Bilinguals Compared To Monolinguals Essay

1981 words - 8 pages

Overview of subject:
Before knowing whether or not bilingualism is a blessing or a curse, it is important to first investigate the similarities and differences between monolingual and bilingual children. Monolingual children in the United States are native English speakers who speak English at home with their family members and also in the community. Bilingual children in the United States speak a language other than English at home and speak English at school or within the community. Bilingual children may also speak both English and a non-English language at home, depending on their family’s native languages. Children raised bilingually from birth are “simultaneous” bilingual speakers and children who learn their second language after their native tongue are considered “sequential” bilingual children.
If being monolingual helps children learn concepts, vocabulary and speech patterns faster than their bilingual classmates, then its advantageous to be monolingual. However, if being bilingual assists children in these areas and monolinguals fall behind, it is better to be bilingual. Understanding the advantages and disadvantages to both bilingualism and monolingualism can help educators, caregivers and parents understand what they can expect from their children.
Bibliographic Reference:
Axmear, E., Reichele, J., Alamsaputra, M., Kohnert, K., Drager, K., & Sellnow, K. (2005).
Synthesized speech intelligibility in sentences: A comparison of monolingual English- speaking and bilingual children. Language, Speech, & Hearing Services in Schools, 36(3), 244-250.
Summary:
The researchers wanted to compare monolingual and bilingual children listening to synthesized and human speech. Axmear et al. (2005) said that although many adults and adolescents had been compared using synthesized speech software, it was important to examine the intelligibility of this frequently used communication tool among young children (p. 254). More and more children are bilingual learners but not many classrooms are prepared to teach using two or more languages. Synthesized speech software can play an important role in helping teachers communicate with young children. However, if they cannot understand the synthesized sentences, using it is meaningless.
In this study, the children were between the ages of four and six years old. They included 10 monolingual English-speaking and 10 bilingual English/non-English-speaking children. Each child heard 16 different sentences in English, half spoken by a real person’s natural voice and half by Perfect Paul from DECtalk, a synthesized speech software. Each child was asked to repeat the sentences they heard.
Bilingual children had lower accuracy when repeating sentences they heard from both the natural and synthesized voices when compared to monolingual children. However, both groups had lower accuracy when repeating sentences they heard from the synthesized voice. The monolinguals had a 15%...

Find Another Essay On Bilinguals Compared to Monolinguals

Cognitive Effects of Early Bilingualism Essay

2500 words - 10 pages representations of words that would have been more difficult for younger test subjects to work with. For example, a study done by Ton Dijkstra, Professor of Psycholinguistics and Multilingualism at the Donders Institute, which focused only on adult English/Dutch bilinguals--the youngest being fifteen years old, all of whom studied their L2 in a middle or high school level. This study included only written examples of words and had the subjects determine

Research Paper

999 words - 4 pages monolinguals. They have increased intellectual growth and their mental development is attained quicker than that of monolinguals. (Marian et al.). Researchers have completed innumerable studies exploring how bilingualism relates to the different systems of the brain. In 1986, Bialystok did a study on Finnish immigrants attending college in Sweden. The study compared the students academic abilities to their Finnish dexterity. The tests were those of

Experimental Psychology

1726 words - 7 pages pseudo words and also to provide the correct spelling of these pseudowords. This experiment provided numerous results. The bilingual group was significantly more accurate with naming the correct pseudowords with their definitions having a success rate of 70.4% as compared with 58.9% and 50.3% for the Russian-Hebrew monoliterates and the Hebrew-speaking monolinguals respectively. The results also showed that the Russian-Hebrew monoliterates and

Bilingual Education in the School Systems of the United States

1400 words - 6 pages . Denser gray matter has been associated with increased intellect. Bilingual children have also been known to internalize negative states such as anxiety, loneliness, and poor self-esteem less often. They also externalize emotions such as anger, aggression, and arguing less frequently than children who are monolingual. Bilinguals also cope with change with more ease than monolinguals. Knowing a second language also allows a child to understand and

Tip of the Tongue Essay

1760 words - 8 pages occurs in a pattern or has less information to be retained than other features of a word . TOT experiences occur across speakers of all ages, both genders, cultures, levels of education including the illiterate, monolinguals, bilinguals and multilinguals and languages including signers and speakers of unwritten languages. There are 45 of 51 languages known to have an expression for TOT situations which metaphorically reflect that the TOT

How to Give American Students a Billingual Education

1426 words - 6 pages longer and with fewer mistakes than monolinguals (Kluger). This signifies bilinguals’ better flexibility, when answering rapidly, and decision making, when answering correctly. The neurological benefits translates into a more well-prepared student to face the world.

