Films As Primary Sources For History

1024 words - 4 pages

Films as Primary Sources for History

If a picture is worth a thousand words than how much is a moving picture, or movie, worth? In the study of history, the usage of movies as primary sources is controversial. Motion pictures are more commonly well-known as sources and created for entertainment purposes. Film is a creation of a reality. This has some valuable resources for the study of history in many respects. They may or may not be representational, and some may include writing or printing. Some can be categorized as fine art, others as documentary record. Originality may or may not be important, and the content may or may not be the primary focus. History is made by people - in a sense that it is written by people positioned in time and in location, living under a certain political regime, in a certain cultural arena, and having an access to certain interpretative schemes.
There are many different types of films. Documentaries and news (newsreels in some instances) are one of the most widely recognized and less-controversial in the study of history since their purpose is not purely entertainment but instead the exploration of an aspect of the world around us. In many respects, they are exposing history as it is happening. Yet with even these films, it should be realized that they are the interpretation of the director/producer, the camera angles are chosen, the people interview are chosen, the information portrayed is chosen. Yet it still retains its advantages. This is the past at its most immediate, valuable for its record of social and cultural life (even if inevitably somewhat distorted in its art form by its purpose as something other than an accurate record). News footage has recorded, both for the cinema newsreel and for television the recent history of past wars in great detail; some of it is readily available on commercial videotapes and increasingly on multi-media CD-ROMs. The weekly newsreels have now been replaced by the much greater immediacy of television. In essence, this is history recorded at the moment of its being made - a trade-off between the ultimate in immediacy and the lack of clarity that reflection and a broader time-scale would produce.
Another form of film would be the historical series. These are the types of films produced for educational networks. They historically research a topic, choose how to represent it, and them produce it for a more or less mass audience. These films can prove quite valuable to the study of history for the elaboration of areas of interest. Also they are valuable in bringing to light aspects that many have been obscured before. On the other hand, the fault of these films lie in which information they choose to portray and not portray. Since they are produced for a mass audience, there are also concerns about them being produced accordingly, leaving out parts of information that may be pertinent in light of public interest. The films have the interesting position of being able to...

Find Another Essay On Films as Primary Sources for History

Describing society using three films, Requiem for a dream, fight club, and American Psycho as examples

1772 words - 7 pages the identity of an individual being crushed by the widespread need to fit in with society and be like everyone else. Differences in character, appearance and emotion are created by unique pasts, and form the foundation for personal beliefs. When these differences are erased by society's attempt to create analogous creatures, individualism is lost. I acquired these values from my personal intuition and from taking the advise of personal mentors as

The failure of the State as the primary referent object for security studies

2127 words - 9 pages The belief that the State should be the primary referent object for security studies has for many, become outdated. With the failure of the Westphalian system in the late 20th century , under which States were the primary institutional agents, international debate sparked over issues of sovereignty and the State became less relevant as the primary referent object. The world was changing and as Dr. Javier Solana, Secretary General of NATO said in

"With Reference to Primary and Secondary Sources, Critically Analyse the Reasons for the use of the Atomic Bomb on Japan in 1945"

2765 words - 11 pages single raid. This would "give that shock to the Japanese that was required to bring them to surrender before the bitter fighting of an invasion"However, unfortunately for this side of the argument, there are many counter factuals included. First of all, much evidence was beginning to suggest that the Japanese were very much prepared, after a clarification of the surrender terms, an opinion shared by some of Truman's advisors, such as Joseph Grew

Evaluate empiricism as an ideology and methodology for writing history

1257 words - 5 pages their time. Through the examination of historical practices over time, it has proven difficult to provide society with an accurate portrayal of the truth.Each composer of history has utilised differing techniques to illustrate an interpretation of the past. For example, ancient historians such as Herodotus interpreted history through story telling, incorporating elements of myth, which is a reflection of that societies beliefs, values, customs

Main Contributions of Bede's Ecclesiastical History as a Source for Early English History

631 words - 3 pages There is not a single work along English History that could have been more determinant and indispensable than Bede's Ecclesiastical History. By describing the story of the English people through their experience of Christianity he became our intermediary with the world of Anglo-Saxon England and their believes. Therefore, in what follows an attempt will be made to describe the main contributions of Bede's Ecclesiastical History as a source for

Sources of Capital - Lands' End - Paper covers sources of capital for the company Lands' End. 582 words also includes brief history of the company and link to the annual report

