Analyzing Michelle Neely Martinez’s Article “Rewards Given The Right Way”

852 words - 3 pages

Analyzing Michelle Neely Martinez’s article “Rewards Given the Right Way”
Ever dreaded the annual performance review? Once a year companies try to evaluate their workforce with a standard form containing generalities that are supposed to define whether each employee was successful over the previous year. The grading systems, one-way communication, and lack of collaborative effort create a dreaded process for all parties involved. To combat this loathsome process, Michelle Neely Martinez, in her article “Rewards given the right way”, explores a new design for performance appraisals that promotes open conversation regarding company and personal goals, avoids the negative reactions caused by constructive criticism, and creates positive evaluation of employees’ strengths and weaknesses to inspire “development and improvement.” (p. 2)
To encourage open conversation managers have to remove the preconceived notions of their subordinates that the review process is a one-way dialogue. Using grading scales made the employees focus mainly on the marks they were receiving instead of involving themselves in what the marks meant. This caused employees to only argue their stance when there was a lower value assigned to their performance than they expected, thus eliminating productive conversation. Eliminating the grading system and introducing the Socratic Method to foster constructive collaboration between manager and subordinate creates a constructive and positive performance evaluation. The purpose of “broader two-way exchanges” Martinez explains, is “to focus more on development, as well as to initiate more open and honest conversations.” (p. 2)
Upon removing the grading systems and encouraging open dialogue the evaluation meetings could accomplish addressing how employees can improve their skills in line with company values and goals. Discussions regarding the employee’s time management skills, for example, become opportunities to build on positive attributes like completing one task before starting another one. Next they can confer on the necessity to eliminate distractions, and discuss specific examples for improvement, without the fear of a negative grade based on one transgression. This open dialogue promotes constructive criticism from both the reviewer and the reviewee.
The new process outlined by Martinez helps reduce the negative reactions by employees caused by constructive criticism. She states “many managers fear that providing negative feedback will backfire, no matter how constructive.” (p. 3) Huse (1966) found “the more criticism, the more the defensiveness. The more the defensiveness, the less the performance change noted in the subordinate.” (p. 2) By opening the review process into collaboration where employees can freely discuss what they need to improve upon, managers can provide candid feedback on the employees’ shortcomings with minimal fear that the employee will...

Find Another Essay On Analyzing Michelle Neely Martinez’s article “Rewards Given the Right Way”

Do it the Right Way: A Raisin in the Sun

1814 words - 8 pages it after it’s too late, “BOBO. This deal…with Willy. Man- Willy didn’t never show up…I’m sorry Walter. I had my life staked on this deal, too…” (Hansberry 126). Walter had his life and his family’s life staked on that deal, and just like that he lost it all. Because of one person’s betrayal, more than five people’s lives were affected. This is not to say that it is impossible to overcome these problems and change back to the right path. People can

The Way We Lie article by Jennifer Ericsson

1476 words - 6 pages important! Even in this situation it’s not always the best way to go at it, since they trusted you enough to have you responsible for it, and even letting them down could result in your job performance making you not stand out in the job as you would’ve wanted to. When Marc Chernoff mentions in his article “The table will be ready in 5 minutes. – Because it sounds a lot better than 15 minutes, Thank you so much! I just love it! – Because telling

Analysis of the Article: "Reading in a Whole New Way" by Kevin Kelly

1178 words - 5 pages pocketable screens to input their locations, what they eat, how much they weigh, their mood, their sleep pattern and what they see.” This gives Kelly the opportunity to persuade the reader that screens know and watch everything for society already. In conclusion, Kelly does a great job of connecting with the readers in the use of rhetoric. He makes his point that digital screens have illuminated our lives and has changed the way we read and write. Kelly’s point of view is very clear throughout the article. Kelly uses ethnical appeal, logic, emotional appeal, intonation, and personification to persuade and connect with his audience with his use of rhetoric.

Analyzing Cohesion of the Article Papua New Guinea: A Trek to the Village Time Forgot by Kevin Rushby

2492 words - 10 pages The following is an analysis of the cohesiveness of the given text. However, in order to analyze a text, it first needs to be established what text is. Halliday and Hasan give the following definition: “The word text is used in linguistics to refer to any passage, spoken or written, of whatever length, that does form a unified whole” (Halliday and Hasan, p. 1). This unification is established by relation, forming “a unit […] of meaning

Is Random Testing the Right Way to Combat Drug Abuse by Athletes?

