Confilcting Ideas Of The Past In Canada

2678 words - 11 pages

Confilcting Ideas of the Past in Canada


He has been called a prophet, a traitor, a martyr, a visionary and a madman, but whatever one thinks of him, Louis Riel, remains one of the most controversial figures in Canadian history. Does this man who has continued to haunt Canadian history for more than a century after his execution, deserve all of those descriptions? After reading three different interpretations of the rebellions, it is still difficult to decide which is closer to the truth. All three authors retold the Metis history and although they differ on crucial issues, there was agreement on the basic facts. The primary difference amongst the three authors was whether the Canadian and Manitoban governments acted in good faith in carrying out the terms of the Manitoba Act, whether John A. MacDonald purposely deceived the Metis as to what Canada’s intentions were with respect to the Canada-Metis Agreement and to what extent were there deceptions in the administration of the Metis land grants. How these three historians attempt to encapsulate Riel’s life, accomplishments, and mistakes is very different. How they attempt to separate fact from fiction and decide whether Riel was justified in his actions against the government is written from three very different perspectives. Where their sympathies lie, how subjective they are and how they interpret the facts is quite evident, but there are many sides to history and every side must be examined if a fair judgment is to be made.
One can surmise that historians have probably debated quite heatedly the rights and wrongs of all the players in the Red River Rebellion, and the Northwest Rebellion. Authors like Stanley, in his book, The Birth of Western Canada believe that the resistances were no more than struggles between “civilization” and “barbarism” because in both resistances, the rebels were the “natives” of the newly acquired territory. He believed that an aggressive, but compassionate, New Dominion had to defeat the “uncivilized” obstacles, because they were resisting progress. The natives had to fail in their stance against the government, because they were a “primitive people”, standing against the march of “civilization,”1 they had to be pushed aside so the new country could progress.
Stanley believes that up until the execution of Thomas Scott, the Red River Rebellion was relatively non-violent and the government probably would have forgiven the Metis indiscretions, because they even continued to follow the process of conciliation through to the passage of the Manitoba Act. “ Although Scott deserved some sort of punishment for his actions against the Metis people, his actions hardly deserved the death penalty.” 2
The execution of Scott was a huge faux pas on the part of the Metis officials and it invited terrible reprisals from the government. John A. MacDonald certainly could not ignore the execution because half the people of his newly formed country were calling...

Find Another Essay On Confilcting Ideas of the Past in Canada

What Are the Changes that Chinese Immigrants Brought to Canada in the Past Decades?

1524 words - 6 pages In the past few decades, an increasing number of Asian immigrants are moving to Canada. “It is well know that many recent immigrants to Canada choose to live in Canada’s largest cities, in particular, Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal” (McDonald, 2004) They are creating a new Canada which is described as the New Pacific. Among all places of birth for the immigrants who come to Canada in the recent years, the People Republic of China is always

Cross Pollination of Ideas in the Crusades

1008 words - 4 pages seems to encourage a higher than normal outpouring of ideas and creativeness. Also the restrictions in effect on certain areas are temporarily forgotten, such as the case with the Nazi medical experiments. These medical experiments were brutal and extremely cruel, but they did help medicine, especially in the areas of amputation and the grafting of body parts. The Crusades were no different in this respect; ideas and customs flourished and were

Ideas of Government in The Prince

2055 words - 8 pages , it is the most rational means of creating a more perfect State. History is littered with examples of good rulers, and with that, numerous examples of bad rulers. There are countless benefits to studying history, and though some may argue about the implications of various events, it is generally agreed that history allows societies and individuals to understand, and learn from, the mistakes of the past. In chapter five of Machiavelli's The

Ideas of Virute in Machiaveli's The Prince

782 words - 4 pages Machiavelli has a consistent teaching about virtue in The Prince, and it is that virtue isn’t something that is consists of being the utmost good, but instead something that is just so amazing it deserves the acclaim of others. The idea of this virtuous act is based off of two main key concepts, which are justice and power. Although virtuous meaning by good people was all well and good and meant to fix things, it was truly whoever had the

The Dirty South Write an essay about a confilcting time in history. Use notes,interviews, and personal experiences

1405 words - 6 pages resulted in the deaths of four innocent black girls, was one of the darkest moments of the Civil Rights Movement and perhaps one of the darkest days in Birmingham, Alabama's history. Betty Blackman was born and raised in Birmingham. Her life was engulfed by the racism and left her with dramatically scaring memories of Birmingham.I grew up in the city of Birmingham, Alabama. I was born there December 11, 1947. Most of the memories I have of

