A Lost Lady: They Could Conquer, But They Could Not Hold

1014 words - 4 pages

In Willa Cather’s A Lost Lady, two types of men are presented to the reader – the old fashioned man who belongs to the Old West, and the new man who is a product of the Industrial Revolution. Niel Herbert and Ivy Peters exemplify these two types of men; by their outlook upon life and by their actions, they are as fundamentally opposed to one another as the Old West was to the Industrial Revolution.
Niel and Ivy’s separate outlooks upon life – that of the Old West versus that of the Industrial Revolution – are as disparate as their appearances. Niel, with his “clear-cut [features, and] his grey eyes, so dark they looked black under his long lashes,” (Cather 33) represents the Old West and all its hopes and dreams, while Ivy with his red skin, harsh dimples like “a knot in a tree-bole,” (21) and his “fixed, unblinking” (21) eyes, is the realist of the next generation. Niel, younger than Ivy by several years, “had believed that man could live according to aesthetic ideals, and this belief is a positive one. However, he had not yet harmonized such ideals with human life” (Rosowski, Willa Cather’s A Lost Lady: The Paradoxes of Change, 59). It is this refreshing – though naïve – belief in the ability of men to rise above petty emotions, and particularly his reverence of Marian Forrester as an archetype of womanly goodness, which is slowly worn away in Niel as the novel progresses. When Niel returns to Sweet Water after his time away at a university, he meets Ivy, and from their brief conversation Niel realizes the difference between himself and Ivy. The men of the Old West, Niel realizes, were “dreamers, great-hearted adventurers who were unpractical to the point of magnificence; a courteous brotherhood, strong in attack but weak in defense, who could conquer but could not hold” (Cather 106). The men of the next generation, the men of the industrial revolution, were their polar opposites: “shrewd young men, trained to petty economies by hard times” (107). Niel, in his unfailing gallantry and old fashioned sensibilities, exemplifies the idealistic outlook of the Old West, just as Ivy, in his crass words and deals made solely for money, exemplifies the new generation of realists.
Another point of differentiation between Niel and Ivy is the separate courses of action they pursue; by the paths they have chosen in life, they again demonstrate the fulfillment of their archetypal opposition. Niel and Ivy “had disliked each other from childhood, blindly, instinctively, recognizing each other as hostile insects do.” (Cather 106) From the very beginning to the very end, they are pitted against one another, in action and in ideal. When Ivy Peters slits the eyes of the woodpecker, Niel is the one who takes action against him, climbing the tree to put the bird out of its misery. When Ivy Peters tramps about the Forrester’s land as though he owns it, draining the marsh and tearing down the barn, Niel is the one who stops to...

Find Another Essay On A Lost Lady: They Could Conquer, But They Could Not Hold

This is a biography of Washington Irving. It is not A+ material, but you cannot always turn in perfect papers. It gives a full description of his life but it is not as vivid and deep as it could be

1110 words - 4 pages Biography of Washington IrvingWASHINGTON IRVING was born in New York, April 3, 1783, and died of heart disease, at Sunnyside, his country-seat on the banks of the Hudson, on November 28, 1859.Both his parents came from Great Britain. His father had intended Washington for the legal profession, but sickness interfered with his studies, and caused him to take a voyage to Europe, proceeding as far as Rome. Returning to the United States, he was

"Mates at War" is written by me and teachers commented on the types of pronouns used and said they could be a little better

2362 words - 9 pages could barley hold Jack but nothing was stopping me no one was taking the only family I have left. As we left about 100 meters away from me they had bombed the tank. I hoped that they think they killed us. We were close to the truck but I observed there were people around and they were definitely not of American soldiers. I couldn't wait any longer they had discovered my means of escape and Jack didn't have long. I saw another plane above I ducked

Drug Abuse In Schools. Parents think the safest place for their school age children is in school, but they could be surprised at the statistics of drug and alcohol abuse

777 words - 3 pages all public, parochial and private schools, since many parents from all walks of like do work, and have less time to spend with their children. I don't think most parents realize that they may not spent enough time with their children talking about issues such as drugs. However, that is not a good reason for parents not to reinforce non-drug use and talk to their children about illegal drug use.It's just that time is so precious in today's society

Because I Could Not Stop for Death

845 words - 4 pages , just not of the sort that one reads about in Twilight novels. Indeed, Dickinson is not referring to temporal perpetuity, but a spiritual eternity. Besides that, earthly pleasures and acts appear to have lost their appeals for the speaker. When she tells of how they “passed the school, where children strove / At recess, in the ring”, notice how the word strove is used in place of the word play, indicating that life is a struggle. Death “kindly

