Once Upon Today: Teaching For Social Justice With Postmodern Picturebooks

888 words - 4 pages

Brittney L. Neff
Professor Jackie Stallcup
English 595PB
February 10, 2014
Critical Response Journal
In her article “Once Upon Today: Teaching for Social Justice with Postmodern Picturebooks,” Kathleen O’Neil argues that children, both in and out of classroom settings, would benefit from postmodern picture books because this genre of books not only disrupts the cultural concepts and roles that picture books traditionally evoke, but allows children readers to challenge their understanding of certain social norms and expectations conventionally used in picture books. O’Neal asserts that students who are subjected to postmodern picture books are being asked to think critically about the “status-quo” and this could result in the students reaching a greater awareness of the world around them and the roles that could potentially play in it.
Immediately prior to stating her argument, Kathleen O’Neil discusses the use of postmodern picture books by teachers in order to prompt students into questioning and debating issues within their own personal lives. She then transitions into stating her argument in the third paragraph of her article in the last sentence. She says, “This article examines the use of postmodern picture books in classroom settings to spark discussions that lead to greater awareness on the part of the students of the world around them and the possibilities of their roles in it” (41). Immediately after stating her argument O’Neil initiates a separate section of her article titled “We Turn to Storytellers,” where she discusses the advancement of the current world and how postmodern picture books are responding to these changes.
The opening of Kathleen O’Neil’s article is a discussion of children’s picture books being used throughout history as tools to teach children cultural expectations. O’Neil mentions that children’s books have historical significance in behavioral codes ranging back as far as the seventeenth century, with Charles Perrault as an example, and how they are still used today as a guide for social expectations that readers internalize. This opening functions as a foundation for understanding not only the traditional roles of picture books, but as an illustration of how they are both similar and dissimilar to postmodern picture books. Alternatively, O’Neil closes her article with a single paragraph that is sectioned off from the rest of her article, titled “Conclusion.” In her conclusion, she reiterates previous points made in regards to postmodern picture books being used in a classroom setting. She focuses on the importance of using these texts to give students opportunities to think critically about social expectations and imagine different ways “of being.” The closing of this article functions as...

Find Another Essay On Once Upon Today: Teaching for Social Justice with Postmodern Picturebooks

Role-Play: A Strategy for Teaching Social Studies

1779 words - 7 pages Role-Play: A Strategy for Teaching Social Studies One of the reasons social studies is viewed as a tough academic discipline is the result of force-fed historical dates and data. It is also one of the reasons that students think history is boring and irrelevant. Furthermore, their inability to relate to the culture and people of the past creates a what-does-this-have-to-do-with-me attitude early on in their education that directly

Teaching Strategies for Students with Autism in Mind

1716 words - 7 pages In the past, teachers had to learn new strategies for teaching disabled children through the use of trial and error. However, the teachers of today are asked to effectively teach ALL students using research-based strategies in inclusive classrooms that encompass both traditional students’ and special education students. The following paper will include instructional strategies and methods which are essential for the success of not only

Effective Teaching Strategies for Students with Intellectual Disabilities

902 words - 4 pages Heward (2009), community-based instruction is an excellent way for students to increase likelihood of the generalization and maintenance of a new skill. Once simulation training is done in the classroom, teaching in the actual setting with real stimuli helps students become more independent. It is also important that skills are taught and practiced over and over with feedback that is, “specific, immediate, positive, frequent and differential

Instructional Methods for Teaching Math to Students with Learning Disabilities

1525 words - 7 pages Instructional Methods for Teaching Math to Students with Learning Disabilities Introduction to Learning Disabilities Learning Disability is a recognized category under the Individuals with Disability Education Act (IDEA) 2004. Students identified as having a Learning Disability after undergoing an Initial Evaluation, are approved for the support of special education services. Under the IDEA all student, regardless of their disability, have the

Social Skills Training for Children with Autism

3953 words - 16 pages Social Skills Training and Children with Autism: Does Teaching Children with Autism Social Skills Improve Their Relationships with Peers? Overview of Autism Children with autism have social skills deficits, which cause them to not socialize with their peers or learn from their peers (Carpenter, Soorya, & Halpern, 2009). In general, children with autism do not attend specialized schools for their needs. Instead children with autism attend

Using a Particular Service User Group Critically Analyse the Theoretical Principles with Regard to Social Justice and Social Exclusion

