Empathy Vs. Compassion Essay

1304 words - 5 pages

Often when using the words of empathy and compassion, many people envision them as having similar meaning. While they may share similar circumstances, they are actually quite different. Empathy is more of an emotional response with an understanding of a person’s particular situation; whereas compassion is an emotion that arouses an active response to alleviate a distressful situation. Nevertheless, these dissimilar expressions are paramount in the way people respond to the individual needs of others and how they reach out to others in their local communities. Barbara Lazear Ascher’s essay “On Compassion” not only creatively offers a very detailed description of the day in the life in New York City, but effectively draws a picture of a community’s response to the homeless while at the same time questioning the very motives that propel certain acts of charity.
Before deciphering what motivates people to help one another, it is vital for one to understand the significant differences between empathy and compassion so that one may draw inferences about their relationship. Firstly, empathy is more of an emotional response to a person’s situation. It is usually evoked by distressing circumstances. One may imagine himself in a similar situation developing in his mind the same emotions as the person he is feeling empathy for. Although he may feel the same emotion, he does not feel compelled to take action to alleviate the pain or suffering for the person he is feeling empathy for. Compassion, on the other hand, is an emotion that takes action. In other words, a person full of compassion is willing to provide another individual with comfort and relief to secure a positive outcome. It is apparent that while empathy and compassion have their differences, they are connected in the sense that they both evoke an emotional response.
Empathy is an innate trait that all humans have and it is the one that we most readily feel, while compassion is a feeling that must be acquired. Ascher astutely points out that “empathy is the mother of compassion” (par.13). In this noteworthy parallel, Ascher compares empathy to a nurturing mother and compassion to the fruit of her labor. Like a mother who has an inherent instinct to protect and teach her young, so too does one have an innate understanding and sensitivity to the feelings and experiences of another, and it is only from these life experiences that the birth of a new awareness is brought forth in the form of compassion. Similar to a mother’s tutelage, Ascher describes compassion as a “learned” behavior that allows one to consciously act upon the distress of others by actively alleviating it. According to Ascher, “Compassion is not a character trait like a sunny disposition. It must be learned, and it is learned by having adversity at our window…” (par.13). In other words, true compassion can only be learned when one is faced with it every day of ones life and that once it becomes...

Find Another Essay On Empathy Vs. Compassion

Honors in Action Project: Many Forms of Incivility

2414 words - 10 pages perception of the effectiveness of bully prevention programs today. Of the surveys sent, 116 survey responses were received and analyzed. The recorded results are as follows: 1) Do you feel you were bullied as a child? 52 YES (45%), 64 NO (55%) 2) Do you feel you have been bullied in the workplace? 37 YES (32%) 79 NO (68%) 3) Do you feel bullying prevention programs are effective? 64 YES (55%) 52 NO (45%) 4) In your home, are empathy and compassion

Euthanasia: The Fight for Life Essay

834 words - 4 pages undertaken with empathy and compassion.” One in six doctors (16 percent) said they have been asked to perform euthanasia with the past five years, according to an article published online by the CMA. (Ontario 1) Doctors are saying that even when being asked to perform euthanasia they were mostly refusing the treatment or were unprepared if asked. This provides shocking evidence that most doctors find euthanasia not as an answer, but rather a bigger

Advancement Opportunities with a Bachelors of Science in Nursing

870 words - 4 pages   Nursing advancements available with a BSN (Bachelors of Science in Nursing) vs. an ADN (Associates of Science in Nursing) are wide and varied as the field of nursing itself. There is truly a niche for every nurse, it just takes a little research. Because it’s hard to know what you’ve never been exposed to. A few of the fields accessible with a BSN, but limited or unavailable to those with an associates or certificate of Registered Nursing are

To kill a Mockingbird

1514 words - 7 pages they need it. At the same time, he also teaches them the importance of courage, compassion, trust and respect. One of the most powerful quotes in the book “You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view — until you climb into his skin and walk around in it.” (pg.39). Atticus uses these words to explain to his daughter the importance of empathy and compassion, and to put yourself in another person’s shoes

Fantasy vs. Reality in J. M. Coetzee's Disgrace

1774 words - 7 pages from the sublime to the ridiculous; people will step over a man lying in his own urine to spit on someone wearing fur. It is not this sort of fanatical expression of concern for animals that is indicative of efficacious compassion, but more a general concern for their actual daily existence, an empathy, an acknowledgement of the soul, mortal, dark or otherwise. Animal ethicists seek to shed light on this soul by inserting normative values where

