Confronting Images Essay

1599 words - 6 pages

Georges Didi-Huberman is critical of the conventional approaches towards the study of art history. Didi-Huberman takes the view that art history is grounded in the primacy of knowledge, particularly in the vein of Kant, or what he calls a ‘spontaneous philosophy’. While art historians claim to be looking at images across the sweep of time, what they actually do might be described as a sort of forensics process, one in which they analyze, decode and deconstruct works of art in attempt to better understand the artist and purpose or expression. This paper will examine Didi-Huberman’s key claims in his book Confronting Images and apply his methodology to a still life painting by Juan Sánchez Cotán.
In Confronting Images, Didi-Huberman considers disadvantages he sees in the academic approach of art history, and offers an alternative method for engaging art. His approach concentrates on that which is ‘visual’ long before coming to conclusive knowledge. Drawing support from the field of psycho analytics (Lacan, Freud, and Kant and Panofsky), Didi-Huberman argues that viewers connect with art through what he might describe as an instance of receptivity, as opposed to a linear, step-by-step analytical process. He underscores the perceptive mode of engaging the imagery of a painting or other work of art, which he argues comes before any rational ‘knowing’, thinking, or discerning. In other words, Didi-Huberman believes one’s mind ‘sees’ well before realizing and processing the object being looked at, let alone before understanding it. Well before the observer can gain any useful insights by scrutinizing and decoding what she sees, she is absorbed by the work of art in an irrational and unpredictable way. What Didi-Huberman is saying is the so-called traditional methodology and scholarship of art history actually distracts from the initial incidence of seeing or beholding the ‘visual’. He might say the formulaic approach misses the whole by focusing so much on the parts.
One way to illustrate this conceptual approach is to walk stepwise through Didi-Huberman’s thought process, in the context of a specific work of art. This paper will examine a work by the artist Juan Sánchez Cotán (1560-1627). How might the viewer incorporate Didi-Huberman’s thinking on the ‘visual’ versus the ‘visible’ in regards to engaging images? First, we must recognize that how a person experiences an image is dependent on past experience. That is to say, varying situations and contexts greatly affect the way in which images appear to someone. Consequently, no one person or art historian can claim absolute sovereignty or certainty in deciding what an image actually means, or was intended to mean. His approach for the understanding of images stresses the experience of the art itself to guide one’s appreciation, which is scarcely resolved with the recognition of the importance of social and historical contexts.
Didi-Huberman notes that the long tradition of...

Find Another Essay On Confronting Images

Medea's Compelling Character Essay

586 words - 2 pages The play Medea, by Euripides, incorporates many techniques to increase the forceful persona of the protagonist, Medea. She has an overpowering presence, which is shown through the use of imagery, dramatic suspense, and the chorus.Medea is frequently shown with images of violence and rage. ?She?s wild. Hate?s in her blood. /She feeds her rage?Stormclouds of anger.? (Warner, ?) These images suggest hatred and anger. They are powerful emotions and

Essay Comparison The Great Gatsby and The Talented Mr. Ripley

1707 words - 7 pages meaning or purpose. This show in both "The Talented Mr. Ripley," and "The Great Gatsby," symbols and motifs are used and play major roles in the progression of the stories."The Great Gatsby," by Scott Fitzgerald uses many visual images, and similarities and once again so dose "The Talented Mr. Ripley." These images in both novel and motion picture are used to show the distance between the two levels of society. An example of this in "The Great Gatsby

The excess and restraint

1091 words - 4 pages :3). Through an art rich in strange and disturbing images Bosch reflected the concerns of an age dominated by religion and death. Hismysterious paintings were complex moralistic allegories, intended to point out to men the error of their ways. Bosch's art was excessive the conceptual content, as he painted about the vices and corruption of humankind, but he also used elements of restraint to emphasise the excessive elements. Another artist who

Tone of Manzanar and Night

702 words - 3 pages book. She bides by stating mostly facts from events from her past experiences at Manzanar, now and then stating her thoughts and feelings. She begins her memoir by telling the reader she wrote the memoir to raise awareness for the Japanese internment in the 1940’s era, which she handles gracefully, remaining calm while confronting the trauma from her past. “My faith in God and in the Catholic church slipped several notches at that time. But not

