Child Witnesses Essay

1110 words - 4 pages

Child witnesses have provided a basis for controversy over the years in criminal justice. There are two main things that people worry about when it comes to having a child witness, one is the anxiety that is put on the child with regard to the traumatic experience and the other is dependability of the testimony. Child testimony has long been considered an important part of the case but what is to be done when there are questions regarding legal, ethical, and professional ways to interact with the children.
Legal, ethical, and professional considerations all tie into each other when it comes to children. The first part of a criminal investigation before the court case would be the line ups and interviews. Line ups can be difficult for adults to do correctly especially when they do not really know the person, now put a traumatized child into the same situation. The child already has less of a memory than an adult, that encompassed with trauma may lead to inaccuracies with the line ups, particularly if someone looks close to the suspect but the actual suspect is not in the lineup. This part is not as crucial as the police may understand an incorrect suspect picked out if they look similar to the actual respondent. The second part of the investigation, which is much more vital, is the interview.
The interview can have many difficulties and can lead to children placing fallacious charges onto a person, depending on how the interview is performed. Some of the problems with the interviews are leading questions, and interaction between an interviewer and the child. An interviewer can actually cause a child to become confused in the way they remember things if they do not ask questions in an appropriate way. The interview brings in the issue of ethics and professional performance as well. If an interviewer believes that the particular suspect may have committed certain offenses against a child it may cause them to ask leading questions. If the officer or interviewer puts their own beliefs into the questioning it is unethical and unprofessional. An interviewer should be trained to ask open ended, point blank questions where they do not put in an opinion of their own. If proper training is done then the questions asked are more likely to illicit an appropriate response. Due to improper and unethical questioning/interviewing the question of reliability of children witnesses has been discussed. Once a child witness is believed to have experienced or witnessed a situation in which a particular subject is charged they then have to go into court.
In the case of child witnesses in court many distinctive situations occur depending on the type of case, however, all cases have some things in common. One thing in particular that the court cases have in common is that they have the potential to cause severe stress and trauma to the child that is testifying. Some children become so afraid that they do not want to testify. The courts have...

Find Another Essay On Child Witnesses

The Forensic Interview Process in the Case of Abused Children or Children Who Have Witnessed a Violent Act

1836 words - 8 pages 26, 2014, from http://www.michigan.gov/documents/dhs/DHS-PUB-0779_211637_7.pdf United States. Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.,. (2002). Interviewing child witnesses and victims of sexual abuse. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Dept. of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

Instilling a Child's Values. Speaks of parenting

537 words - 2 pages to behave, givethem justifiable discipline, and, at the same time, let the child be their own person.As a child is growing up, he spends a very large part of his life with his parents. A childlearns by seeing what his parents do and mimicking it, so a parent's job is very crucial to a child'sacquisition of good morals. A parent must show the child the virtues of good judgement byusing good judgement in their own life. If a child witnesses an

Sexual Abuse Cases in the Courts

1024 words - 4 pages . According to the text, "Child Abuse and Legal Systems," it states that thirty-two states allow child witnesses to testify via closed-circuit television to the court and jury. An example is the Code of Virginia, which allows child victims in criminal proceedings to testify from a room outside the court room via two way closed-circuit television. The closed-circuit testimony is applicable to a child witness who is fourteen years of age or under at

Forensic Evidence Admissibility For or Against in the Bloodsworth v. State Case

2496 words - 10 pages . It was not until the child got home that he told his mother that he was afraid and had picked the wrong person on purpose. The mother waited three weeks before she told the police what her son supposedly had done. (McNamara, 2009) Also of the two adults that supposedly saw him only one was able to pick Bloodsworth out of a line up. The state also used witnesses that knew him, two that reported him saying that he had done something wrong. Thru it

False Memory

596 words - 3 pages proved to be the single most compelling piece of evidence. Witnesses took the stand, one by one, corroborating heinous accounts of unlawful behavior, such as child molestation and sacrificial murders. Case after case, convictions were handed down rendering the defendant guilty. In each case, the conviction was due to the traumatic and detailed testimony of the victims. Unfortunately, the courts were unaware that these precise accounts were