584 words - 2 pages it still resides today. (Hoover's Online, 2003)Sources of CapitalSince the company's sales peak during seasonal times of the year, they need to meet their inventory requirements to obtain much of their working capital. Working capital for Lands' End is generated from company operations as well as short-term bank loans. They are then able to upgrade their assets and purchase treasury stock. During fiscal year 2001, $28 million was spent on

'The history of news since the nineteenth century has been the history of a translation from popular defined as "for the people", to popular as "for the market"'

2744 words - 11 pages 'The history of news since the nineteenth century has been the history of a translation from popular defined as "for the people", to popular as "for the market"' (Hartley, 1982:130). Discuss with reference to examples from today's popular press.This essay will begin by defining the press as popular "for the people". Newspapers were once the bearers of education, in all it's shapes and forms, working for the benefit of the people. Now, the

The History of Micro-Credit as a Means for Development of Poor Nations

1689 words - 7 pages The Indian population lacks opportunities such as financial resources and the ability to get jobs. They are stuck in an endless cycle with no opportunities for people to lift themselves out of poverty. Microcredit has been used as a method by governments in developing countries, international funding organizations and donor agencies, in order to help the poor make money since the 1950’s. During the 1950s and1960s, the Indian government started

AP Advanced Placement U.S. History DBQ essay: "During the colonial period, religion provided the primary rationale for the authority of the king." Task: Assess the validity of this statement

993 words - 4 pages Puritans, the Catholics, etc. This was done because they set certain limits and freedoms according to the way they believed God meant to govern. The colonists used similar concepts to that of England which justified powers of the government with religious support and the supremacy of God as being a primary rationale of its authority. The King of England ruled by divine right, which forced people who were strong followers of their faith to submit to him. Thus, the king had secured his own position.Source: AMSCO United States History - Preparing for the Advanced Placement Examination by John J. Newman, John M. Schmalbach.

What kind of primary source is this and what strengths and weaknesses does it have as a source for your study? (Extract from the speech made by Jacques Roux)

867 words - 3 pages distinguish, where appropriate, between witting and unwitting testimony?From the speech of Jacques Roux it can be learnt in respect to Paris during the Terror,that the districts (assumed of Paris) are famous for their crimes committed by egoistsand knaves (those who are self interested and those of a humble birth). He uses ‘Ahundred times…’ as an unwitting testimony to the fact many crimes if not animmeasurable amount of crimes has been

Discuss the role of History as a political mechanism for social control (reference to Brave New World and 1984

981 words - 4 pages in the novel, the world state ruler Mustapha Mond says, "History is bunk". He knows History well, to see the potential threat. No citizens in the Brave New World get in contact with History. The ideology of the Brave New World is to life timeless in the presence and after Mond's view there should be no History.Another essential factor for the banning of History in the Brave New World is that History is often regarded negatively, which would lead

Similar Essays

Primary Sources For Social Studies Essay

1431 words - 6 pages as for science, mathematics, and language arts. They also connect these practices to Bloom’s taxonomy to provide a familiar foundation for teachers to better understand the concepts. Ensminger and Fry hope that by providing this framework teachers will be able to train themselves to use primary sources effectively as the sources become increasingly available. Passion for the Past (1998) by James Percoco offers creative strategies for history

Primary Sources For Social Studies Essay

1920 words - 8 pages does not allow them to learn analytical skills. (Cleary & Neumann, 2009) Lastly, there is concern for the way students may view history through the lens of primary sources. Often teachers use primary sources to present the stories of individuals that are not as prominent in the typical textbook. Students study these documents and learn how this individual contributed to the overarching event or process. However, the concern is that students may

Primary Sources For Social Studies Essay

2033 words - 9 pages Primary sources have become a popular topic of discussion and interest among social studies teachers and students. Teachers have seen the positive impact they can have on the curriculum and the students. As for students, they have seen history come alive through primary sources. Additionally, these sources have become easier and easier to find as the Internet resources continue to grow. According to Yale (2008) a primary source is an item or

Pompeii: Some Primary Sources For Pompeii And Descriptions Of Thier Purpose. On Funeral And Burial Practices

1226 words - 5 pages used during worship. With these paintings we learn about religious art and the worship of Isis as a god possessions of the priest were also found this helps us understand what the priest does within the temple. The renovation after the 62 A.D earthquake was financed by a freed slave in the name of his young son. There may have been political motivations for this since freed slaves were not allowed to hold public office, and the son who was