Identity Crisis Essay

1010 words - 5 pages

Identity, from Latin identitas (“sameness”), can be defined and understood in multiple ways in different contexts. However, regardless of the definition used, the general concept of identity always concerns a relation or relative state between things or people. This holds true in different contexts where the term “identity” is used as well: mathematics, philosophy, psychology, etc. The existential nature of defining identity may lead to many issues in the perception of oneself and of others as the relative properties of identity are always changing and shifting – an identity crisis. It is this exact property of identity that Rebecca Walker chronicles in her memoir Black, White, and Jewish; ...view middle of the document...

In reading Walker’s experiences, a reviewer may be inclined to believe that he or she may have acted differently, or criticize Walker for not taking advantage of her unique, multicultural background to further the contemporaneous Civil Rights Movement. However, this is largely the result of many cognitive biases. Criticisms such as Ralina Joseph’s “Performing the Twenty-first Century Tragic Mulatto” highlight these biases and the effect they have on the reviewer’s own perception of Walker as an individual, despite only having all but a brief insight into the author’s life as presented and chronicled in the book.
Other critics, such as Julius Lester, see an incongruence with Walker’s use of the term “autobiography” in the title of her memoir as he believes Walker lacks sufficient understanding of herself (Lester 2003). Though a valid criticism, this perceived lack of self-insight arises when reading Walker’s experiences episodically instead of considering the entire work and the overarching theme of the “shifting self” as Walker is forced to develop and mature. In their reviews and criticisms, both Lester and Joseph focus on the dissonance between what Walker writes and what she attempts, in reviewers’ minds, to portray herself to be. This is an important aspect in relational identity in that there exists a relationship between reader and author. Objective criticisms of a literary work are nearly impossible for this exact reason. Though the title of Walker’s memoir explicitly states the “shifting self” theme and Walker’s unabashedly upfront embrace of her ability to shift, many readers find fault with the seemingly apparent immaturity Walker displays in her writings. However, this same ability to perceive social cues, to change one’s behavior to match cultural norms and mores, is indicative of a greatly advanced stage of psychological development and social competence. The main issue many readers might have regarding this may arise from Walker’s lack of “sugarcoating” when writing of her experiences and her methods of changing identity – her exploitation of the relativism between self and...

Find Another Essay On Identity Crisis

Identity Crisis in Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury

755 words - 3 pages In the novel "Fahrenheit 451" by Ray Bradbury, Guy Montag doesn't want to be ignorant. He wants to understand the reason why the society is unhappy and burns the books. As Montag struggles between his identity crisis of being a fireman and seeking change, he wants to be knowledgeable. Montag's identity crisis of being a fireman makes him to question who he is. Montag notices that the firemen have the same appearance as himself

Identity Crisis and Spirituality in John Updike's Rabbit, Run

1682 words - 7 pages other hand, the article “Young Man Angstrom: Identity Crisis and the Work of Love in Rabbit, Run” by David Crowe explores Rabbit’s journey to find his true identity, the relevance of Christian faithfulness in the novel, and how ethical misconduct has an effect on both. These articles both investigate the effects Rabbit’s actions have on his spiritual journey as well as if he even has the ability to achieve his goal. These articles differ in that

Canada's Ongoing Identity Crisis: What Are We Now?

1830 words - 8 pages Canada is really big, and this causes a unique problem. Canada has an identity crisis. The Spicer Commission (Spicer, 1991) showed us that by giving us the Canada Clause, essentially stating Canada is one nation and a dual nations, three nations and multicultural, centralized and decentralized. All of these identities are equally supported at different times in history. For example, directly following The Great Depression, public support for

The Crisis of Identity

1553 words - 6 pages Why is it that man needs to compare himself to others in order to define himself? Is man able to form a society where only the necessary connections between individuals are the most basic fundamentals of the human condition? The world we live in is vast with a web of social interconnections, and we can no longer just identify ourselves in simple terms. When one is born, he or she is not simply brought into a family identity, but along with that

Identity Crisis for Yellowknives

2537 words - 10 pages Yellowknives were dispersed to Fort Resolution, Yellowknife, and other areas of Canada.As can be seen and verified through historical records the original Yellowknives continued to be the largest tribe in the north until the 1900's, verified by the historical treaty documents. From the 1920's through the 1940's the Yellowknives still retained their true identity and were well known by the names of: "Yellowknives, Redknife, Copper, Indians". The