Life Could Not Exist Without Water

635 words - 3 pages Life on earth would not exist without water. Not in any way or form could any planet exist with any life forms whatsoever if not for the common thing we call water. In my home state of Washington, there is a lot of surrounding bodies of water. To the cities and their economies, water is essential and cannot be replaced or removed. There is nothing that can take its place. Though, it can be damaged. Around the big towns the air can become

because i could not stop for death

828 words - 3 pages The poem “Because I Could Not Stop for Death” by Emily Dickinson is an extended metaphor on death, comparing it to a journey with a polite gentleman in a carriage taking the speaker on a ride to eternity. Death and immortality are some of the principal concerns of the poetry of Emily Dickinson. In her poem “Because I could not stop for Death,” she compares dying to a ride in a horse carriage, and enjoys the company of Death. As they travel

Because I could not stop for death

538 words - 2 pages "dead." This "House" is a grave. This is where her body will be housed while her soul journeys onward. She describes the house as a "Swelling of the Ground," an image of a fresh burial plot. She can hardly see the roof, fancy looking molding near the roofline, is only just visible above the pile of earth. She does not describe how long they "paused" there, but it could not have been long. This seems to be

Because I Could Not Stop For Death

597 words - 2 pages Emily Dickinson wrote "Because I Could Not Stop For Death" in 1863. It is a ballad with six stanzas of four lines each, or six quatrains. There is no set rhyme scheme, because each of the lines is enjambled. The meter of the poem alternates after each line between iambic tetrameter and iambic trimester.The theme of Because I Could Not Stop For Death is that human death, while unavoidable, is not as harsh and dreadful as many believe it to be

because i could not stop for death

902 words - 4 pages “Because I could not stop for death,” is a poem written by Emily Elizabeth Dickinson. Dickinson’s style of writing is very different from other poets. She writes down what comes to mind and doesn’t focus her attention on the grammatical errors she has in her poem. She writes in prose, uses many hyphens, and has unconventional punctuations. This, however, is what makes Emily stand out from other poets. Throughout the poem, Dickinson uses free

Because I could not wait for death

784 words - 4 pages There are several themes running through the poem “Because I Could Not Stop for Death”. The main themes focused on are mortality, immortality, spirituality, and love. The first theme noticed in this poem is mortality. The poem shows the narrator’s attitude toward her death, and what the actual day of her death was like. The narrator paints a picture of the day that does not seem too far from the ordinary. The narrator does not seem to be scared

An in depth report of the history of Tesco supermarkets and possible future business strategies they could use

1417 words - 6 pages . Due to its popularity it was able to take advantages of commercial economies of scale such as supplies purchased in bulk. However they could not complete with the prices of other supermarkets because the current trading standards restricted selling below a set price. To combat this problem Tesco developed other ways of keeping customers loyal to the brand, one of these methods was the use of stamps that could be exchanged for cash or goods, sort

Similar Essays

Marijuana Effects Of Marijuana An Dwhat They Could Do

862 words - 3 pages replacing the tobacco with the drug marijuana this is known as a "blunt". Some users who do marijuana now even mix it into their foods like brownies for instance and also brew it into their tea (Stwertka 1986).When the marijuana smoker takes down or inhales the smoke of the drug they also inhale the THC into their lungs. When they inhale it they usually hold the smoke down in their lungs as long as possible usually around seven to ten seconds, the

After Kristallnacht, No German Citizen Could Say They Did Not Know What Would Happen To The Jews

910 words - 4 pages , regardless of conscience, was able to help. As a fireman in Laupheim during Kristallnacht remembers :"Eventually we were allowed to tale the fire engines outs, but only very slowly. We were ordered not to use any water till the whole synagogue was burned down. Many of us did not like to do that, but we had to be careful not to voice our opinions because 'the enemy is listening'."This forced disregard for Jewish property and Jewish citizens was planned by

Could Go To War But Can't Drink

1165 words - 5 pages they are putting up a fight and protecting our country, they should be able to consume alcohol. Young adults who barely look old enough to be legal are fighting for our country and putting their lives at risk everyday. Blood drips down their face as they’re being targeted, their lives are flashing before their eyes. It’s unfair that they are old enough to experience tragedy like that, but are not able to drink a beer or two to help them relax

Evolution Of The Loxodonta Africana And Elephas Maximus And How They Could Lose Their Tusks

1375 words - 6 pages problem in today’s world, not just with elephants. If poaching continues to increase as it has in the past, the elephants may not only lose their tusks, but they may also become extremely endangered or extinct.   Works Cited Cressey, D. 2013. Tusk tracking will tackle illegal trade. Nature 494:411-412. Kalmykov, N.P. and E.N. Mashchenko. 2006. New data on the migration of the family Elephantidae (mammalia, proboscidea) in Eurasia. Doklady