Comparing The Role Of Women In Indian Camp And Shiloh

1563 words - 6 pages

Role of Women in Indian Camp and Shiloh  

    The women of "Indian Camp" experience a life much different from the woman in "Shiloh." Ernest Hemingway wrote "Indian Camp" giving the women a definite role in their families while Bobbi Ann Mason wrote "Shiloh" leaving the woman’s definite family role ambiguous. Because they are responsible for the birth of the babies, the Native American women of the preceding story are the nurturers as opposed to the men. The women accept their roles and partake in their duties without any protest. On the other hand, Norma Jean’s role is not as traditional compared to the other women’s since she and Leroy have no children, she basically lives alone, and she maintains a job. While the Native American women and Norma Jean live different lives, they share the same problem of enduring the men’s ignorance to their needs. However, as the story progresses, Norma Jean realizes she wants to move on in her life, so she does not accept her situation. The Native American women continue their lifestyle not because they choose to be submissive, but because they know no other way. The women of the two stories lead totally different lives in that the Native American women accept their situation, assume submissive behavior, and endure the ignorance of men, while Norma Jean does not accept her situation, assumes assertive behavior, and does not put up with the ignorance of her husband.

Not being exposed to Norma Jean’s independent way of life, the Native American women accept their lives of nurturing and care taking. The doctor’s visit to the Indian camp shows only women helping with the delivery of the baby. As they help the doctor, the men sit up the road away from all the commotion. No signs of resentment towards the unhelpful men can be detected in the women. Additionally, the doctor fails to bring the proper operating supplies in his tackle box, but nobody seems to mind except for the doctor’s son: "Oh, Daddy, can’t you give her something to make her stop screaming?" (16). The doctor responds by saying, "No. I haven’t any anesthetic. But her screams are not important" (16). Everyone in the room knows she feels intense pain, but only the little boy requests relief of her pain. The women must be used to births without pain relief because of the way they live or else one of them would have questioned the doctor’s operation. The birth is clearly a woman’s responsibility and a woman’s own experience in the camp because if it were not, the men would be helping or at least ready to give their congratulations. Like the Native American women, Norma Jean seems complacent with her duties of cooking and cleaning for Leroy. However, she cannot hide her true feelings for long. Until now, Leroy has been on the road and away from their home for fifteen years, and she feels awkward having him around. While he has devoted his life to truck driving and nothing else, Norma Jean seeks a better life for herself. For example, she...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Role of Women in Indian Camp and Shiloh

Comparing the Treatment of Prisoners of War in the Andersonville and the Rock Island Prison Camp during the Civil War

2215 words - 9 pages , respectively. The conditions of each camp will be examined and compared using factors such as nutrition, living arrangements, habits of camp leaders, and death rates. The main source used in this investigation is Life and Death in Civil War Prisons by J. Michael Martinez. Through interpretation and evaluation of several books, primary sources, and court cases, the treatment of Confederate prisoners and Union prisoners will be compared. B. Summary

Cultural and Racial Inequality in Hemingway's Indian Camp

574 words - 2 pages Cultural and Racial Inequality in Hemingway's Indian Camp Hemingway's "Indian Camp" concerns Nick Adams' journey into the unknown to ultimately experience and witness the full cycle of birth and death. Although Nick's experience is a major theme in the story, cultural inequality also is an issue that adds to the the story's narrative range. Throughout this short story, there are many examples of racial domination between Nick's family and

Analysis of Nick’s Father in Ernest Hemingway's Indian Camp

722 words - 3 pages Indian Camp Analysis of Nick’s Father   	In Earnest Hemmingway’s story Indian Camp, from his first book In Our Time, there is a character named Henry refereed to in this story as Nick’s father. Nick’s father is a doctor. A closer look at Nick’s father reveals that he is quite a paradoxical figure. 	On one hand, Nick’s father appears to be a great father who is nurturing caring and wants only the best for his son

The Role and Status of Women in Buddhism and Confucianism

1292 words - 5 pages The role and status of women in any religion in the word is known to be controversial. In Buddhism and Confucianism, women are seen as unequal and some of their belief promotes gender inequality. As outsiders of both main Chinese religions, we wonder how women put up with the gender inequalities. Women go through with the inequalities because they respect their faith and believe deeply in the teachings of Buddha for Buddhism, and