Rights of Victims and Witness within the Military Justice System

2025 words - 8 pages information discussed openly in court-martial proceedings should be considered and weighed in the context of the circumstances surrounding the assault. At a minimum, any administrative or punitive action to be taken against a victim should be delayed until after disposition of the sexual assault allegation.Child witnesses are protected by allowing closed circuit televised testimony where testifying in the presence of the defendant would cause the child

The Salem Court Against Proctor

906 words - 4 pages was headed by biased judges, who were given power through lying witnesses, making for a flawed court to execute John Proctor. The court system itself had many faults, in that it was missing many components of a modern day court. A court today would throw out a case at the mention of a spectral yellow bird attacking the witnesses, but the Salem court fully accepted this as Mary Warren sending her shape out (106). Even if a court accepted spectral

Childrens Testimony

2621 words - 10 pages witnesses in juvenile and criminal proceedings (Ceci & de Bruyn, 1993). Each year hundreds of thousands of children in North America become entangled in the legal system. Often these children testify about the alleged actions of a parent, teacher, baby-sitter, relative or neighbor. And when this happens, the case is often decided on the basis of the relative credibility of the child versus the defendant. Regardless of whether such testimony is

Ted Bundy and Charles Manson

1777 words - 7 pages for them to piece together the type of person they will be. If the child witnesses abuse, they will remember that. If the child witnesses prejudice and racism, they will remember that. If the child witnesses the complete opposite of that, such as acceptance, fairness, and acts of love; they will remember that. From the ages of ten to fifteen, research shows that “early adolescent brain goes through a growth spurt just before puberty and then a

Perspectives of Death

1003 words - 5 pages , shaping their perspectives. In the novel “Snowball, Dragonfly, Jew,” Ben’s child perspective of death is shaped by the stylized, intimate and romantic deaths he witnesses in Hollywood movies. While both Ben’s child and adult perspectives of death are displayed in the novel, the comparison between the two suggests that Ben’s child self has a false reality of death, whereas his experienced, adult self, has a full and rational understanding that

Ethics in Business

2923 words - 12 pages Jehovah's Witnesses v Kings Count. This was a class action suit that sought to enjoin all physicians and hospitals in the state of Washington from administering blood to plaintiffs in the future. Ten children were included in this suit. The court ruled that Prince v Commonwealth of Massachusetts was pertinent and upheld the state of Washington's child neglect regulations that allowed minors to be removed from their parent's care for necessary

Similar Essays

Jehovah's Witnesses Essay

1743 words - 7 pages called them child murderers even though they seek non-blood treatments provided by doctors who offer viable alternative treatments. Jehovah’s Witnesses have won more Supreme Court Cases than any other religious group in the United States. Between 1938 and 1946, the Supreme Court provided rulings on twenty-three separate cases involving the Jehovah’s Witnesses. It is not unreasonable to say that a large measure of the freedoms of religion

Psychologically Vulnerable Group Of People Essay

882 words - 4 pages justifiably applicable to the subject of vulnerable witnesses in the criminal justice system. Lamb (1999) also listed suggestibility as a factor, which is supported by Baxter’s research (1990). Baxter found that high suggestibility and a lack of direct questions leads to bias information provided by child witnesses. This has led to the notion that suggestive questioning during interviews with vulnerable witnesses is considered an inappropriate method of

Half Lifers As Witnesses Essay

1730 words - 7 pages and against him need to be far enough away from him so as not to be invaded. If the witnesses were allowed near him he could easily block their testimony. He may even be able to alter the testimony in his favor; the extent to which he can influence half-lifers is not really known. In Maryland vs. Craig a child witness was able to testify against the accused and was cross-examined on a closed-circuit television. In the case stated above

Child Abuse In Our Society Essay

574 words - 2 pages provide for the childThe people who commit child abuse and want to get help so theycan stop usually can't get help. That is because they are shunnedby their community, or they are afraid of being shunned.There are 3 types of people involved in child abuse:.The VICTIM is the child who suffers the abuse.The ASSAULTER is the person who causes the abuse.The BYSTANDER is the person who witnesses child abuse. Thebystander has two options when witnessing