1956 words - 8 pages its impact on social upheavals will be discussed. This piece of work will conclude with a discussion of how social inclusion and social justice can be attained perhaps through provision of training courses and jobs for school leavers who cannot join further education due to lack of qualifications. Teague and Wilson (1995:79) suggested that Social exclusion is an idea that has affected how social policy is implemented, without any significant

Criminal Justice Reform / Speech Paper with Outline and all Supplements. The need for extreme criminal justice reform in California

2714 words - 11 pages eliminating incarceration for all non-violent offenses and requiring victim compensation and community service, resources can be committed to preventing crime rather than to the feeding and housing of offenders.E. This is consistent with the findings of the legislature and is cost efficient, requires minimal systemic change, and increases public safety and security.IV. The ProposalA. 'Our current criminal justice system appears to be based upon the

"Teaching with a Multicultural Perspective." Submitted for Intro to Education Class

2313 words - 9 pages ." Instructions for steps 1, 2, and 3 should be given at once. Allow 8-10 minutes for participants to complete all three steps, but remind them with 2 minutes remaining that they must fill in the stereotype sentence.4.Probe the group for reactions to each other's stories. Ask whether anyone heard a story she or he would like to share with the group. (Make sure the person who originally told the story has granted permission to share it with the entire group.)5

Dr. Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar and his Quest for Social Justice in India

1972 words - 8 pages One of the major problems in India has been the great differences between castes. These differences occurred mainly for religious reasons, but when does it stop being religion and where does it start being an unjust difference which leads to social discrimination and inequality. Dr. Ambedkar was a strong believer in social justice and how certain religious beliefs where interfering with the quest for social justice. Dr. Ambedkar itself was born

Brief report: measuring the effectiveness of teaching social thinking to children with asperger syndrome (AS) and high functioning Autism (HFA). Journal of Autism & Developmental Disorders

1074 words - 4 pages of Mind. People's ability to adjust to another person's perspective normally develops in children early. For children with AS or HFA, this process is confusing and painstaking. Social thinking is related to social cognition and promotes the teaching of the 'why' behind socialization without targeting social skills. This report examines the usefulness of teaching a social cognitive/social thinking approach to six males which have Asperger

Identify the key elements which account for the success or failure of social movements. Discuss with reference to examples

1757 words - 7 pages "The overthrow of an existing government, ... the installation of traffic-calming measures in a suburban street" (Abercrombie, 2000: 324), the nuclear disarmament movement, the stop the war coalition, all are examples of social movements. A social movement, as defined by Tarrow (1994: 4), is 'collective challenges by people with common purposes and solidarity in sustained interaction with elites, opponents and authorities'. This shows that

Similar Essays

Paper On Teaching For Equality And Justice

1020 words - 5 pages Americans faced when they were forced to move out of their homes or that there was resistance even from the Supreme Court. Pang also mentions that Chief Justice Marshall ruled in favor of the Cherokee and Andrew Jackson still went along with the plan to move the Cherokee anyway. This sort of fact is usually not mentioned in history or it is glossed over to focus on what is perceived to be more important. This kind of teaching can plant the seed about

Teaching Strategies For Students With Disabilities

1769 words - 7 pages strategies in my classroom. One noted that once she took her time and repeated a rhythm multiple times “[the students] would finally echo you” (Gerrity et al. 2013). This study was great for confirming the strategies I had already learned, but I found some flaws with how I could apply them in my setting. I hope to be in a secondary setting, but most of the students with disabilities were still in elementary school. There is less time in a middle

Bilingual Education: Social Justice For All

2970 words - 12 pages -school literacy programming. These methods deny minority students the right to use their language in educational settings, with which they could preserve their culture, and achieve academically. In order to establish the educational equity that is a pre-requisite for social justice, implementing two-way bilingual education is necessary in communities such as Goshen, where linguistic minorities are widely represented. Language is an intrinsic

How Do Poets Explore The Subject Of Emotional Attachments To Different Things And People In Remember By Christina Rossetti, Once Upon A Time With

2023 words - 9 pages and laugh with their eyes” to the forced action of “laugh[ing] with their teeth”. The comparison amplifies the bitterness of others to create a hostile atmosphere, emphasizing on his reasons for having an attachment to his childhood. Once Upon A Time uses past tense to show the persona’s regrets and indicates the theme of nostalgic attachment of past times. Third person and elementary-level phrases are used to suggest that the persona is speaking