Electoral College Outdated Essay

1024 words - 4 pages

Every four years, the century-old debate over the Electoral College rekindles. Currently, as the contest between the Republican candidates intensifies and the remaining four rush toward the finish line for nomination, speculators are turning their attention toward the Presidential Election that is right around the corner. Predictably, the legitimacy of the Electoral College is once again under scrutiny. Although the Electoral College was an ingenious compromise establish by Framers of the Constitution, the development of the two party politics and the “winner-take-all” system has led it to the fail its original purpose.
When the Framers were drafting the presidential selection procedure of the Constitution in 1787, they presented an artful compromise to the issue of direct election. With the new country spanning thousands of miles along the Atlantic coast and barely connected by transportation or communication, it was impractical if not impossible to distribute information widely enough for every citizen to make an informed choice (Kimberling). In a direct election, this lack of knowledge about candidates living in other states would inevitably result in citizens voting for the candidate they knew the most about. Because the larger states have considerable more voters, presidents would be elected not for their political beliefs, but for their place of residence. Given the inability to spread information extensively, the Framers compromised by adopting the idea of representation. The people up and down the country would vote for local delegates with whom they were familiar with. These electors would then elect a president “pre-eminent for ability and virtue” (Hamilton 333). By devising the Electoral College, the Framers ensured the voice of the people be heard while letting a few elite individuals choose the President of the United States based on their own judgment after careful deliberation.
In fact, as Justice Robert Jackson states, the Framers of the Constitution established the Electoral College with the purpose “that electors would be free agents [who can] exercise an independent and nonpartisan judgment [and thus choose] the men best qualified for the Nation's highest offices” (Ray v. Blair). With electors coming together to vote for president, the Framers wanted to maximize the will of the people. However, the American party politics and political system have change so much in the past 200 years that the Electoral College is no longer holding up to its initial intent.
One of the problems the Framers did not foresee is the rise of the political parties. As these political organizations developed at the end of the eighteenth century, electors pledged to a certain party appeared. Today, it is the parties in most states that wield the power to choose their respective slates of electors (Longley and Braun 28). The existence of these electors, with their pledge toward a party, makes the ideal that free representatives should vote according...

Find Another Essay On Electoral College Outdated

A speech disputing the electoral college

1112 words - 4 pages national campaigns. Today the Electoral College is outdated. The majority of Americans are for direct popular vote. An amendment must be added to the constitution to eliminate future inequalities between states, inaccurate distribution of votes, or questionably victories. And in closing, for all you bush supporters, this speech was not presented by an angry Gore supporter still pissing and moaning over his defeat. On the contrary, I was a Bush

Electoral College vs. Popular Vote Essay

1909 words - 8 pages former political officer in the 1800's, states that a it would be "as unnatural to refer the choice of a proper character for chief Magistrate to the people, as it would, to refer a trial of colours to a blind man" (qtd. In Glennon 7). I became very interested about the whole system of the college and thought that I could present an argument about how it's really outdated and could use a big change. And so the Electoral College is created. It is

The Electoral College: A Blemish on Democracy

1159 words - 5 pages The United States is considered one of the most democratic nations in the world. Why do the people not choose their own president? This is a good question. People have a right to choose their leader. The electoral college should be abolished because campaigns focus too much on states with lots of electoral votes, the leader of the people should be elected directly by the people, and it is an outdated and unfair system. The electoral

The Electoral College: Passing the Test of Time

1456 words - 6 pages criticize that the Electoral College was formed 225 years ago and that it is outdated. Before the invention of the T.V. or Internet, word did not travel quickly enough. This reason largely contributed to the formation of the Electoral College. If the presidential election was based on the number of votes a candidate receives, individuals may vote for a name that he or she recognized rather than the person who is best qualified for the job. Although

