Obedience To Authority Essay

1132 words - 5 pages

During the Vietnam War, a unit of American Army soldiers invaded My Lai a South Vietnamese hamlet resources contended was the enemy Viet Cong stronghold. That day in May 1968 an estimated 347 unarmed civilians “including women and children” died as a result (Cantrell, 2007). My Lai became one of the most controversial situations of the long Viet Nam War. When the truth came out due to letters to the government describing the horror, two questions resulted. Understanding why some of the young American soldiers that day killed so many innocent civilians and why did so few in the unit try to save the lives of as many as they could require moral clarity. Though obedience to authority has hurts and killed innocent people, but lack of moral clarity is the crux of what happened in My Lai, Vietnam in 1968.
Americans want moral clarity. Moral clarity is often more of a testament to the idea than a living reality. In the case of the My Lai incident, America faced a moral dilemma in trying to understand what went wrong, why it happened. Testimonies during the trial that ensued of those who participated in the massacre induce more questions than provide answers. “Beyond parading our moral presumptions, we come to believe we act more morally the less we think about it”, says Cotkin (2010, pp 1).” Kendrick, (2006) offers, “Nearly forty years on, however, the status of the massacre as historical pivot is unclear, not so much because it is explicitly contested, but because its memory is muted” (Kendrick, pp 37). Ending a war, keeping America free assumes these are moral actions, but what is acted upon to achieve this in the face of what is moral then becomes “problematic”. Accepting there is an inherent difficulty in acting morally in certain situations is the lesser road traveled to “moral enlightenment”. One suggestion, according to philosopher Hannah Arendt is to start “thinking.”This offers a certain direction for considering what actions lead to what consequences and remains another road less traveled. Bombing of civilians by Americans during WWII and the tragedy of the My Lai massacre of Vietnam brings the realization that “morality-evil, empathy, and virtue” are components of this dilemma that creates the truth in paradoxes (Cotkin, pp 2).
When the My Lai massacre reported at the hands of Army Unit Charlie Company came under military investigation, soldiers who were in the village that day, under oath gave testimony. Army Specialist 4, William Frederic Dougherty was asked if civilians were routinely the victims of cross fire when the fighting between the enemy Viet Cong was in a village and he replied that sometimes this happened if the Viet Cong were located behind the village firing through toward the Americans (Dougherty Testimony, 1969). He explained, “Well, sir, it has happened…they fire through village to us and it puts us in a bind where (we) don’t want to fire into a village – and they (villagers) can get as many casualties. The...

Find Another Essay On Obedience to Authority

Obedience to Authority by Stanley Milgram

2669 words - 11 pages Stanley Milgram’s 1963 studies into obedience have provided important and shocking insights into the power of authority. The study set out to discover how obedient people really are. Debate and controversy have surrounded the study since the results were first published. Predictions made by psychologists before the experiment proved dramatically inaccurate. The experiment led volunteers to believe they were administering increasingly painful and

Obedience to Authority vs. Personal Conscience

849 words - 3 pages Stanley Milgram, conducted a study focusing on the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. According to the study Migram suggested “that obedience we naturally show authority figures can transform us into agents of terror” (Migram, 1974/1994, p. 214). Milgram experiment was developed for the justification of the act of genocide in World War II. Many of the accomplices in the Holocaust said they were following in order

Obedience to Authority as Showcases in A Few Good Men

2320 words - 10 pages psychologist, also explores obedience to authority in his essay “ The Perils of Obedience”. On the other hand, Erich Fromm, a psychoanalyst and philosopher, focused on disobedience to authority in his essay “ Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem.” Milgram wrote about how people were shockingly obedient to authority when they thought they were harming someone else while Fromm dissected both: why people are so prone to obey and how

Do They Really Go Hand In Hand? An interpretive analysis of language and obedience to authority

774 words - 3 pages understanding, support and communication. This shows us how opinions about the same subject can greatly differ from person to person as well as how the language associated with a term follows one's opinions about that term. There is another term that is closely associated with authority - obedience. Is it always absolutely necessary to be obedient to authority?Obedience - following the rules - is perceived by society as the virtuous thing to do. However

A Brief Summary of Milgram's Seminal Research on Obedience to Authority

1537 words - 6 pages power of the immediate situation, social psychologists generally view the fairly high levels of obedience to authority displayed in Milgram's classic experiment as the paradigmatic example of evil behavior (Berkowitz, 1999). Reading about the work of Ross and Nisbett, 1991 (as cited in Berkowitz, 1999, p. 247) stated that “social psychologists, by and large, do not think of evil actions as the product of evil personalities. Rather, they

