Democracies Are More Likely To Win “Total Wars” Than Totalitarian Regimes.’

2177 words - 9 pages

The term ‘total war’ has been attributed to a small number of conflicts. The term was originally coined by the German military officer Erich Ludendorff in his book ‘The Total War’. Previous to this the renowned military theorists Carl von Clausewitz and Antoine-Henri Jomini both touched on the raw principles of ‘total war’, but failing to ever recognise the term Ludendorff went on to fashion. It was not until the 1950s that the term re-emerged to describe the nature of the conflict during the First and Second World Wars, whilst a number of wars previous to this have characteristics of ‘total wars’, the primitive state of national economies and refusal to fully mobilise the economy purely for war can explain why these conflicts were more ‘limited’ than ‘total’.
Historians suggest that despotic central power regimes were catalysts towards their own downfall as a result in their lack of ability to effectively run and motivate the home front and military during times of conflict. The state of Austro-Hungary during the early 20th century exemplifies this, beset with internal frictions and hostilities even during the First World War. The problems faced by the Hapsburgs in Austro-Hungary were encapsulated by Stephen P. Duggan who stated “Austria-Hungary is doomed unless she resolutely applies a surgeon’s knife and cuts down deep, cuts out the cancer of race strife with all its roots” . It was without question the lack of representation for the numerous ethnic groups in Austro-Hungary which accelerated its collapse in 1918. More recently, historians have suggested the nation’s problems could have been solved by introducing a democratic “self-government for each of the races and federalism for the empire” , indeed, by the outbreak of war in 1914; the Hapsburgs were already clinging on to power, a distinct absence of democratic procedure along with a nation suffering from a lack of self-identity was integral to the empire’s dissolution.
When analysing the principal differences between the governance of democracies and totalitarian regimes during times of war, there are a number of factors which support the argument that democracies are more likely to win conflicts. For a start, as Dan Reiter and Allan Stam illustrate “when governments must answer to the will (and anger) of the people, they start only those wars they are confident they will win” . The very nature of democracy attaches a level of accountability to the government, and this politician-citizen link is crucially maintained, which usually reassures citizens and prolongs their support for the administration; something that is a fundamental characteristic especially for war-time governments. It follows from this that democracies are rarely driven by the ideology of a single figure, and if such a person is apparent, their views and opinions are usually counteracted by other officials and colleagues. Leonard Schapiro speculates that, “had Hitler been born, say, in a Buckinghamshire village...

Find Another Essay On Democracies are more likely to win “Total Wars” than totalitarian regimes.’

If inequality is increasing, are we likely to see more armed conflict?

2353 words - 10 pages with the probability as well as duration of civil wars. In high income countries the opportunity costs of going to war, disrupting industries and destroying livelihoods are too high. Collier and Hoeffler’s claim is underpinned by Bueno de Mesquita’s (1985) work which showed that those perceiving they have nothing to lose are more likely to go into conflict. This supports the thesis that inequality in itself is not crucial for the outbreak of

Can Geneics Cause Crime - Are genetic factors more likely to make one person violent?

806 words - 3 pages otherbiological factors, most likely will be contributed to otherthings such as alcoholism and addictions rather than genesbeing blamed for the violent behavior. Diana Fishbein, ofthe US Department of Justice states that, criminologistsneed to call for more research into behavioral disorders andattention disorders and certain other temperamental traitslike impulstivity that might be more likely to turn upbetter results in the fight against crime.Sources

If inequality is increasing, are we likely to see more armed conflict?

1596 words - 6 pages discriminating apartheid laws and sought to achieve this goals through boycotts, strikes and civil disobedience. The hope was to cause mass arrests with which the apartheid government would be unable to cope. During the campaign, more than 8,000 people were arrested while violating apartheid legislation, including Nelson Mandela, and Walter Sisulu (SAHO a, no date). Despite the defeat of the resistance and a subsequent iron-fisted government response

Response to “Are Dogs more Intelligent than Cats?”