Elimintating the Electoral College

1661 words - 7 pages Elimintating the Electoral College Judging by the way things are looking with this year’s election, the Electoral College is not benefiting American citizens. People fight both sides of the system, but the truth of the matter is that although the Electoral College has been in place for over 200 years, Americans are still not sure how it works or if it is the best method. Our country is supposed to be a symbol of democracy, but to this

Election Problems

1852 words - 7 pages against the Electoral College. For instance Colorado attempted to pass an amendment that would change the way the electoral votes are counted within the state. Within this outdated system a candidate could win the majority of the popular votes but still not win the election. This is taking away from the voice of the American people. There are many flaws because of the way elections are conducted. There are two arguments in favor of the

The Electoral College Should Be Abolished: Persuasive Research Paper

2518 words - 10 pages joke. There isn't a candidate who doesn't use every source of exposure including everything from television advertisements to grassroots campaigning. It has become a staple in the election process. In addition, Electoral College actually corrupts campaigning, causing candidates to focus mainly on "swing states" and suburban areas (Abolish the Electoral College).Not only are the origins of the Electoral College outdated, they are also corrupt and

We Should Abolish the Electoral System

2510 words - 10 pages of a joke. There isn't a candidate who doesn't use every source of exposure including everything from television advertisements to grassroots campaigning. It has become a staple in the election process. In addition, Electoral College actually corrupts campaigning, causing candidates to focus mainly on "swing states" and suburban areas (Abolish the Electoral College).Not only are the origins of the Electoral College outdated, they are also

Character Analysis for Parris in The Crucible

952 words - 4 pages untruthful ones. The Electoral College was created so long ago that it is now outdated, so we shouldn't even have electors, after all the Constitution of the U.S. is a "living document". People of the U.S. may think that they are participating in a direct election for the president, but with the Electoral College system technically, this isn't the case. I believe that the Electoral College should be done away with and a new system be devised.Having

The Electoral College Should Be Revised

1409 words - 6 pages The Electoral College Should Be Revised As citizens of the United State of America, one of our most important rights is that of which to vote. By voting, the general population has a say in who its leaders are. Votes for local, state, and even federal representatives directly reflect who the constituents want in office. However, America’s highest office is not elected by a vote of the people. Instead we use a confusing and outdated system


1320 words - 5 pages candidates but those from their own states, it would have been very hard for any candidate to win a national majority of votes. Times have changed, and the American public is much better equip to seek out and receive information. Our Electoral College System, however, remains largely outdated. Although it is popularly understood that members of the Electoral College will vote for the candidate the majority of those they are to be representing voted

Similar Essays

The Electoral College: An Outdated And Flawed System

1376 words - 6 pages of functioning with this outdated and flawed system; however, it would function more efficiently if the system was replaced with a system that allowed the president to be elected by a direct popular vote. The only way to accomplish this completely would be to pass an Amendment. The Electoral College is the current system for electing the next president and the process is as follows: a direct popular vote is conducted in each state – each of

The Unfairness Of The Electoral College

925 words - 4 pages majority of electoral votes instead of a majority of popular votes. That is because some people’s votes are worth more than others. Even though the Electoral College system is in place since the birth of this nation, it is severely outdated because of it is not fair. In fact, there is already talk about abolishing this system because of these reasons and with petitions already made to try to get rid of it, the Electoral College’s downfall might not be far off.

The Past, Present, And Future Of The Electoral College

1775 words - 7 pages In the United States, the Electoral College determines the victor of a national election. Each state has its own number of electoral votes, which is determined by state population. This system is a “winner takes all” system. Which means the candidate with 50 percent or more of the votes in an individual state gets all of that states electoral votes. The 2016 presidential election will have 538 electoral votes, this means that the election will

Electoral College Essay

1274 words - 5 pages realize is that the Electoral College actually elects the President, not the individual voters. The Electoral College is an outdated, flawed institution that does not reflect the majority of the country’s opinion, and, therefore, it should be abolished and replaced by a direct election, or at the very least it should be reformed, using a method called “Allocating the Electoral Vote.”      This system of presidential selection