772 words - 3 pages substance abuse." In other words, both writers agree and state clear points that some type of action must take place to solve the problem of drug abuse.What should be done to resolve this issue? That is where the disagreements between the writers take place. Fralic considers random testing as being the right way to combat drug abuse by athletes. "I believe drug use is rampant," says Fralic. He believes that it is unfair to the other athletes and

This article expresses the differences and simularities of the way truman and eisenhowercarried out the containment policy

1996 words - 8 pages and Asia, in effect, to help those countries help themselves. He saw economic stability as essential for peace and stability in the intentional arena. Moreover, he saw giving aid to these countries as a way to subtly influence the ideology of their constituents. Furthermore, Truman accepted ongoing government economic intervention as an appropriate way to direct resources within the economy. Eisenhower, on the other hand, was more interested in a

How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?

1816 words - 7 pages How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?Article 12 states 'Men and women of marriageable age have the right to marry and found a family, according to the national laws governing the existence of this right'. The European Court held that there is no one European-wide view of what marriage is and so each country is given a margin of

Running a profitable Intranet is a continual challenge, and finding the right business model is not always easy. This article will talk about TASKManage for the Retail Industry

6923 words - 28 pages inventory management or specialized consulting to other organizations electronically. Geographic and physical barriers that once hampered growth disappear.Giving to getSelling razor blades to people you've given razors to is a common tactic today. Companies give away phones in exchange for a cellular service contract, personal computers for an Internet services commitment -- even free Internet service for the right to monitor Web habits. Regardless

Feeling Right in the Wrong Way

1136 words - 5 pages leaning against the column she had just leant. “Do I amuse you, Mr. Lucas?” She looked away from him and expected him to be flabbergasted. “Do I attract you, Miss Reese?” Unexpectedly, her head snapped towards his way and shot daggers at him. A faint blush crept to her pale cheeks as she tried to hide them. His crooked smile reached to his eye while gracefully striding over to her side, his height towering over her. She never liked being towered by

Alfred Kazin's Summer: The Way to Highland Park. Personal opinion given

844 words - 3 pages - -There are two main reasons why I have chosen Summer: The Way to Highland Park as my essay. My first reason is I love the city. In the city there is an essence of the past, marred by the shameful present. Kazin captures this feeling of the city to the point you can almost smell the city. His scents and sights bring this story to life. This brings me to the other reason I chose this story. I find Alfred Kazin's view of the world as refreshing

His eaasy talk about the article "How Boys Become Men," by Jon Katz. I agree boys are forced to hide their emotions and men will act the same way as women if we treat them the same

806 words - 3 pages In the article "How Boys Become Men," Jon Katz gives us some examples to explain why men grow up to be insensitive. Katz points out that boy are supposed to learn how to handle things by themselves and hide their weakness and tears. Boys always pressured to be tough and not allowed showing any emotions and fears. Boys' growing up experiences has prepared their adulthoods, all the attitudes and behaviors. I agree with Katz that boys learn from

Similar Essays

"Doing The Right Thing" An Analysis Of The Movie Insider's Influence On Our Society In Response To Sydney Polack's Article "The Way We Are."

2321 words - 9 pages It is not easy to do the right thing. Doing the right thing often involves compromising one's self-interest for others who might not appreciate his/her sacrifice. However, such an action is a benevolent virtue that our society tries to encourage by honoring it and making it memorable to everyone. In addition to a plethora of newspaper and magazine companies, our movie industry is also zealous about presenting stories with such a theme. Many

Analyzing The Right To Education Act, 2009

3172 words - 13 pages primary education. The fundamental purpose of education that is collective and personal freedom is not given a complete scope to develop in the current form of the RTE Act. Conscious effort and thinking has gone into while including education as a fundamental right and not a directive principle but to achieve the social justice that fundamental rights promise a more determined, careful positive action is needed by the society and the state. Otherwise the authenticity of free and compulsory education as a fundamental right will be lost in the political clout.

Troubled Times In The Right Way Supermarket

1113 words - 5 pages Fred Ferrell and Amy Caldwell are both doing what they thing is best for Right-Way Supermarket. They are both neither completely right nor wrong. I do not agree with Mr. Ferrell’s management style but Amy was a little over eager in the way she approached him. Changes and compromises need to be made for things to work out at Right-Way between Amy and Mr. Ferrell. Mr. Ferrell seems to have traditional management style and I’m not sure I would

Survey About Criminal Psycology, Crime And The Way You Would React In A Given Situation

691 words - 3 pages Hey people, the members in this website are really quite clever so I would like to conduct a survey about criminals, using your minds and thoughts. Just to test public opinion. I'm currently studying criminal phycology at my last year at high school. I want to know what you think about the following questions, and to answer them please. Please just write your comment/opinion below. By the way thanks in advance =DQuestion 1-What do you blame in