Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1248 words - 5 pages

The United States is a nation founded on freedoms and liberties, giving each citizen the ability to make their own life decisions. This freedom includes all aspects of one’s life, including medical care. With freedom comes responsibility, and this is true in terms of physician-assisted suicide. The ongoing struggle between those in favor and those opposed to this subject has ravaged the medical field, bringing into question what is morally and ethically right. The fact of the matter is that physician-assisted suicide is neither morally nor ethically acceptable under any circumstance. Not only is it a direct violation of a doctor’s Hippocratic Oath, but it is not constitutionally binding. Physician-assisted suicide would also lead to unnecessary deaths in order to alleviate some of the health care costs. Patients in United States deserve to be treated with the utmost respect, and approving assisted suicide degrades the reputation of American medicine.
The definition of physician-assisted suicide, according to the American Medical Association, is “when a physician facilitates a patient’s death by providing the necessary means and/or information to enable the patient to perform the life-ending act” (“Opinion 2.211”). This means that an individual takes their own life with the tools given to them by a doctor. An example of this might include a doctor informing a patient of the lethal dosage of a drug he or she prescribed. A doctor’s job is to aid in the healing of his or her patients, not assisting in their suicide. It is against a doctor’s Hippocratic Oath to partake in such murderous activities.
Upon completion of medical school, future doctors recite the venerated Hippocratic Oath. This oath states that the doctor will not intentionally harm their patients. “I will not give a lethal drug to anyone if I am asked, nor will I advise such a plan…” is stated directly in the sacred Oath (“Greek Medicine”). This line directly refutes the idea of a doctor assisting in the suicide of another living being. By promoting physician-assisted suicide, doctors invalidate their pledge to be the best healer they possibly can. This, in essence, ruins their credibility and their reputation as a physician. The opposition to this idea states that the no harm claim within the Hippocratic Oath allows for a doctor to end a patient’s life if they are suffering. They claim that it is more harmful to the patient to suffer the pain and agony of a terminal illness than for doctors to assist in the death of their patient (Humphry). The problem lies with the definition of no harm. Hippocrates intended for doctors to heal their patients, not kill them. The Hippocratic Oath is clear when it states that no lethal drugs or other methods of assisted suicide should be practiced (“Greek Medicine”). Ignoring these principles goes against the Hippocratic Oath, degrading a doctor’s credibility and character. Not only does physician-assisted suicide discredit a doctor, but it is...

Find Another Essay On Arguments against Physician-assisted suicide

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1424 words - 6 pages provided, it is in society’s best interest that physician assisted suicide remain illegal. Physician assisted suicide should not be legalized because suicidal people experience distorted judgments resulting in not being mentally equipped to make such a decision, people who feel they are a burden to their family may choose death as a result, and physicians should not have to go against their personal doctrines and promises. One reason physician

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

624 words - 2 pages authorize death. How will a patient feel when his physician recommends physician-assisted suicide as a treatment option? Sometimes, miracle recoveries occur. Ending a life by physician-assisted suicide would not give the patient or the family the chance to see what was in the future.Many religions are against suicide and the intentional killing of others believing in the commandment "thou shalt not kill." The definition of kill in this commandment

Physician Assisted Suicide

1982 words - 8 pages Assisted Suicide is against the common good. There are many reasons the Catholic Church opposes Physician Assisted Suicide, and they can be summarized into one vital statement; Physician Assisted Suicide, purposely killing another human being, is unethical and morally wrong.The Catholic Church's position on Physician Assisted Suicide will never change. However, the Church does recognize other options to alleviate suffering. In Search of the Good

Physician Assisted Suicide

800 words - 3 pages of choice. The right to be able to choose how you die. Those who choose physician-assisted suicide have more than one different form of physician-assisted suicide, but they all end in suicide. Ed Newman states that there are four arguments for legalizing physician-assisted suicide. The Mercy Argument, which states that the immense pain and indignity of prolonged suffering cannot be ignored. We are being inhumane to force people to

