An Analysis Of The War Powers Act

2296 words - 9 pages

“When war is thrust upon the nation, the President had not only the authority but the responsibility to ‘resist force by force.’” –U.S. Supreme Court ruling of the Prize Cases, 1862 (67 U.S. 6335).

During the past decade of military operations combating terrorism, members of the U.S. government have thoroughly debated the power of the President and the role of Congress during a time of war. A historical review of war powers in America demonstrates the unchecked power of the executive when it comes to military decision-making and the use of force. Throughout history the power of the President to initiate, conduct, and sustain military operations without oversight has greatly increased. Through a historical lens, this essay will analyze: the expanding role and use of power of the President; weak Congressional legislative policies that empower the executive; and the Supreme Court’s role legitimizing the autonomy of Presidential war making.
Beginning with a review of constitutionally assigned roles and the intent of our forefathers, this essay will analyze the history of war powers that propelled Congress to pass the War Powers Act of 1973. Furthermore, this report will evaluate the effectiveness of the War Powers Act and whether it accomplished its purpose. In conclusion, this report provide recommendations to balance power within the three branches of the U.S. government in regards to the nation’s decision making for foreign policy and the use of force.

Background: The Need for the War Powers Act of 1973
Initially, the founders of the country were weary of the abusive nature of a strong executive; therefore, a balance of power amongst three branches of government was established. In regards to war making and the use of military force, Articles I and II clearly assigned the role for the legislative and executive branch. The Constitution gave sole authority to declare war, as well as raise and support an Army and Navy, to the legislative branch. Furthermore, Congress was granted the power of the purse. Modeled after the British Parliament’s control over the King through the control of money, the framers of the constitution created a separation of powers supported by the philosophy of Locke and Montesquieu, oversight through funding. The frames intent for these powers would enable Congress to balance the authority of the President, the Commander in Chief, and submit him to Congressional approval for the use of force.
The authority of the Judiciary—Article III—enables the Supreme Court to rule on all laws and treaties, enabling the branch to oversee and regulate the powers of war. “It is virtually impossible to discuss the national security enterprise without discussing the role of the U.S. Supreme Court.” During the 190 years from the signing of the constitution, to the War Powers Act of 1973, the influence of the Supreme Court greatly enhanced the precedent of executive powers.
Early American history demonstrates an...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of the War Powers Act

War Powers Resolution of 1973 Essay

785 words - 4 pages appoint foreign ambassadors and other ministers, and is allowed to consult with a hand selected group of advisors within the Executive branch on foreign policy issues. These powers are directly subject to Congressional oversight. Article I section 8 of the Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war, raise an army, appropriate funds for military action, ratify treaties, and to confirm Presidential advisors. The War Powers Resolution

An Analysis of the Outbreak of the Iran-Iraq War

1124 words - 5 pages resources • ANALYSIS: • Iraq wanted to become a regional hegemon but wasn't able to due to a lack of sufficient power. It chose to attack a significant actor such as Iran because of its population size, its army, its industrial base, its territorial size was a significant threat to Iraqi hegemony. Additionally, due to the revolution, Iran was considered to be an international pariah and Iraq attempted to use this to its advantage. It chose not

An Analysis of the Outbreak of the Iran-Iraq War

796 words - 4 pages Costing up to $1,000,000,000 monthly and possible over $300,000,000,000 in material terms (Swearingen, 1988) over the course of the conflict, the Iran-Iraq War was at face value, an attempt by Iraq to compel Iran to recognize Iraq's territorial rights and to renegotiate the 1975 treaty. Initially, Iraq seemed to have either no clearly formulated strategic goals or had fallen short of them - the first reaction one would have when hearing that

An Analysis of War Poetry

2005 words - 9 pages John McCrae, which dissimilitudes yet intensifies the main message. Whether from a more emotional perspective or from a physical view, war has devastated the prime time of many young men in multitudinous ways. First of all, a sense of sickness and damage of the mind and body of young soldiers are conspicuously shown in “Dulce Et Decorum Est”. For example, this is clarified by the quote “coughing like hags”. A hag is an old women, and coughing

