East Geman Border Guard: Let Him Go.

2158 words - 9 pages

My fellow justices of the court, we find ourselves at a crossroads, advised to convict of murder a man whose prior government would have lauded, not punished, him for his actions. We must weigh the unjust loss of a human life against the injustice of convicting a man under an ex post facto law. Hans’ death is a terrible tragedy, but we must rule with respect to our system’s principles and reverse the lower court’s decision.

This man’s former superiors, both his commanding officers and his government, emphasized that, whatever happened, it was better to kill a man than let him escape across the border. The border guard’s government pardoned the use of deadly force against any man attempting to commit a felony within a border guard’s sight. Commanding officers instilled in their subordinates a special hatred of escapees. Border guards were taught that escapees were treasonous defectors running off to East Germany’s worst enemy to let out state secrets. Commanding officers even taught subordinates to regard escapees as dangerous people who would kill border guards. At the border, there were memorial rooms set up in honor of border guards killed by escapees. Given the environment, it is understandable that the border guard would choose to kill Hans.

It is important to note that the border guard shot Hans while performing his duties as a soldier in the army. The East German government gave this border guard a firearm to use should dangerous or combative situations arise. A government never gives its soldiers guns and then charges them with murder for killing enemy combatants. This border guard saw Hans as a traitor, a spy for West Germany, someone possibly dangerous – something along the lines of an enemy combatant. Shooting at Hans was not a murder but a necessary act of war. We cannot punish a man for performing the actions his country and government required and encouraged him to do. For example, if a guard prevented an escape, even if a killing resulted, the government rewarded that guard with cash rewards, medals and special leaves of absence.

There was some shame in killing a person, however. The government removed the offending guard’s name from the service record, and the guard did not wear army clothes or insignias to avoid societal ostracism. The government had a blanket media blackout on any escapee deaths along the border. In an almost Orwellian fashion, all evidence of killed escapees’ existences were expunged, their families told they had committed suicide.

Besides covering up the killings, the East German government also refused to prosecute guards who killed escapees, even in instances of excessive force. Though East German law permitted use of deadly force only when an escapee was joined by multiple perpetrators or tried to escape using “dangerous means,” it was an unwritten rule that guards should shoot and kill escapees rather than allow them to escape. This law descended from both commanding officers’ insistence on...

Find Another Essay On East Geman border guard: Let him go.

Berlin Wall Essay

1300 words - 6 pages declaring all-out war so they decided to shut down the blockade in 1949. During this time many people were flowing in and out of East Germany with borders that were relatively easy to bypass. Finally after being embarrassed by the sheer number of people who were crossing the border daily the Soviet Union decided to do something about it. In 1961, the first efforts to make the Berlin Wall were being made. The original wall took only two weeks to

The Fall of the Berlin Wall and the Disintegration of the Soviet Union

1305 words - 6 pages flocked to the Wall. Once they saw there was no one going through the border they began to demand the guards let them through. With the guards being heavily outnumbered, they had no choice but to start letting people through the border (“Fall of the Berlin Wall: 1989”). When the East Germans finally made it across the West Germans were waiting on the other side with opened arms. During their celebration of being back together, some citizens stared to

The Separation of Germany

838 words - 3 pages 65th birthday to go to the West to visit their families. From 1971 there was relief for the German-German relations. The border – also known as the “anti-fascist protective wall” – became passable again for foreign currency for the citizens of the Federal Republic of Germany and for the Berliner, also for those people who came to Schönwalde. The way across the “Steinerne Brücke” was closed for them furthermore. The opening was long in coming

The Wall Came Tumbling Down

1370 words - 5 pages endanger West Germany, he let his secretary off to go to a ball game, and went sailing. West Germany was the only concern of the United States, as Foy Kohler of the State Department said, "After all, the East-Germans have done us a favor. That refugee flow was becoming embarrassing." If America had known that a simple show of force at the wall construction site would have prevented 28 years of death and suffering for East Germans, maybe the reaction

The fall of the Berlin Wall and the disintegration of the Soviet Union

850 words - 4 pages construction of the Berlin Wall (“Berlin Wall”). The Berlin wall was built to divide the post World War II communist ran East Germany with the democratic West Germany. On that day families in Berlin were woken up to military machinery, barbed wire coils, and armed guards. The families that had crossed the newly made border the night before to visit friends and/or family were greeted by a wall and closed transit systems (“Berlin Wall”). For them this