Beauty Re-imagined

1274 words - 6 pages While women have made significant strides in gaining more freedom and rights in the past decade, society and culture at large continue to place a great emphasis on how women look. Certain standards of feminine beauty are presented in many different forms of popular media, bombarding women with images that portray what is considered to be the "ideal body”. Consequently, the importance of physical appearance is emphasized early on which leads to

The Human Imagination

553 words - 2 pages that as we age it is more difficult for recollect past events or have the ability to make new ones. According to the study, it shows that some older adults cannot form imaginary scenarios, since their memories are linked to their ability to recall detailed memories. Another case for imagination confronting reality in the elderly would be Alzheimer’s disease. This disease can often cause a person to have delusions and other

The Consequences of Addiction

1146 words - 5 pages seeking healthy interaction and discourages the addict from treatment. Maintaining isolation to avoid the confronting this shame often leads to relapse (Wilson, 1999; Wilson, 2003). The relationship with the addiction “keeps painful feelings and associations… at a distance” and is a way to deny, or at least and avoid confronting, the feelings of shame (Wilson, 2003, p. 281). Wilson (1999) also notes that sex addicts “have learned to unconsciously

Explain how contemporary artists challenge ideas about art

1658 words - 7 pages conventional art forms, confronting the audience. Originating in the 1960’s, from a change in historical and social value systems, Postmodernism is an experimental movement in which artists use a variety of mediums in order to convey high-in-depth messages. To relate cause and effect and to provide reasons how and why contemporary artists challenge ideas about art, photographers Bill Henson and Rosemary Laing need to be considered. Bill Henson

The Others

1204 words - 5 pages front of himself. The real images are passing but they are incapable of turning back, realizing or communicating with them. The voice they hear, if there is any, is just an incomprehensible murmuring.In the scene of children's isolated readings, the den image is apparent. Ann is lying back to the fireplace and "the others" as the real figures, like Victor, come and go. Victor makes sounds, cries, while no one realizes what the true picture is


1222 words - 5 pages and has a better feeling for the events which unfold. (Not part of the essay: the last 2 sentences equate to the term "It was boring as all buggery"). Emma is written in a period where the members of society are extremely well mannered and polite to one another. Contrasting this to America in the 1990's presents two totally different images. America with its confronting approach to life, the frantic pace and the promiscuous nature of

The Unconscious Heroe

1168 words - 5 pages Bram Stoker’s Dracula is a tale that sets its characters on a path of psychological turmoil and heroic satisfaction. The supernatural nature of the vampire as well as its seemingly human form allows one to analyze these characters as being archetypes of the personal unconscious for the human characters confronting them, particularly the shadow and the anima/animus as postulated by Carl Jung in his text Aion. Furthermore the purely human

Similar Essays

Compare Two Poems From The Norton Anthology Sylvia Plath "Lady Lazarus" And "Daddy"

967 words - 4 pages ", Sylvia Plath uses the imagery of colour "Red Fire", "Red Hair" to denote one of her major themes. The colour "Red" is a fierce colour it represents life and vitality therefore it highlights the theme of Re-birth. Plath expresses her need to die in order to be re-born. Here she is confronting her pain through her poetry in an attempt to find internal peace. Images of Lazarus from the bible who was raised from the dead by Christ further highlights this

Stop Blaming Victims For Sexual Assault

2044 words - 8 pages the way we function. The various types of media, especially visual media helps to determine what becomes main-stream in our culture, and this usually affects the society’s behavior. For instance, certain types of visual media promote sexual violence against both men and women; often times they promote stereotypes. For instance, sexual mass media images tend to portray victim responding favorably to their situation after awhile; also they portray

Color Symbolism In Sons And Lovers

1316 words - 5 pages , which echo the conflicts confronting the characters. The three colors and their associated images relate to the emotional states of the characters, and explain the reasoning (or lack thereof) behind their actions. Industrialized England as portrayed in Sons and Lovers corrupts and demeans its citizens under the oppressive burden of hard labor and meager wages. Lawrence uses blackness, darkness, and dirt as symbols of the moral and physical

A Wander Through Wordsworth's Poem "I Wander Lonely As A Cloud"

560 words - 2 pages flower that he is describing. He mentions that the daffodils are "fluttering," "dancing," and "twinkling," such terms make the lines flow with a musical expression. He is able to make the daffodils come to life in a joyous movement making one feel like they are also swaying along with the flowers.One can see that he holds daffodils and nature in high admiration. This poem has a lot of nature images that one can see, such as trees, water, stars, and