Buford Vs. United States Essay

863 words - 3 pages

Buford vs. United States


Certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the seventh circuit
No. 99-9073. Argued January 8, 2001--Decided March 20, 2001
TYPE OF CASE. This case has to deal with the certiorari (Latin for “to be informed”) from the United States Court of appeals for the seventh district. This case raises a question of the sentencing laws. What is the standard of review as it applies when a court of appeals reviews a trial court’s Sentencing Guideline determination as to whether an offender’s prior convictions were consolidated, hence “related,” for purposes of sentencing? In particular, should the appeals court review the trial court’s decision deferentially or de novo?
FACTS OF THE CASE The trial court decision at issue focused on one aspect of the United States Sentencing Guidelines' treatment of "career offenders," a category of offender subject to particularly severe punishment. The Guidelines define a "career offender" as an offender with "at least two prior felony convictions" for violent or drug-related crimes. United States Sentencing Commission, Guidelines Manual §4B1.1 (Nov. 2000) (USSG).
Petitioner Buford pleaded guilty to armed bank robbery. At sentencing, the Government conceded that her four prior robbery convictions were related, but did not concede that her prior drug conviction was related to the robberies. The drug crime (possession of, with intent to deliver, cocaine) had taken place about the same time as the fourth robbery, and Buford claimed that the robberies had been motivated by her drug addiction. But the only evidentiary link among the crimes was that the police had discovered the cocaine when searching Buford's house after her arrest for the robberies.
Moreover, no formal order of consolidation had been entered. The State had charged the drug offense in a separate indictment and had assigned a different prosecutor to handle the drug case. A different judge had heard Buford plead guilty to the drug charge in a different hearing held on a different date; two different state prosecutors had appeared before the sentencing court, one discussing drugs, the other discussing the robberies; and the sentencing court had entered two separate judgments. Petitioner Buford pointed out that the State had sent the four robbery cases for sentencing to the very same judge who had heard and accepted her plea of guilty to the drug charge; that the judge had heard arguments about sentencing in all five cases at the same time in a single proceeding; that the judge had issued sentences for all five crimes at the same time.
The Court of Appeals found the "functional consolidation" question a close one, and wrote, "The standard of appellate review may be...

Find Another Essay On Buford vs. United States

United States vs. Japan in Math and Science

858 words - 3 pages Over the years, tests have determined that the United States has not improved in math and science compared to Japan. Both countries have a different approach towards school. This might be the reason why American students are doing so poorly in math and science. American education should be compared to Japanese so that both can learn from each other because even though American scores are down they still have great ways to educate students

Present Day Detention Camps: North Korea Vs. The United States

1144 words - 5 pages Present Day Detention Camps: North Korea Vs. The United States Abstract The purpose of this research was to determine how similar detention facilities run by the U.S. government are to the gulags of North Korea. The research spanned many different media sources from online news articles to reports in scholarly journals to an anthology of memoirs and articles concerning the treatment of prisoners in U.S. detention facilities. Although some

Genetically Modified Organisms: The European Union vs. The United States

4919 words - 20 pages Genetically Modified Organisms: The European Union vs. The United States "By increasing the fertility of the land, it increases its abundance. The improvements of agriculture too introduce many sorts of vegetable foods, which, requiring less land and not more labor than corn, come cheaply to the market." -Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations Book I.XI.n The United States and the European Union

A Search for Truth - United States Healthcare Debate: Government vs. the People

1741 words - 7 pages Paletta PAGE 1 A Search for TruthU.S. Healthcare Debate: Government vs. the PeopleIn 1965 Lyndon B. Johnson amended the Social Security Act to provide American citizens with two health insurance programs: Medicare and Medicaid. Since then the United States' healthcare system has been questionable, unreliable, and immoral. The existence of these programs goes against the very principles this country was founded upon. To this day, forty-five

Watkins vs United States

1534 words - 6 pages Watkins v. United States 354 U.S. 178 In the case of Watkins v. United States, John Thomas Watkins was trying to have his conviction of contempt of Congress overturned due to his belief that the subcommittee’s questions were outside the scope of their investigation. The House of Representatives Committee on Un-American Activities interviewed Watkins on suspicion that he was a card-carrying member of the Communist Party. Watkins was a labor