The Legalization of Marijuana in Canada

1969 words - 8 pages 1. Introduction In the prime news on the television, there is plentiful atrocious news of deaths by excessive use of drugs. Often, many entertainment stars in Hollywood have been accidentally killed by excessive ingesting of narcotics, for example, Michel Jackson. Furthermore, in some cases in Canada, when the majority of the companies hire employees, they are usually questions or drug tests the candidates. Unfortunately, the

The rise of violent crime in Canada

2778 words - 11 pages , anger and disparity.This may be the cause for the rise in armed/robbery rates around Canada. It has beenshown that in the past when there have great economic hardships, the rate of violentcrime has increased as is with the present day.Many of the reasons for the increase in social protection and laws has been thatit has been instituted to a higher degree in the Criminal Justice System. Toughersentences are being given out as the state fails in

Analysis of the Mens Movement in Canada

2750 words - 11 pages Analysis of the Mens Movement in Canada With the emergence of the Women's Movement, a deep cleavage was created in gender relations, seemingly pitting women against men in the struggle for equality and status. An effect of this separation in spheres, was a collective of men feeling as if they were being misrepresented, or left behind during a revolutionary period of changing gender relations. A product of this was the conception

The Negative Impacts of Polygamy in Canada

1931 words - 8 pages educational impacts on children being brought up in polygamous families will be examined. Overall, this essay will demonstrate the negative effects of polygamy and argue that its criminalization in Canada is completely justified. Polygamy in Canada: Religious freedom or crime? In Canada, the practice of polygamy is a controversial subject regarding the violation of religious rights (Bala, 2009). Communities that practice polygamy, challenge its

The Sale of Indian Textiles in Canada

6091 words - 24 pages The Sale of Indian Textiles in Canada Canada, with its economic and political stability offers a variety of business opportunities. With such a large population of immigrants, Canada is known for its acceptance of diverse cultures. English and French are Canada's official languages and there are many other languages spoken freely by diverse racial groups on Canadian soil. Many different religions are also practiced freely and peacefully in

The Legalization of Marijuana in Canada

2252 words - 9 pages illegal in Canada in 1923 under the Opium and Drug Act, and since 1997, marijuana has been under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (Decriminalization of Marijuana in Canada, 2003). Under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, Marijuana is a Schedule 2 offense, meaning "cannabis, its preparations, derivatives and similar synthetic preparations" (Greenspan, s.3). This includes cannabis resin, cannabis (marijuana) and any other cannabis related

Similar Essays

Ideas Of The Past In Contemporary Pieces

1027 words - 5 pages It is appropriate to say that the conditions of Blacks in the past have improved since various Black power movements. The twenty first century generation of African Americans continues to be content with the accomplishments’ of our ancestors, instead of becoming more aware of our heritage and culture in order to understand the present. Renée Stout’s art develop from Black movements such as Garveyism and the Pan-Africanism movements that aimed to

Ivy Rowe's Ideas Of The Past In Fair And Tender Ladies

860 words - 3 pages Ivy Rowe's Ideas of the Past in Fair and Tender Ladies In Lee Smith's Fair and Tender Ladies, Ivy Rowe has a constant attachment to her past. This attachment is one of the main themes in the novel. It is one of her main reasons for letter writing and why she does some of the things that she does, because she does not want to lose her grip on her past. Ivy Rowe, in Lee Smith's Fair and Tender Ladies, uses letter writing to keep a hold of

A Critical Study At The Dissemination Of Ideas And Trends Through Tv And Advertising In The Past 20 Years: Do We Define Television Or Is Tv Defining Us?

2421 words - 10 pages Today's world changes at an amazingly fast rate: today's tendencies are tomorrow's past fashions. Just as the world changes so does humanity and its views pertaining entertainment and the development of society. The way our society changes is not only attributed to the change in people's mindset, demographics or time passage, but I believe that it has to do with the message that is propagated through the mediums, especially television and

What Are The Changes That Chinese Immigrants Brought To Canada In The Past Decades

1221 words - 5 pages Introduction In the past few decades, an increasing number of Asian immigrants are moving to Canada. “It is well know that many recent immigrants to Canada choose to live in Canada’s largest cities, in particular, Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal” (McDonald, 2004) They are creating a new Canada which is described as the New Pacific. Among all places of birth for the immigrants who arrive Canada in the recent years, the People Republic of China