice. School vouchers are set up to help out struggling families or families who qualify. Vouchers can be given to help out families with financial need but there are not set up to cover the total cost of a private tuition. Low-income families will still need to make up the difference. If families do find a way to complete the difference, their children can still be

School Vouchers: Allowing Parents to Choose What School Their Child Attends

1881 words - 8 pages receive funding from the government. Though the Arizona senator’s campaign website is surprisingly lacking in details, throughout his political career, McCain has shown strong support for school vouchers as an appropriate system of choice for parents. He argues that opening the education market will increase the quality of American education. There is little argument over whether or not the dismal American school system needs improvement

Pros and Cons of Inner City School Vouchers

1812 words - 7 pages by the government to send their children to a school of choice, whether that school is public, private or religious (School Vouchers). In effect, it separates the government financing of education from the government operation of schools. Sweden and the U.K. both have an educational voucher system in place (School Vouchers). Another form of vouchers is the means tested school voucher program. “Within the United States Cleveland, Milwaukee

Similar Essays

School Vouchers: Parents Need A Choice

4626 words - 19 pages choice for students and parents. School vouchers will level the educational playing field in many communities across America. Voucher systems are designed to give parents a choice when considering schools for their children. With many of our public schools considered failing, parents will receive a certificate for a predetermined amount to supplement educational costs for parochial/private schools. It is my strong opinion that school

A Case For Vouchers And School Choice

1063 words - 4 pages . No longer would parents, primarily low-income parents, remain in the predicament which has crippled them for so long. Not only would parents recognize poor schools, but empowered with vouchers, they would be able to forbid their children from attending such institutions on a merely geographic basis. Parents would actually exercise their intrinsic right to direct their children's education. School choice animates parents into becoming active

Vouchers And School Choice Beats No Choice

842 words - 3 pages maximize their learning success.   The ideal choice program, in my opinion, would comprise vouchers, drawn from the child's home district and not exceeding the average amount spent locally per student. A voucher or draft is awarded upon the completion of an in depth interview of both student and parents, guardian or assigned mentor and an interview board consisting of school board and local business representatives, and nominated tax payers

The Problem Of Vouchers And School Choice

1138 words - 5 pages children passing each other on the street on their way to schools composed of people mostly like themselves.   Could you talk me into choice? Perhaps if substantive reforms were made first. In a perfect world, students could choose among schools equal in facilities, security and quality of instruction. They would make choices based on specialties of programs -- one school might focus on theatre, another on science enrichment, still another in