694 words - 3 pages leaf of lettuce).” Coren adds that another factor “is how social the animals are.” Animals that socialize and interact are smarter, this is why dogs have been found more intelligent than cats. Cats are more independent and much less sociable. This causes them to have less chances of gaining intelligence. In recent data it was found that dogs are more subjected to newer demands, which increases their intelligence. Because of more demands put on

Zoos are Doing More Harm Than Good

655 words - 3 pages Zoos are public parks that claim to display animals for the purpose of education and procreation of endangered species; but in reality Zoos area actually doing more harm than good. Animals that live in zoos are more likely to suffer from illness or injury as opposed to those who live in the wild, and they also have shorter lifespans. Even though some zoos have an endangered species exhibit with the intention of protecting and rehabilitating

Are women more polite than men

3834 words - 15 pages male speakers interact with one another, in different contexts ranging from informal conversations to more formal meetings, interviews, seminars and so on. Many linguists have conducted studies of gender and talk, in which they have documented several specific features of conversational style that are said to differentiate between female and male speakers. Examples of these are:Amount of talk: male speakers have been found to talk more than

STAR WARS MOVIES ARE BETTER THAN STAR TREK MOVIES

805 words - 4 pages has better weapons, 2. STAR WARS has better villains, 3. STAR WARS has better music, and finally, 4. Star Trek is less of a motion picture ICON than STAR WARS..... The first point of argument I’d like to express is that the STAR WARS films have far better and more impressive weapons than Star Trek. Not only is this shown by the death star, a massive display of weaponized strength, but by how the centerpiece weapon of Star Trek, the phaser

Video Games Are More Useful Than You Think

986 words - 4 pages games provide player with numerous benefits. More than hundred reasons that make video games violent are good for people who really love to play an action video game. Video games create benefits for players both directly and indirectly ways. First of all, the clear advantage of video games is a video game introduces children to computers and the internet technology because nowadays most games are involved with the internet. (Farrales) Then the

Traditional Classrooms Are More Effective Than Online Learning

2309 words - 9 pages talking to peers, students find others who share their study habits and can help them study their material more efficiently or in a way that makes more sense. Without this face-to-face interaction, these peer study groups are not likely to form. Online classes do not allow for this in person peer collaboration, and thus closes off online students to the additional help and viewpoints that other students could provide. Online classes isolate the

"Words are more powerful and treacherous than we think" J.P.Sartre

624 words - 2 pages language for ages. Many words possess a double meaning, hence if we would like to express something we ought to remember about choosing an appropriate context in order to shun being wrongly-understandable.It is my contention that words are more powerful than we think that they are, moreover the vast majority of us do not realize of both significance and how treacherous words are. I am sure that everybody has ever been in touch with being wrongly

Race and Intelligence - Are different races more intelligent than others?

655 words - 3 pages status, which in the United States remains lower for those of African than of European descent."So how much can we trust the relationship between IQ and race? We see Asians are culturally encouraged to do well in school. Does this mean they are the smartest Americans or that they are better at taking tests? Or is it the environment that has a drastic impact on how well we do in school? If all races had the same upbringing, the same economic means

Similar Essays

What Are The Main Reasons Why Women Are More Likely To Be In Poverty Than Men Since 1945

455 words - 2 pages Causes of Poverty to WomenThe feminisation of poverty has meant a higher percentage of women than men are likely to experience poverty throughout their lives (TUC). Society views a husbands income as primary to be shared amongst the family and a wife's role as domestic worker and carer (Brown: 1983). The male control of economic power within the family can cause unequal resource access, with acute cases resulting in a wife's poverty when her

Democracies And Their Tendency To Be More Peaceful Than Authoritarian States

1655 words - 7 pages . Conversely, regimes featuring constitutional government, liberal freedoms, and democratic participation are naturally unjust."[1] Therefore can we assume that as authoritarian states are unjust they are more inclined to be hostile and that democracies being just are less inclined? The international political environment may be a great influence on why hostilities occur between authoritarian states rather than democratic

Are Today's Terrorists More Likely To Use Chemical And Biological Weapons?

3899 words - 16 pages and federal emergency services workers. While the "victims" are usually volunteers or Boy Scout troops fulfilling their community service requirements, the drills provide essential training for local emergency services workers, who will likely be the first on the scene in the event of a real attack. Such exercises are part of the Defense Department's Domestic Preparedness Program, which will spend more than $40 million to train and evaluate

If Inequality Is Increasing, Are We Likely To See More Armed Conflict?

2540 words - 10 pages more rapid mobilisation. This shows that even after the transition and the elimination of the grossest forms of discrimination, given the right circumstances, violent outbursts can still occur. However, one should refrain from likening the Marikana massacre to the 1960 Sharpeville massacre as some commentators did (Magaziner, 2013:138). The political channels to choose one’s government were barred in those days, whereas now, people are free to