The Role of Men and Women in the Odyssey

1430 words - 6 pages . Interestingly enough, despite how valiant he can be during battle, it is in the Odyssey in which it becomes clear how Odysseus can be seduced and enchanted by women. In the Odyssey, myriad examples of such temptation reflect the importance of gender and the role of women. His specific interactions make this clear, creating an interesting duality between the power of men and women as illustrated throughout the poem. Women are portrayed as seductresses

The Battle of Shiloh

1795 words - 7 pages The Battle of Shiloh was an extraordinary event in the civil war timeline and would be a great deal as to when the war was fought at its hardest. The sources I have researched and collected will help me better understand this battle and many other facts I have yet to discover. The Battle of Shiloh is not the most well known battle during the Civil war, but it gives us an idea on how gruesome the fighting was during this time. I view this battle

The Role of Women and Marriage in Socrates' The Republic

1114 words - 4 pages In his constant quest to find the true meaning of justice and the creation of the ideal city Socrates finds that while many of the element of the city have been properly set forth he forgot to take into account the place women will have in the city and the idea of child-rearing. After some careful discussion about the nature of women and how it would relate to their particular role in the city Socrates and Adeimantus come to the agreement that

Athena, and the Role of Women in the Odyssey

1875 words - 8 pages Homer's great epic, "The Odyssey" was written several thousands of years ago, a time in human history when men played the dominant role in society. The entire structure of civilization was organized and controlled by men; It was an accepted fact that women held an inferior position in society. Society was constructed as if women were around only to serve the men. The involvement of women in any circumstance was almost completely dominated by

The Past and Present Views on the Status of Women in Indian Society

620 words - 2 pages Introduction In India, past and present, the status and freedom that are held by women has and is in a constant decline due to both external and cultural factors that not only causes large panic, but defensive reactions that negatively affect and hinder the women in their culture. Many studies conducted, have shown that the influence of other cultures and religions have made an impression on the ideas of Indian men that have resulted in

The Role of Women in Western Europe and Japan

1157 words - 5 pages . Women in Japan were less successful politically compared to those in Western Europe. There were a couple of women able to take the role of empress, Empress Koken being the last. In the late 700's, Koken was the last female emperor and was able to move the capital. Women never could rule Japan after the incident with Empress Koken in which one monk tried to achieve much political power by marrying into the royal family. Women trying to rule the

The Role of Women and Community in Christianity Versus Islam

1563 words - 6 pages reason why I chose to take World Religion. I thought it was important to learn and understand the beliefs of other religions so that I could better understand the issues affecting our society today. But that is easier said than done. It is hard to separate the actual religion from the outside influences and people using religion for their own purpose. In this essay I will focus on some of the ethical differences of these two cultures; the role of

Similar Essays

Comparing The Role Of Women In Emma And Jane Eyre

1561 words - 6 pages       Throughout history women have played important roles in society. Women have gone through much adversity to get where they are today.  Jane Austen and Charlotte Brontë are some the pioneers of women's literature. Each shows their different aspects of a women's role in society in their books Emma by Austen and Jane Eyre by Brontë.  In both of these books the author shows how

Comparing The Role Of Women In Beowulf And Sir Gawain And The Green Knight

1322 words - 5 pages also, unable to speak, and is incapable of being effective and defeating Beowulf in a male-dominated society. Contradictory to Beowulf, in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, women play a vital role in this plot. However, these women are neither heroic nor independent. Rather, they are deceitful, lack morals, and are depicted as sexual objects. One woman in particular is Bertilak's wife. Her task is to seduce Gawain on a daily basis

Comparing The Role Of Women In Their Eyes Were Watching God And Go Tell It On The Mountain

2155 words - 9 pages Role of Women in Their Eyes Were Watching God and Go Tell It On the Mountain Literature is a reflection of the community from which it comes. Understanding the role of women in the African-American community starts by examining the roles of women in African-American literature. The portrayal of women in Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937) and James Baldwin's Go Tell it on the Mountain (1952) provides tremendous

"Importance Of The Sioux Women In The Sioux Camp"

676 words - 3 pages and cook it. But on the other hand the men can not cook food take care of the babies hunt for crops or vegetables and sew. So I have come to the conclusion that women are more important than the men in the life of the Indian camp, and I don't care what the books or teachers say!