The Powers of Congress

643 words - 3 pages The constitutional powers of Congress are enumerated in Article I. These include the power to appropriate money, authorize borrowing, levy taxes, regulate the currency, regulate interstate commerce, establish lower federal courts, maintain the armed forces, declare war, propose amendments to the Constitution, and (in what is called the "Necessary and Proper Clause" or the "Elastic Clause") "Make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for

Powers of the Constitution

720 words - 3 pages Powers of the Constitution The national and state governments derive their respective powers from the Constitution in several ways. Some powers are explicitly stated while others are not. Understanding the various types of powers can be difficult and this essay is an attempt to clarify them. The Tenth Amendment of the Constitution states, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the

The Powers of Propaganda

603 words - 3 pages animals that an event that happened in the past was different than what really happened. The pigs rely on the animals' lack of self-confidence and bad memories to convince all except the skeptical that the pigs' account of the information is true. Such as, " Do you not remember how . . . Snowball suddenly turned and fled . . ." (56)? In this example, Squealer is convincing the animals that instead of fighting bravely in the battle and using retreating

An Analysis of the Vietnam War, focusing mainly on the American Perception of the war

1460 words - 6 pages clearly that the Americans are never the "bad guys". It is always the brave American soldiers who is either "fighting the Communist evil" or trying to save his ass, in attempt to annihilate the "Charlie". Such films do not portray the reality of the American colonial greed that ravaged a country, killed many, and then placed an economic sanction against the starving people. American soldiers are never portrayed as the "bad guys", but in reality (most often, without them knowing) they were. We have learned today that those "Hippies" that protested the war and that were not given much credit, were in actuality the ones with the most sense.

The Powers of the Government

1388 words - 6 pages The Powers of the Government PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 7 AbstractShortly after the Revolutionary War in 1787, our founding fathers met in Philadelphia to draft the Constitution of the United States. They came to the table with a few ideas in mind on how the new government should be ran. Prior to the Constitution, the government was established under the Articles of Confederate but that proved to be a weak system. It was their goal to establish a

The Powers of the Government

1388 words - 6 pages The Powers of the Government PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 7 AbstractShortly after the Revolutionary War in 1787, our founding fathers met in Philadelphia to draft the Constitution of the United States. They came to the table with a few ideas in mind on how the new government should be ran. Prior to the Constitution, the government was established under the Articles of Confederate but that proved to be a weak system. It was their goal to establish a

What narrative techniques does Powers use to emphasise the power of war in 'Yellow Birds'?

1098 words - 5 pages Powers uses an array of narrative techniques such as imagery, personification, alliteration and varying sentence structure to emphasize the power of war from the first sentence on page three to "We stayed awake on amphetamines and fear," on page five. Powers personifies war throughout the first page and extends it to the next, this is an example of a semantic field. For instance "the war rubbed its thousand ribs against the ground in prayer

Similar Essays

The War Powers Act Essay

1294 words - 5 pages The War Powers Act The farmers of our Constitution recognized the need for separate powers as well as checks and balances among the executive, legislative and judicial branches. This in turn helps to "provide for the common defense". Separation of powers prevents one branch from becoming excessively dominant over the United States, in order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the

Freedom Or Security? An Analysis Of The War Measures Act, 1970

929 words - 4 pages " Just watch me," was uttered by Pierre Trudeau on October, 13, 1970, in response to how far he would go to keep order during the October Crisis. Three days after Trudeau made this statement, he imposed the War Measures Act in an attempt to prevent a nationalist terrorist group, called the Front de liberation du Quebec (FLQ), from continuing with their violent revolutionary crimes. The implementation of the War Measures Act was strongly

An Analysis Of The American Recovery And Reinvestement Act 2009

2818 words - 12 pages During an economic uncertainly the government has to make decisions that it believes will help the country in its time of need. In 2009 when the country continued to face dreadful economic circumstances involving jobs and a movement of money. In order to set economic recovery into motion, President Obama called for the passing of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA). This is known as the stimulus bill. This bill was very

World War 2: The Demise Of The Axis Powers

1121 words - 5 pages Around 1939 to 1942, the axis powers had a very dominant lead in World War 2. It almost seemed like there would be absolutely no chance of stopping them. As it’s been said, sometimes people with the highest power can make forgetful mistakes that can cost them their seat. But the amazing thing is both Japan and Germany were at their highest point in power by 1942. In just a matter of 3 years, all is lost. So the only main question that still