United States vs. Sokolow

607 words - 2 pages This case was about a guy Andrew Sokolow who was searches and investigated at the Honolulu airport because of his appearance and his activity. He paid for two airline roundtrip tickets in cash from a 20 dollar bill roll, he was wearing a black jumpsuit and gold chains, he traveled under a different name from that on his home phone number and he never checked any of his 4 bags. The person that sold him the tickets reported him to the DEA saying

Supreme Court cases who's decisions have greatly impacted society. (Veronia vs. Acton (1995), Planned Parenthood vs. Casey (1992), Lee vs. Weisman (1991), and United States vs. Lopez (1995)

1011 words - 4 pages The Supreme Court of the United States is at the apex of the United States judicial system. Ever since its creation, it has affirmed and interpreted the facts within the Constitution. The Court's decisions have greatly affected society. Four major cases which have had cataclysmic effects on society are Veronia vs. Acton (1995), Planned Parenthood vs. Casey (1992), Lee vs. Weisman (1991), and United States vs. Lopez (1995).The case of Veronia vs

Cold War vs. United States

1369 words - 5 pages The Cold War ended in 1991 after the Soviet Union fell apart. Since then, Russia's economy paralyzed, and the United States is three trillion dollars in debt, and both counties were weakened by the Cold War because of military spending. To have world peace does not mean that United States should increase its military strength. The Realist theory would argue that military strength is important to maintain peace both domestically and

" Propaganda vs. Reality" This essay is about political factor that is going on between United States and Iraq. Our reality between Americans, and other reality between strangers

1254 words - 5 pages Kathy Brandon English 28 Staci Ranger Argumentative Analysis 08-21-01 Propaganda vs. Reality For the last couple of years, the United States and Iraq have been unfriendly to each other. It's been difficult to determine who was stating factual evidence, and who was ludicrously attacking to start a war. Its been known that the best and the worst way to get someone's attention, is to manipulate and mislead their views. The precise definition of

United states president vs canadian prime minister

1262 words - 5 pages power but its overuse might degrade not only his position but also that of the entire American political system. However, the President still has power over Congress in that he must put his signature to all legislation before they become law. The same applies to the budget; the President only prepares the budget but its passage rests entirely on Congress. Since the President is the Commander in Chief of the armed forces of the United States, he

United states of America vs Germany

809 words - 4 pages There are a lot of of differences when it comes to comparing two nations together, there is a lot to think about. For example what could we compare? You could compare money intake for each household, you could just compare two nations just using something as simple as culture or maybe race. When comparing Germany to America you still have a lot of differences like the fact that in Germany you are legally allowed to drink and gamble anywhere in

Similar Essays

Somalia Vs United States Essay

1527 words - 6 pages Somalia vs United States Somalia, which is about the size of Texas, is a small country located in Eastern Africa next to the Indian Ocean. The United States, which is located on the Western Hemisphere, is bordered by Mexico and Canada and is between the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. Separated not only by the Atlantic Ocean, Somalia and the United States are also separated by the differences in economies and populations. These two countries

The United States Vs. Mexico Essay

885 words - 4 pages The United States vs. Mexico After an eleven-year war to free itself from Spanish colonial control, Mexico had won but in a sense lost greatly. In 1821, she had to begin the long struggle to rebuild an economic, social, and political stability for the huge mass it now controlled. This area included present day Mexico and what is now known as Texas, New Mexico, Utah, Nevada, Arizona, California and part of Colorado. “The new republic

Russia Vs. The United States Essay

2159 words - 9 pages Russia vs. The United States The United States and Russia have been battling off pernicious factions menacing the stability of their democracies over the years. Russia has come a long way over the past century, enduring a number of different phases that have completely desecrated any power Russia may have had paralleled to the rest of the world. The United States, however, has been evolving into a prosperous world power that has led to new

Business Culture: China Vs. The United States

669 words - 3 pages Business Culture: China vs. the United States      Cultures are varying among different parts of the globe. People with different cultures have different characteristics and viewpoints on the subjects due to diverse understanding and method of learning. During the past few decades, the international trade grows in a very rapid rate due to the advantages that it provides; “increased sales, operational efficiencies, exposure to new