A western identity crisis

934 words - 4 pages This country was founded by immigrants and is known for its population from a wide array of cultural backgrounds. Living in a westernized society that is so diverse, we are forced to choose an identity for ourselves at one point or another in our lives. Some choose to identify by their outer qualities, while others may identify by their inner qualities. One may identify by their looks, gender, sexuality, political views, or their beliefs. Some

Castell's Postion Regarding African Americans and the Identity Crisis They are Facing

2379 words - 10 pages crisis that they are experiencing (or were in the 1990s). Furthermore the state of ethnicity within South Africa will be described followed by the comparing and contrasting of Castells’ position regarding the identity crises between African-American and the state of ethnicity in South Africa. Through the application of Marcia’s theory a argument that a similar situation to the African-American situation will arise in South Africa will be made

National Identity Crisis in Margaret Atwood’s Through the One-Way Mirror

806 words - 3 pages National Identity Crisis in Margaret Atwood’s Through the One-Way Mirror National identity is one of the most important factors in maintaining a country. It defines one’s nation, culture and everything associated with that country. When it comes to Canada, however, it seems that our national identity has been lost. In Margaret Atwood’s essay “Through the One-Way Mirror,” she effectively questions Canada’s national

The Polemics Of Identity And Crisis: Rabindranath Tagore’s Ideas Of Civilisation And Modernism

3427 words - 14 pages century life both at microcosmic and the macrocosmic levels. The scandal created by Sandip in the home and the world brings the narrative to delve into yet another means of identity formation by the crisis of faith and mutual understanding in the familial set up. In the words of Supriya Chaudhuri: “Bimala’s relationship with Sandip is based on a confusion of inner with outer, a confusion that is present in his corrupt version of a nationalist ideology

This report was written by Travis Weigel, "America's Identity Crisis." It talks about political correctness or lack of common identity in the USA

559 words - 2 pages . Go to the local schools, ball games, city meetings, and other local gatherings and listen to the Pledge of Allegiance being said by everyone there.Do we know what it means to be an American? Can we stand up and say the Pledge of Allegiance? Yes, we can and with pride. We know what the meaning of unity is. We do pull together in and out of times of crisis. We have and will never lose our identity. When people start criticizing America, maybe

The Partition of Indian Subcontinent: Crisis of Identity and Uprooted Nationalities Resulting in Double Disaster for Pakistan

2127 words - 9 pages valley civilization are largely glossed over except in the tawdry publications, India produce for the benefit of the few foreign tourist who venture here. Those contortions have resulted in a major identity crisis that has robbed at least two generations of their creativity: by cutting the people out off from their real roots. Pakistani ideologues have fabricated a nation that is unsure of its position in the region and the world. One reason why

Similar Essays

Identity Crisis Essay

1054 words - 4 pages The major concept of “American Dreamer” is about the identity of immigrants. Mukherjee says, it an “identity crisis” which “one’s identity was fixed, derived from religion, caste, patrimony, and mother tongue”. Because of her families religious tradition, Mukherjee is embittered by her permanent identity in her own culture, “a Hindu Indian’s last name announced his or her forefathers’ caste and place of origin…a Mukherjee could only be Brahmin

The Identity Theft Crisis Essay

935 words - 4 pages The Identity Theft Crisis The crisis of identity theft has dramatically increased due to people using their credit cards on the internet. Hackers are tapping into large corporations and gaining access to millions of people’s credit card information (Bray and Yadron 2). One’s identity is never safe and can be stolen easier than they may think. As identity theft rates increase, it becomes more dangerous. The government, along with many large

Homelessness And Identity Crisis In Poetry Of Tabish Khair

1735 words - 7 pages Tabish Khair is an English writer in English whose concerns are about India even though he has settled in Denmark. He belongs to state of India which is entirely different in language, culture and tradition as compared to the European nations. He is a poet whose poems deal with small town culture, and experiences. His style is simple, rich in metaphor and irony. Concept of identity crisis and anxiety is a new emerging trend in world literature

Identity Crisis In Amy Tan's "Joy Luck Club"

958 words - 4 pages women, although in different ways. Some of the women experience this crisis through self-doubt while others experience this through passiveness. Some of these struggles with identity cause these women to be too passive while others fear that they have become too American and have lost touch with their Chinese heritage. The daughters particularly seem to be unable to reconcile the Chinese and the American parts of their characters.In the relationship