Physician Assisted Suicide - 2091 words

2091 words - 9 pages with a terminal disease. Therefore, we should protect the rights of individuals afflicted by these disorders. Performing a physician assisted suicide is an act of great kindness, not murder as those against it would have one believe. It is compassionate to end people's suffering, especially when they have nothing to live for. When a patient is untreatable and in agony, then the only options is to treat the symptoms and make the patient more

Physician Assisted Suicide - 1295 words

1295 words - 5 pages Assisted Suicide Physician assisted suicide, also known as right to die has become a hot button issue within the last twenty years. The reason behind the interest is because in the “land of the free” known as America, that promotes independence and personal rights; it seems quite regressive to many to deny a person their right to die. After the 1997 Supreme Court decision which declined to nationally recognize assisted suicide, Chief Justice

Physician Assisted Suicide - 2214 words

2214 words - 9 pages pain they had. When given pain medicine or applied most people change their minds about committing suicide (American Medical Association). Most people who wish to kill themselves is cause by depression or psychiatric disease. When people feel the need to do such a traumatic decision they are caught up by feeling and fear. Arguments in favor of physician-assisted suicide: it protects people who do not want to suffer lingering painful deaths, it is

Physician Assisted Suicide - 1108 words

1108 words - 4 pages The practice of assisted suicide is not a modern phenomenon. In ancient Greece, the government gave hemlock to those who wanted it. William Shakespeare memorialized the Roman practice in Julius Caesar by depicting Brutus running into the sword held by Strato (Egendorf). While physician assisted suicide is not a new concept the moral debate surrounding euthanasia in America has certainly been brought to the forefront in the last thirty years with

Physician Assisted Suicide

986 words - 4 pages Is Physician-Assisted Suicide A Solution ?       Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is a very important issue. It is also important tounderstand the terms and distinction between the varying degrees to which a person can be involved in hastening the death of a terminally ill individual. Euthanasia, a word that is often associated with physician assisted suicide, means the act or practice of killing for reasons of mercy

Physician Assisted Suicide - 641 words

641 words - 3 pages ‘incurable’. Pulling into the hospital parting lot, you began to slide out of your car and notice he had been waiting in the lobby to take you into the family conference room, where you knew that every serious situation was discussed. Your mother’s doctor told you about your mothers questioning in physician-assisted suicide. If this was your situation, would you encourage your mother to go through with the physician-assisted suicide, otherwise know as

Physician Assisted Suicide

2322 words - 10 pages that death with dignity imposes a negative message stating that disabled life is not worth living, however as Cormack (2000) states, “the same criticism can be leveled against the practice of withdrawing and withholding of life sustaining treatment” (p. 619). This argument supports that physician assisted suicide should not be illegal, if withdrawing treatment that results in death is legal. A patient deciding to end their life by assisted suicide

Similar Essays

Argument Against Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1354 words - 5 pages Physician assisted suicide should not be legalised. Assisted suicide is no better than suicide, in fact it is even worse: how can physicians, who have made oaths to promote life and health, even consider helping a patient to die? Doctors must live by the Hippocratic Oath; this goes against what a doctor stands for and is just murder. It is wrong to kill someone else even if they ask to be killed - even if the death is painless. In a state of

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 1798 Words

1798 words - 8 pages are many arguments that are for the prohibition of PAS. One that seems to be the more obvious one is that of health care providers. The medical community is very outspoken on this topic; it goes against the role of health care providers as healers. A health care provider’s primary concern is to first cause no harm (Kopelman, L. M., & Allen, K. D. 2001, p. 203). Physician assisted suicide obliterates the confidence one should have between their

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 2568 Words

2568 words - 10 pages with some dignity. In this case study, “sixty percent [of physicians] agreed that physician assisted suicide should be legal for certain circumstances” (Gupta 4). People outside of the medical field propose that taking a life, even for valid reasons is still wrong. For most Americans, the argument against physician assisted suicide is not only based on the questions of the responsibilities and duties of the medical profession, but on more vague

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2223 words - 9 pages that interfering would not be the right thing to do (40-41). All in all, physician-assisted suicide has become a very controversial issue that today's society must begin to find a resolution for. There are many arguments in favor of and also against the legalization of assisted suicide for those with a terminal illnesses or condition. There were many ideas that made the decision of whether or not assisted suicide should become legalized very