Educational and Social Advantages of bilingual children

1533 words - 6 pages ability can be demonstrated in the classroom. In the instance of Spanish-English bilinguals who are learning new words in English that are similar in Spanish. Consider a third grade class learning the word "wonderful", "wonderful" is a German-derived word "wundervoll" therefore new to both bilingual and monolingual students. However, now consider the word "marvelous" being introduced, "marvelous" is very similar to "maravilloso", which is a Spanish

why French Regional Languages should be taught in schools

1612 words - 6 pages taught in French Schools is Firstly, Bilingualism "As an Intellectual Asset" In fact, there is ample research to show that bilingualism gives children social, linguistic and cognitive advantages over their peers. Bilingual children out-perform their monolingual peers in study after study. Research has shown that the advantages last well into old age. Elderly bilinguals perform as well as younger monolinguals. In other words, Bilingualism is kind of

American Global Illiteracy

1282 words - 6 pages . The United States Census indicates that approximately 20% of Americans speak a language other than English at home, which is the number used to estimate the number of bilinguals in the country (Erard, 2). Michael Erard of the New York Times suggests that this is not an accurate representation. He believes that the employers who pick up enough Spanish to direct workers and retail employees who know enough vocabulary to do their job should also be

Bilingualism For Tomorrow

1119 words - 4 pages higher scores on the ACT exams in English and math regardless of their ability level" (FL 1). Other research suggests that students who receive second language instruction are more creative and better at solving complex problems. Bilinguals also have outperformed monolinguals on both verbal and nonverbal test of intelligence (Marcos 1).Increasing the number of languages Americans speak would be an asset to the United States and the world. Often

The Cuban Presence: Miami’s Trump Card

1182 words - 5 pages their bilingual and monolingual participants based on age, sex, and their socioeconomic status. Peal and Lambert’s studies showed that bilinguals outperformed monolinguals in verbal and non-verbal tests and proved that bilingualism promotes mental flexibility and cognitive abilities (Rumbaut 241). Aside from the transition into a bilingual culture and an increase in diversity, the Cuban presence has had significant economic effects. Trading and

Similar Essays

The Effect Of Bilingualism On The Working Memory

1662 words - 7 pages block test which showed that there was no difference on tasks between adult monolingual and adult bilingual. Hutchison (2008) conducted a study and she used some tasks to compare between English monolingual children and German-English bilingual. Fifty-six children could complete the tasks of working memory. So, she suggested that there was no difference in performance between monolinguals and bilinguals. ‘Working memory in

Link Between Verbal Fluency And Phonological Short Term Memory In Simultaneous Bilinguals And Monolinguals

2242 words - 9 pages bilingual is the reduced exposure to each language. Studies show that both sequential and simultaneous bilinguals score lower on vocabulary measures than monolinguals (Rosselli et al., 200 as cited in Kaushankaya, Blumenfeld and Marian, 2011). Strong evidence for weakened vocabulary performance in bilinguals comes from research with children while the evidence brought from research on adults is considered less reliable. However, as it’s been

French Classes Should Be Mandatory For Canadian Students

1811 words - 7 pages (Marian, et al.,1). Their divergent thinking helps relevant aspects of a problem may become more salient to bilingual children since their experiences with two language systems and cultures enable them to incorporate different perspectives to the solution (Bialystok, 2001 pg. 204). Bilingualism promotes divergent thinking that is caused by greater cognitive flexibility. Bilinguals have greater cognitive flexibility compared to monolingual children

Language Processing In The Bilingual Brain

2344 words - 10 pages Introduction With the rapid development of globalization, international business, and education in the last century, bilingualism has become a necessary skill in enabling communication across national borders and overcoming cultural differences. This social phenomenon has caused bilingual education to expand rapidly, and according to the Hanen Centre, the number of bilinguals today is equivalent to those of monolinguals. However, this leads to a