MY LAI MASSACRE AS A RESULT OF OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY. Relates to stanly milgrams experiments and how authority play a part in genocide killings

1215 words - 5 pages MY LAI MASSACRE AS A RESULT OF OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY The Vietnam controversy made many people feel at distress. It was never considered a "war," although that is exactly what it was. The My Lai Massacre in Vietnam was one of the many atrocities of that war. There is an unquestionable connection between Milgram's "Obedience to Authority" and the My Lai Massacre. According to Kelman & Hamilton, "Unquestioning obedience has been the cause of such

Any interpretation of obedience to authority, whether good or bad, or examination of the phenomenology of obedience to authority will lead a reader to make judments on human nature

1566 words - 6 pages conducive of life and what is destructive of life. This conscience serves our functioning as human beings" (Fromm 379). Readers tend to make judgements on what is a negative situation rather than what is positive. In the area of obedience to authority, both come with a high price.

A synthesis of conscience vs. obedience

956 words - 4 pages conscience vs. ObedienceWhen individuals relinquish their own autonomy for the benefit of the larger group, they are no longer individual but products of conformity. Obedience to authority can become dangerous when morality and independent thought are stifled to the point that harm is inflicted upon another person. "The Perils of Obedience," by Stanley Milgram reports on his controversial experiment that tested how far individuals would go in

Summary of the Dilemma of Obedience

616 words - 2 pages Summary of The Dilemma of Obedience In the chapter "The Dilemma of Obedience" of the book Obedience to Authority : An Experimental View, Stanley Milgram explores the concept of obedience to authority, and why people cannot defy authority even the situation is totally conflicting with morality. He introduces his ideas by giving the definition of obedience, and mentions Nazi extermination as an instance of obedience, which contradicts with

Frankenstein

1824 words - 8 pages , falling through a dark tunnel with no sense of direction or time, I closed my eyes tightly. Whenever the spinning sensation concluded, I opened my eyes. The aroma was stronger here, forcing tears out of my eyes and my dinner back up my throat. I knew exactly where I was… In recent discussions of Frankenstein, an issue has been whether the characters struggle with obedience to authority. Some argue that the characters react to circumstances at

Obedience at its Finest: Milgrams Study

1351 words - 6 pages Would you harm another person against your better judgment just because someone of authority told you to? Stanley Milgam’s experiment of obedience was unique in that he wanted to find out if there was a link between obedience to authority and Nazi Germany by conducting an experiment that required one to shock someone else because they were told. The experiment, though slightly extreme, was effective despite what some might think in determining

Similar Essays

Obedience To Authority Essay

1568 words - 7 pages follow orders as directed by authority, even when it seems like lethal actions could be involved in the situation. People sometimes can`t say ‘no’ in circumstances that requires an answer of no. As a preventative measure to help assist in better decision making, people need to learn how to accurately weigh and balance obedience, disobedience, and authority for best results. Obedience is about following a set of rules, which helps provide

Obedience To Authority Essay

860 words - 3 pages The presence of an authoritative figure is present in nearly even human being’s life; along with this, is the expectation of obedience to that authority. Through this obedience, many great things have been accomplished, as well as many instances of cruel and immoral acts. Defiance of the established authority, though, has also lead to great things, such as the creation and founding of the United States of America. In his writing, Obedience to

Stanley Milgram’s “Obedience To Authority” Essay

791 words - 4 pages In 1961, Stanley Milgram, a Yale University psychologist, conducted an experiment that tested the obedience of a person to an authority figure. According to simplypsychology.org the experiment started a year after the start of the trial for Adolph Eichmann. Eichmann was on trial for his involvement in World War II and was eventually charged on counts of war crime and crimes against Jewish people. Milgram wanted to answer if Eichmann and many

Discuss Milgram’s Study Of Obedience To Authority

1050 words - 4 pages York.’ (Zimbardo, 2010) Milgram’s study of obedience was an experiment that looked at how ‘ordinary citizens obey the orders of an authority figure if those orders meant physically harming an innocent person’ (Milgram, 1974). He conducted ‘18 studies between 1960 and 1963’ so that he then could examine whether people would obey authority figures that involved giving innocent people electrical shocks of up to 450 volts. One of the