Moral Philosophy of Global Peace

3441 words - 14 pages global, because it is the foundation of the survival of mankind. Mental peace reveals a state of unshakable quiet and composure, which is achieved through the inculcation of such creative virtues as friendliness, compassion, mercy, moderation, modesty, forgiveness, non-violence, love etc . Most of these virtues imply that "Peace carries with it a surpassing of personality" (3) or abandonment of egoism. It means that even the personal peace

Jewish Philosophy and Social Work

2420 words - 10 pages their lives with this person. Maybe God was even saying in a way that one can not go through life and be complete without a partner. I quote in Genesis (chapter 2 vs.22-23) "and he took one of his sides and he filled in flesh in its place. Then Hashem, God fashioned the side that he had taken from man into a woman". Not only did this end first man's utilitarian loneliness, it also may have been showing us how we should feel about a loved one. The

Want V Need

2080 words - 9 pages conclusion that as a person’s wealth goes up their entitlement and self-interest go up along with it and their compassion and empathy plummets down (“The Sociological basis of Greed” 2). It is safe to say that wealth distracts people from what is ethical and what is not. Another study was conducted where hundreds of rich and poor members of the community were given ten dollars each and given the option to keep the money, or share it with a less

Science, Morality and Responsibility in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

2026 words - 8 pages Science vs. Morality and Responsibility in Frankenstein The most frightening horror story can only be called such if it is believable. Nothing is so unnerving as lying awake at night with very real fears. No monster can harm you, unless the monster was genetically engineered by a mad scientist. The theme of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein - scientific investigation without consideration of morality and responsibility - is a very relevant topic

SME 3 ECTS Project

1986 words - 8 pages could have chosen alternate, cheaper routes to employ seasonal part-time laborers vs. more expensive full-time employees for example, but because of their sense of responsibility for right and wrong, Company policy and guidance specifically promoted ‘the right thing to do’. Core Value III: Love and Compassion Throughout my interactions with the Company’s adult students, as well as front desk receptionists, there is a common core of respect for

Man vs. Nature in Princess Mononoke

4047 words - 17 pages sides for doing what they are doing, and both are unwilling to back down. This causes an eternal struggle between each other, particularly Lady Eboshi and Moro, the wolf God, and Ashitaka as the middle man. This film actually brings several symbolic themes by its twists and turns of the story. It is a simple story, yet it is complex and works on so many levels.   Works Cited David, R. “The Dharma of MIYAZAKI Hayao: Revenge vs. Compassion in

Similar Essays

Compassion Empathy Essay

947 words - 4 pages The two essays “On Compassion” and “This is Water” by Barbara Ascher and David Wallace argue their different viewpoints on both compassion and empathy. While Ascher simply argues that compassion is not a simple character trait but more so a skill acquired overtime; Wallace tries to convince his audience that humans are preprogramed to be motivated by their own selfish desires and must reprogram themselves to think out of sympathy and concern for

Thesis And Outline: How Free Will And Inborn Neurological Hardwiring Influence Morality

1156 words - 5 pages . Ethics = “code of conduct” recognized by group 2. Morals = individual’s interpretation of “code” C. Compassion & Empathy 1. Compassion = emotion we feel when others are in need a. Motivates our response to help 2. Empathy = ability to feel the emotions of others III. Brain development A. Humans develop in the same order of events (from fertilization to birth throughout development) 1. Emotions are an innate part of human nature 2

A Comparison Of The Monsters Of Frankenstein, Bladerunner, And Star Trek The Next Generation

1648 words - 7 pages Victor's unconscious self becomes a reality when the monster kills Elizabeth when Victor shuns all compassion to help his creation. Because of the lack of empathy on Frankenstein's part, resentment builds up in both the creator and the creation to the point that total hatred consumes them both. Frankenstein himself denies the similarities that are so apparent between Frankenstein and the monster when he says to the monster, "Begone! I will

Motivational Interview Essay

1415 words - 6 pages , 2007)Health professionals engaged into MI must also possess certain characteristics like empathy, compassion, and authenticity for them to be able to bestow an idyllic ambiance of security and support to their patients. Health Canada (2002) outlines the acronym FRAMES to conceptualize the approach.. To wit:F- Feedback to clientsR - Responsibility for changeA - Advice on harm diminutionM - Menu on the stipulation of optionE - Empathy to clientS