Berlin wall book review on the

819 words - 3 pages The Berlin Wall: Book Review In August 1961, Berlin, Germany was seperated by a border of barbed wire. People of East Berlin could no longer enter West Berlin. The Berlin Wall tells about this event and what led to this event. Norman Gelb, the author, tells of the actions of the communistic East Berlin and the democratic West Berlin. The book begins by explaining how the wall was put up. East Berlin put it up because of the

Cyrus the Great

2468 words - 10 pages at important locations around the empire that allowed him to not only put an end to rebellions but to also guard his trade routes. At first the army was composed of Persians who had been drafted, but later it was also made up of hired soldiers. In times of war, soldiers from the entire empire were drafted (Persian Empire, Ancient Near East). In addition to maintaining control of his empire with his military, one of the main reasons for Cyrus’s

Importance of Border Security

1166 words - 5 pages . The new visa system requires that all new applicants go through an interview and an extensive background check if deciding to travel, study, visit relative or conduct business in the U.S. Applicants must have secure documentation such as a passport or something of equivalency whether they are a citizen or noncitizen all are required to have such information. Another change over the years that has helped border security is the fingerprinting to

The Shadow

1011 words - 4 pages south-east to Carthage the capital of men.Dan's squad made it to the border and then to Carthage without trouble, they then went directly to the palace and were joined by Lord Dalnther in the throne room."Do you have it?" Lord Dalnther asked."Yes," replied Dan revealing the stone to Lord Dalnther. "Ahh... Earth," he exclaimed "come, let us celebrate." "We now have Earth and Wind," Lord Dalnther said placing the stone on the middle of the table next

A short timeline and reason why the Berlin Blockade occured (during 1948)

557 words - 2 pages only 6 feet tall with barbed wire at the top. However it was hastily reconstructed with observation towers with flood lights, machine gun nests, and guard dogs. To reduce bad publicity, the East Germans said they would allow movement from the two sectors. Yet, during the twenty years from 1961 to 1981 there were only 37,800 cases of people being let through, and there were 100 reports of people shot trying to climb it.Finally, during November 1989 the border was opened again. And nearly a year later on October 3 1990, Germany was reunited.

The Innocent Australian

1049 words - 5 pages ..y..yes, sorry what…what’s the go with this?” “This is a random security check.” John placed his bag onto the bench ambiguously. The security guard gestured to John to unzip his bag. Once opened, the guard noticed a document sitting on top of the other items. He continued to scan his way through the contents of the bag, and then ordered John to spread out his arms for a body scan. The guard then detached the swab from the scanner, and placed it

Similar Essays

Chester Himes’ If He Hollers Let Him Go And God’s Little Acre By Erskine Caldwell

1816 words - 7 pages Chester Himes’ If He Hollers Let Him Go and God’s Little Acre by Erskine Caldwell It has long been contested that works of great Literature have certain qualities and that they belong to an exclusive canon of works. Value is placed upon them for a number of reasons, including their reflection of cultural or social movements, the special meaning they possess, and even their use of specific narrative elements. Up until recently, scholars

The Do's And Don't Of Border Patrol

656 words - 3 pages know if you are free to go or if you will be detained. If you are being detained they will let you know the reason. At this point since you are being pretty much arrested you will be given your Miranda rights and taken into custody. At this point you are allowed to remain quiet and contact your attorney. Border patrol has 32 permanent check points which are check points that are always there. In California the “permanent” check points are San

The Berlin Wall And The Holocaust

1559 words - 7 pages of the wall. The other one which was named Peter Fechter did not succeed like his friend as he began to scale the wall a guard opened fire. He continued to climb the wall but as he reached the top he couldn't go on any further and fell back on to the east side. The guards did not shoot at him anymore and they did not go to help him they just let him lay there. Peter shouted in pain. Ater he had bled to death the guards carried off his body.Peter

Protecting The U.S. Mexican Border Essay

1404 words - 6 pages east coast. The west had gold and silver and a lot of other natural metals that brought the attention from other countries and ethnic groups. From the area of the entire modern day Mexican bored and US border had a lot of silver discovers from the 16th century to the 19th century. The area was technically a Spanish owned colony but with no one virtually there to guard it and no one was there to settle or tell others otherwise the area was up for